Why would it be pointless to argue about it? Was it also pointless for all draft talk information to exist since everybody was just speculating and nobody really knew for sure? I don't agree with you and I highly doubt they would have traded JJ, they would have wanted him and taken him and you just are lost, just like you were before the draft as well. But that's where you wind up when you think analyzing and debating things is a pointless activity.
It is pointless to argue about because neither one of us has facts. Hypothetical debates are fun if you actually enjoy talking to the person you're debating with. I don't think analyzing and debating things in general is pointless, I think analyzing and debating things like this with you is pointless. And if you think I'm wrong / lost, great, that is your own opinion. But you have no facts, no proof to back it up.








