Will too much muscle mess up your skills?

Moderators: Clav, Domejandro, ken6199, bisme37, Dirk, KingDavid, cupcakesnake, bwgood77, zimpy27, infinite11285

Wades Team
Freshman
Posts: 98
And1: 0
Joined: Jun 13, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#121 » by Wades Team » Mon Jul 11, 2011 3:32 am

dreamcloud wrote:
Wades Team wrote:Hey honest question I'm a junior in high school, i'm 5'11 and pretty scrawny about 140. Should I focus on getting bigger or getting more skilled to play better?


Get bigger and more athletic, seriously. There's a difference between being well built, and too bulky. Being scrawny has no advantages. Eat big and lift heavy, and your entire life will change for the better.

Alright what should my target weight be for a wing player? I was thinking 155-160
User avatar
dreamcloud
Analyst
Posts: 3,047
And1: 464
Joined: Jul 19, 2008
 

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#122 » by dreamcloud » Mon Jul 11, 2011 3:41 am

Wades Team wrote:
dreamcloud wrote:
Wades Team wrote:Hey honest question I'm a junior in high school, i'm 5'11 and pretty scrawny about 140. Should I focus on getting bigger or getting more skilled to play better?


Get bigger and more athletic, seriously. There's a difference between being well built, and too bulky. Being scrawny has no advantages. Eat big and lift heavy, and your entire life will change for the better.

Alright what should my target weight be for a wing player? I was thinking 155-160


I think at that height somewhere between 165-170 at about 10% bf would be ideal for most players, I think your goal should be around 160 at least.. but take it slow, don't want to gain too much too fast
Image
RojanRando
Banned User
Posts: 648
And1: 0
Joined: Apr 03, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#123 » by RojanRando » Mon Jul 11, 2011 3:41 am

Pooh_Jeter wrote:I'm also hoping for a Dragonball GT review. This thread got me motivated to watch DBZ again, but should I go all out and watch GT?


GT is terrible
Just watch Dragonball Z
User avatar
Joseph17
RealGM
Posts: 10,430
And1: 529
Joined: Jul 09, 2004
Location: New York
   

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#124 » by Joseph17 » Mon Jul 11, 2011 3:58 am

Wades Team wrote:Hey honest question I'm a junior in high school, i'm 5'11 and pretty scrawny about 140. Should I focus on getting bigger or getting more skilled to play better?

Focus on getting faster and more athletic. Do serious speed training and follow a program to increase your vert. More muscle would be good for you as well, but I think speed and athleticism are more important for a guy that's 5'11.
User avatar
gino_giode
Head Coach
Posts: 6,976
And1: 1,505
Joined: Jan 03, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#125 » by gino_giode » Mon Jul 11, 2011 4:14 am

GT isn't for everybody. But it was still good.

It lacked the pleasant humor and interesting enemies that Z had. And it's probably hard for most ppl to shift their DBZ love to characters like Trunks and Pan.

But the battles were epic as well. Baby, Super Android 17, and the Omega Dragon were some badass baddies.

It's 65 eps long, so it's not such a long distance marathon like DBZ was.

My only gripe with GT was how Funimation produced it with such terrible music. DBZ's US intro was godly.

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WAshPnOKzSg[/youtube]
vs
[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8tH3Z2NYxak&feature=related[/youtube]
WTF were they thinking?
Image
User avatar
spacemonkey
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,551
And1: 8,661
Joined: Nov 24, 2004

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#126 » by spacemonkey » Mon Jul 11, 2011 5:00 am

tiderulz wrote:Anthony Mason was pretty well muscled and he used to play Point Forward. I think it all just depends on the player themselves

Image


Mase was such a badass. I love it every time he's brought up in conversation.

Just so I can say that Mase was such a badass, and that I love it every time he's brought up in conversation.
User avatar
spacemonkey
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,551
And1: 8,661
Joined: Nov 24, 2004

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#127 » by spacemonkey » Mon Jul 11, 2011 5:09 am

Also, Gilbert Arenas has a really bulky ass in that planking pic of him.
User avatar
Doormatt
RealGM
Posts: 17,438
And1: 2,013
Joined: Mar 07, 2011
   

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#128 » by Doormatt » Mon Jul 11, 2011 10:13 am

Cowboy Bebop pwns DBZ all time. DBZ had great longevity, but never had the dominant peak CB did.

I'd go as far as Full Metal Alchemist being better as well.

Of course nobody compares to the GOAT, FLCL.
#doorgek
MLSE
Banned User
Posts: 1,098
And1: 0
Joined: Jun 11, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#129 » by MLSE » Mon Jul 11, 2011 10:55 am

Not sure how related...

