Will too much muscle mess up your skills?

Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

User avatar
old rem
RealGM
Posts: 50,753
And1: 1,080
Joined: Jun 14, 2005
Location: Witness Protection

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#81 » by old rem » Sun Jul 10, 2011 5:43 pm

Storm Surge wrote:Adding muscle is proven to affect your shot, bit it also affects your speed/quickness and can also lead to more injuries if you become unbalanced (see tmac)

You see what I'm sayin I'm super sayin like Goku


SKILL...happens between the ears. Putting on BULK...even if it's solid, can cost some quickness or agility.
CENSORED... No comment.
Point-God
Banned User
Posts: 2,114
And1: 8
Joined: Jun 01, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#82 » by Point-God » Sun Jul 10, 2011 5:47 pm

KV20 wrote:Am i wrong about that?
In this sport throughout the years we have seen that the players that don't lift weight were the best skilled in basketball.
Does it mean that a player like Dwight Howard will never be a great skilled player even on working harder than anybody?

As far as i can remember, David Robinson and Karl Malone were the only freak of nature that were very skilled as players. But those hall of famers were not as skilled than players like Zach Randolph or Pau Gasol.
This is why i think LeBron james will never be as skilled than Carmelo Anthony. This is why i think Dwight Howard will never be as skilled than All Jefferson. This is why Blake Griffin will never be as skilled than Demarcus Cousin even if he works out much more than him his basketball moves and his jump shot.

Do you think that players like Howard or Griffin lifted too much weights to be one day known as skilled players? Same question for LeBron James.

We will never see a player with the level of skill of Larry Bird and the muscles and athletic abilities of LeBron James.
Is it morphologicaly possible?
If, it isn't, the athletic trainners of Blake Griffin and Dwight Howard should be ashamed.


That's one of the worst posts have ever read. He thinks Pau Gasol is more skilled than the Admiral and that Carmelo is more skilled than Lebron. The Blake Griffin Demarcus Cousin's thing is probably the greatest joke, oh by the way compare their rookie assist numbers. :lol:
bigboi
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,663
And1: 1,383
Joined: Nov 05, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#83 » by bigboi » Sun Jul 10, 2011 6:20 pm

To all my dbz boys, Broly is the strongest one there is, fact. Buu is probably the closest to Broly. Broly only got killed because Goku gets the most retarted powerups
tlee324 wrote:
Lebron made it to the finals with that cleveland team.

Bird would have won 4 rings with that team, in this weak ass era of basketball.
User avatar
gino_giode
Head Coach
Posts: 6,976
And1: 1,505
Joined: Jan 03, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#84 » by gino_giode » Sun Jul 10, 2011 6:32 pm

bigboi wrote:To all my dbz boys, Broly is the strongest one there is, fact. Buu is probably the closest to Broly. Broly only got killed because Goku gets the most retarted powerups


First off F that roid raging Brolly! Buu is a pink POS who sucks off all the strong dudes! And :lol: at the end.
Image
bigboi
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,663
And1: 1,383
Joined: Nov 05, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#85 » by bigboi » Sun Jul 10, 2011 6:34 pm

Spelling error, woops
tlee324 wrote:
Lebron made it to the finals with that cleveland team.

Bird would have won 4 rings with that team, in this weak ass era of basketball.
Point-God
Banned User
Posts: 2,114
And1: 8
Joined: Jun 01, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#86 » by Point-God » Sun Jul 10, 2011 7:17 pm

U-Borat wrote:depends what you mean by skill. carmelo's footwork is a million times better than lebron's ever will be- but i somehow doubt having more muscle and less fat is going to affect that.


Carmelo's footwork is not better than Lebron's. Carmelo is a better shooter than Lebron. Carmelo can be said to be more clutch than Lebron even though Carmelo lead teams haven't been as good. Carmelo and Lebron comparisons are so 2005. Carmelo long ago solidified his place a tier below D Wade and Lebron.
User avatar
JWiLL02
RealGM
Posts: 10,858
And1: 2,443
Joined: Jan 06, 2004
Location: Sprite Zone

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#87 » by JWiLL02 » Sun Jul 10, 2011 7:17 pm

peja_the_legend wrote:I've always thought that Iguodalas huge Popeye-style arms have prevented him from developing a proper jumpshot.I'm also wondering, are there many players build like bodybuilders who are also consistent jump shooters?


Ben Gordon.

Annnnd that's about it.
Image
*Sig courtesy of Raptors' royalty 'Turbozone'. http://www.turbozone.ca"
Hon-essim
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,690
And1: 1
Joined: Feb 07, 2009

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#88 » by Hon-essim » Sun Jul 10, 2011 8:22 pm

bigboi wrote:To all my dbz boys, Broly is the strongest one there is, fact. Buu is probably the closest to Broly. Broly only got killed because Goku gets the most retarted powerups


That's like saying Kobe is probably the closest to Shaq. Oh and Hakeem did not get retarted powerups.
Gerhalt11 wrote:What? He produces better results than he should? Fire that guy!

No coach. No GM. Probably no star. I swear, in my 23 years of following this team, I can't name a stranger time than this moment to be a supporter of the Magic.
User avatar
ManualRam
RealGM
Posts: 23,361
And1: 2,749
Joined: Jun 25, 2004
     

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#89 » by ManualRam » Sun Jul 10, 2011 9:56 pm

Point-God wrote:
U-Borat wrote:depends what you mean by skill. carmelo's footwork is a million times better than lebron's ever will be- but i somehow doubt having more muscle and less fat is going to affect that.


Carmelo's footwork is not better than Lebron's. Carmelo is a better shooter than Lebron. Carmelo can be said to be more clutch than Lebron even though Carmelo lead teams haven't been as good. Carmelo and Lebron comparisons are so 2005. Carmelo long ago solidified his place a tier below D Wade and Lebron.

yeah it is
idontgiveashtaboutmelo
User avatar
Joseph17
RealGM
Posts: 10,430
And1: 529
Joined: Jul 09, 2004
Location: New York
   

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#90 » by Joseph17 » Sun Jul 10, 2011 10:07 pm

It depends on the player's style of play. If the player is a power player like prime Shaq getting as strong as possible is the best option. I don't think looking like Ronnie Coleman would be a good idea for a finesse player that relies on quickness like a Monta Ellis or a Tony Parker. Muscle mass has nothing to do with skill though. I heard that if you go through your shooting drills right after you lift the added muscle mass won't have a negative effect on your shooting.
User avatar
Joseph17
RealGM
Posts: 10,430
And1: 529
Joined: Jul 09, 2004
Location: New York
   

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#91 » by Joseph17 » Sun Jul 10, 2011 10:11 pm

Point-God wrote:
U-Borat wrote:depends what you mean by skill. carmelo's footwork is a million times better than lebron's ever will be- but i somehow doubt having more muscle and less fat is going to affect that.


Carmelo's footwork is not better than Lebron's. Carmelo is a better shooter than Lebron. Carmelo can be said to be more clutch than Lebron even though Carmelo lead teams haven't been as good. Carmelo and Lebron comparisons are so 2005. Carmelo long ago solidified his place a tier below D Wade and Lebron.

Image
RojanRando
Banned User
Posts: 648
And1: 0
Joined: Apr 03, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#92 » by RojanRando » Sun Jul 10, 2011 11:20 pm

Hon-essim wrote:
bigboi wrote:To all my dbz boys, Broly is the strongest one there is, fact. Buu is probably the closest to Broly. Broly only got killed because Goku gets the most retarted powerups


That's like saying Kobe is probably the closest to Shaq. Oh and Hakeem did not get retarted powerups.


Mystic Gohan is the strongest fools
konkeydong
Ballboy
Posts: 24
And1: 4
Joined: Jul 10, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#93 » by konkeydong » Sun Jul 10, 2011 11:22 pm

Hon-essim wrote:These are pros. They don't really build too much anything. Their lifestyle pretty much means unlike trying out USSJ for the first time, these guys actually have an off-season to get used to their new body.

It's more like maybe blind muscle sculpting gets combined with added muscles and sometimes that takes away from skills training. Other times it's the wrong skills and not actually the training part. Other times it's the lack of evolution in their skills.

Dwight and Rose for example are monsters and their weight training know how and regimen probably far surpasses MJ's or Shaq's based on how fast they close the gap in physicality even though they are arguably less gifted players. Yet even with this and their probable superior work ethic, they don't focus on the urgency of the situation and they find themselves in disappointing moments everytime they meet a smart adversary in the playoffs. Dwight doesn't train enough in his confidence so all that muscle becomes over-compensation rather than an additional edge. Rose similarly has an inflated sense of his offensive success in the regular season so all the off season effort is wasted in the post-season when he lets his guard down.