My buddy used to be a pretty awesome golfer but he took up body building and now he can't even swing the club.
peja_the_legend
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,426
And1: 897
Joined: Jul 13, 2006

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#130 » by peja_the_legend » Mon Jul 11, 2011 11:05 am

What is all this stuff about japanese cartoons or whatever this goku is?Cant the mods move this trash elsewhere?.I can hardly follow the discussion with all these irrelevant messages..
RojanRando
Banned User
Posts: 648
And1: 0
Joined: Apr 03, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#131 » by RojanRando » Mon Jul 11, 2011 11:54 am

Doormatt wrote:Cowboy Bebop pwns DBZ all time. DBZ had great longevity, but never had the dominant peak CB did.

I'd go as far as Full Metal Alchemist being better as well.

Of course nobody compares to the GOAT, FLCL.


FLCL is the GOAT? FLCL is like the Karl Malone of anime. Has great substance and longevity, but lacks that "edge" that puts it in GOAT conversations.
RojanRando
Banned User
Posts: 648
And1: 0
Joined: Apr 03, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#132 » by RojanRando » Mon Jul 11, 2011 11:54 am

U-Borat wrote:hay guys should i watch dragon ball z or is the newly mastered dragon ball z kai version enuff? its a lot shorter but will i miss out on good ****?


Kai doesn't have the Buu Saga. So you would miss out on a bunch of good **** there.
doctorfunk
Banned User
Posts: 4,334
And1: 6
Joined: Sep 13, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#133 » by doctorfunk » Mon Jul 11, 2011 12:06 pm

MLSE wrote:Not sure how related...

My buddy used to be a pretty awesome golfer but he took up body building and now he can't even swing the club.


sort of is, I guess he has to learn it from 'the start'
cb4_89
RealGM
Posts: 27,650
And1: 517
Joined: Oct 02, 2004
       

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#134 » by cb4_89 » Mon Jul 11, 2011 12:39 pm

RojanRando wrote:
U-Borat wrote:hay guys should i watch dragon ball z or is the newly mastered dragon ball z kai version enuff? its a lot shorter but will i miss out on good ****?


Kai doesn't have the Buu Saga. So you would miss out on a bunch of good **** there.


Isn't kai still coming out? The english version at least. I doubt they would just leave out the Buu saga (though it was a step down from the rest of the show, minus the garlic junior and HS gohan sagas)
User avatar
pross
Veteran
Posts: 2,753
And1: 174
Joined: Apr 30, 2009

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#135 » by pross » Mon Jul 11, 2011 1:33 pm

U-Borat wrote:strong stereotyping good luck getting anywhere in life!


If only you knew.

A few people from my city in the Australian threads know who I am. I know where I am in life and love it. At 24 years old, I probably earnt more last financial year than you and your parents combined.

By the way, what's wrong with what I said? It's an asian cartoon, The only friends of mine that watched it when we were younger were asian. This site is known to have a lot of asian followers, so putting those together one would assume the majority of people posting in this thread are asian. Nothing wrong with that, was just a little joke.

This off season is already turning this place bad. I mean a thread about muscle in basketball has turned into Dragon Ball Z chat? I mean, REALLY?

Edit to answer OP's question.

I think bulking up "can" slightly hinder your skill set. I'm using myself for example here but follow along. When I was younger, I was a good shooter and had quite good form. As I got older (19-20ish) I decided to bulk up (6'1 70ish kilo's to 85ish KG today). What I noticed over that time, was that my shot form got worse and I still can't seem to get it back to where it was no matter how hard I work on it.

In saying that, I've found my overall game to be a lot better. Better at finishing at the rim, can run faster and jump higher, handles haven't been affected at all and overall movement on court seems better. In the end, it comes down to the individual. I don't think muscle is stopping Dwight developing a hakeem esk post game.
Image
Chosen01
RealGM
Posts: 17,107
And1: 534
Joined: May 08, 2009
 

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#136 » by Chosen01 » Mon Jul 11, 2011 2:20 pm

GOAT thread, I used love Dbz growing up.

GTFO pross!
Palmeirense
General Manager
Posts: 8,504
And1: 1,125
Joined: Apr 19, 2007
     

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#137 » by Palmeirense » Mon Jul 11, 2011 2:49 pm

Hon-essim wrote:These are pros. They don't really build too much anything. Their lifestyle pretty much means unlike trying out USSJ for the first time, these guys actually have an off-season to get used to their new body.

It's more like maybe blind muscle sculpting gets combined with added muscles and sometimes that takes away from skills training. Other times it's the wrong skills and not actually the training part. Other times it's the lack of evolution in their skills.