If you want to use a DBZ moment, compare it to how Freeza was bulking up to 100% not some urgent form Trunks has to assume because there wasn't enough of an off-season to test it.

Freeza had tons of success in the regular planets with no legendary SSJ. By far if it weren't for the fillers, he arguably could be the most powerful since there's no proof his father is as strong as him and even if he was - Freeza was far younger. Freeza is the Dwight and Rose and Lebron of the NBA. They are battle tested individuals who can turn it up season after season and scare the rankings for how much dominant they are at such a young age and how much playoff battles they've already gone through in terms of attrition.

However Freeza rarely goes at 100% because he doesn't need to. Going so much as to toy with his prey. Dwight even hinted at this in an interview. Something about training with Olajuwon teaching him the difference between a ninja and a mercenary. For the most part, Freeza is a ninja and while ninjas are cool there's a reason why in reality they are assassins. Their moves are designed to be go to moves and yet Lebron, Dwight and to an extent Rose' go to moves are not varied and optimized enough to really become fall back moves. Instead their secret moves end up becoming predictable power up moves they fall back on.

This is why Freeza not only lost his squad but allowed Goku to reach Namek and become the legendary SSJ. Zaza, Barea, Gasol, Perkins even Lebron when he guarded Rose wasn't aiming to "beat" Dwight/Lebron/Rose. Same way Krillin and Gohan and Vegeta wasn't aiming to beat Freeza.

They were simply aiming to limit Freeza and hoping a miracle would happen. When that miracle happened, Freeza still had a chance. After all he was the one who could go 100%. He was the one with experience dealing with that type of power while Goku had to get used to it on short notice.

However Freeza had the wrong mindset even in his off-season and it finally caught up. Just as Dwight still had his moves, Rose was still a pg with improved playmaking and Lebron as horrible as he was posting up still was someone who could use that silly foul on Barea as an aggressive motivation - their muscular training had reduced the mental aspect of their instincts under pressure even though they aren't as mentally weak. Freeza similarly could have battled against Goku in a war of attrition in which he could probably win but his muscular pride in his super secret ninja move being unbeaten made him forget the difference between a super powered mercenary who is mentally more ready to beat him for a greater cause than his own self deluded value of proving his ninja moves superior. The result was that Freeza ends up losing because he tried to play the superior game of his opponent. A game that even there is close to equal but every frustrated technicals, every failed drives, every humiliating words edged it closer to the mercenary who grew more motivationally stronger as the battle go on where as the muscle guys who hid behind those muscles slowly crumbled and seemingly choked themselves out.

The USSJ failure is much closer to Gasol's failure the first time against Boston. Up to that point in time, the legendary SSJ was already seen as some ultimate unbeatable transformation and that was who Gasol was when he went to LA. Unlike Goku who had faced superior opponents before that nearly killed him while he wasn't a SSJ, Trunks came from a timeline when that transformation was the key. Similarly when Gasol came to LA, it was like he became part of the unspoken NBA champion not just because of the prestige of playing with Kobe but because of the ease the way LA went through almost every team even against the Spurs were Gasol and Kobe simply activated their patented pick and roll and it jarred the normally quick to adapt Spurs.

Then suddenly here comes Cell who were making it tough for the Super Saiyan to perform even on equal terms. Trunks and Gasol had to do something so they tried compensating for who they were and it just hurt the team more. The USSJ may be flawed in that it made the bearer slow but to someone like Trunks who had an exposure to the SSJ transformation as a god send and not just an additional power-up, the USSJ felt like the perfect instinctive back up if the powered up SSJ wasn't enough. And to an extent he's right. USSJ may be slow but SSJ's are darn fast to begin with. Not to mention durable. Under the right opponent who wasn't as mentally cold blooded and hungry as Boston or Cell that would have unnerved them enough in the same way Goku messed up Freeza. I.E. it was a near perfect considering the solution basically meant creating SSJ 2 which at that point had no reference to and Gohan only achieved because of his superior power to Trunks. Unfortunately the solution ended up being a mistake because just like Gasol, Trunks was trying to play a perfect game but although it was perfect, it was still imperfect against the opposing team. Trunks in his attempt to unlock the perfect solution within his body ends up forgetting to look at who his opponent is.

The only comparable element this has to Lebron, is that Lebron might have also tried to play a perfect game and forgot to factor in the way Dallas is and the way Miami is as a roster. That resulted in him becoming more passive. He thought he was being the perfect Pippen to Wade with the triple doubles and the play making and he completely forget that the way Miami was built, they needed Lebron to simply contribute to the team.

The problem with the comparison is that Lebron is on Gohan's level. Even if SSJ2 Gohan went USSJ2, he could have hurt Cell. More importantly, Gohan would realize that at his power level, he needn't go USSJ2 to compensate for the power level since SSJ2 was enough. He just has to get mad.

Instead Gohan does an about face and Wade err... Goku ends up having to bail his ass out there and thankfully the NBA Finals isn't a do or die game but nonetheless Wade ends up injurying himself trying to compensate for Lebron and unfortunately Lebron didn't unleash the beast. Of course the comparison ends there since Dallas is in no way the Perfect Cell of the NBA.

Longtime lurker finally signing up to say: I love you guys.
User avatar
PippenAintEasy
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,469
And1: 6
Joined: Jan 26, 2009

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#94 » by PippenAintEasy » Sun Jul 10, 2011 11:23 pm

So is Dwight Howard a saiman?
From the "Story behind certain jersey numbers" thread...
C'mon Cavs wrote:Larry Hughes wears #32 because he sucks.
RojanRando
Banned User
Posts: 648
And1: 0
Joined: Apr 03, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#95 » by RojanRando » Sun Jul 10, 2011 11:28 pm

PippenAintEasy wrote:So is Dwight Howard a saiman?


Saiyan?
User avatar
pross
Veteran
Posts: 2,753
And1: 174
Joined: Apr 30, 2009

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#96 » by pross » Sun Jul 10, 2011 11:31 pm

I can tell who the asians are from reading this thread.

:o
Image
User avatar
Darain
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,294
And1: 39
Joined: Dec 09, 2010
Location: Florida

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#97 » by Darain » Sun Jul 10, 2011 11:34 pm

pross wrote:I can tell who the asians are from reading this thread.

:o


Lol at thinking only asians watch DBZ
crowd goes wild wrote:Joel Anthony. Dude could probably give you around 27 ppg if he wasn't playing along side Chris Bosh.

I'm not a Kobe fan
nhh90 wrote:Kobe hasn't been doubled in a game since 07-08 season.
User avatar
Sulleigh
Junior
Posts: 280
And1: 5
Joined: Jul 03, 2009
Location: Denton, TX
   

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#98 » by Sulleigh » Mon Jul 11, 2011 12:06 am

pross wrote:I can tell who the asians are from reading this thread.

:o


I'm not asian and I loved DBZ as a kid. I thought everybody did honestly?
Image
User avatar
MrBigShot
RealGM
Posts: 18,700
And1: 20,289
Joined: Dec 18, 2010
 

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#99 » by MrBigShot » Mon Jul 11, 2011 12:13 am

What a great thread...
"They say you miss 100% of the shots you take" - Mike James
Hon-essim
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,690
And1: 1
Joined: Feb 07, 2009

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#100 » by Hon-essim » Mon Jul 11, 2011 12:15 am

RojanRando wrote:
Hon-essim wrote:
bigboi wrote:To all my dbz boys, Broly is the strongest one there is, fact. Buu is probably the closest to Broly. Broly only got killed because Goku gets the most retarted powerups


That's like saying Kobe is probably the closest to Shaq. Oh and Hakeem did not get retarted powerups.


Mystic Gohan is the strongest fools


Pfftt yeah... except Lebron keeps finding a way to screw himself.

Maybe if Lebron didn't bring his talents down to Satan City and trained his ass off, he might have a case.

Instead, Gohan had not 1, not 2, not 3, not 4, not 5, not 6...not 7...wins over a major DBZ boss despite being the strongest. If it weren't for the combined fusion of Wade and Bosh unlocking Lebron's talents, he might not have won a ring next season.
Gerhalt11 wrote:What? He produces better results than he should? Fire that guy!

No coach. No GM. Probably no star. I swear, in my 23 years of following this team, I can't name a stranger time than this moment to be a supporter of the Magic.

Return to The General Board