Dwight and Rose for example are monsters and their weight training know how and regimen probably far surpasses MJ's or Shaq's based on how fast they close the gap in physicality even though they are arguably less gifted players. Yet even with this and their probable superior work ethic, they don't focus on the urgency of the situation and they find themselves in disappointing moments everytime they meet a smart adversary in the playoffs. Dwight doesn't train enough in his confidence so all that muscle becomes over-compensation rather than an additional edge. Rose similarly has an inflated sense of his offensive success in the regular season so all the off season effort is wasted in the post-season when he lets his guard down.

If you want to use a DBZ moment, compare it to how Freeza was bulking up to 100% not some urgent form Trunks has to assume because there wasn't enough of an off-season to test it.

Freeza had tons of success in the regular planets with no legendary SSJ. By far if it weren't for the fillers, he arguably could be the most powerful since there's no proof his father is as strong as him and even if he was - Freeza was far younger. Freeza is the Dwight and Rose and Lebron of the NBA. They are battle tested individuals who can turn it up season after season and scare the rankings for how much dominant they are at such a young age and how much playoff battles they've already gone through in terms of attrition.

However Freeza rarely goes at 100% because he doesn't need to. Going so much as to toy with his prey. Dwight even hinted at this in an interview. Something about training with Olajuwon teaching him the difference between a ninja and a mercenary. For the most part, Freeza is a ninja and while ninjas are cool there's a reason why in reality they are assassins. Their moves are designed to be go to moves and yet Lebron, Dwight and to an extent Rose' go to moves are not varied and optimized enough to really become fall back moves. Instead their secret moves end up becoming predictable power up moves they fall back on.

This is why Freeza not only lost his squad but allowed Goku to reach Namek and become the legendary SSJ. Zaza, Barea, Gasol, Perkins even Lebron when he guarded Rose wasn't aiming to "beat" Dwight/Lebron/Rose. Same way Krillin and Gohan and Vegeta wasn't aiming to beat Freeza.

They were simply aiming to limit Freeza and hoping a miracle would happen. When that miracle happened, Freeza still had a chance. After all he was the one who could go 100%. He was the one with experience dealing with that type of power while Goku had to get used to it on short notice.

However Freeza had the wrong mindset even in his off-season and it finally caught up. Just as Dwight still had his moves, Rose was still a pg with improved playmaking and Lebron as horrible as he was posting up still was someone who could use that silly foul on Barea as an aggressive motivation - their muscular training had reduced the mental aspect of their instincts under pressure even though they aren't as mentally weak. Freeza similarly could have battled against Goku in a war of attrition in which he could probably win but his muscular pride in his super secret ninja move being unbeaten made him forget the difference between a super powered mercenary who is mentally more ready to beat him for a greater cause than his own self deluded value of proving his ninja moves superior. The result was that Freeza ends up losing because he tried to play the superior game of his opponent. A game that even there is close to equal but every frustrated technicals, every failed drives, every humiliating words edged it closer to the mercenary who grew more motivationally stronger as the battle go on where as the muscle guys who hid behind those muscles slowly crumbled and seemingly choked themselves out.

The USSJ failure is much closer to Gasol's failure the first time against Boston. Up to that point in time, the legendary SSJ was already seen as some ultimate unbeatable transformation and that was who Gasol was when he went to LA. Unlike Goku who had faced superior opponents before that nearly killed him while he wasn't a SSJ, Trunks came from a timeline when that transformation was the key. Similarly when Gasol came to LA, it was like he became part of the unspoken NBA champion not just because of the prestige of playing with Kobe but because of the ease the way LA went through almost every team even against the Spurs were Gasol and Kobe simply activated their patented pick and roll and it jarred the normally quick to adapt Spurs.

Then suddenly here comes Cell who were making it tough for the Super Saiyan to perform even on equal terms. Trunks and Gasol had to do something so they tried compensating for who they were and it just hurt the team more. The USSJ may be flawed in that it made the bearer slow but to someone like Trunks who had an exposure to the SSJ transformation as a god send and not just an additional power-up, the USSJ felt like the perfect instinctive back up if the powered up SSJ wasn't enough. And to an extent he's right. USSJ may be slow but SSJ's are darn fast to begin with. Not to mention durable. Under the right opponent who wasn't as mentally cold blooded and hungry as Boston or Cell that would have unnerved them enough in the same way Goku messed up Freeza. I.E. it was a near perfect considering the solution basically meant creating SSJ 2 which at that point had no reference to and Gohan only achieved because of his superior power to Trunks. Unfortunately the solution ended up being a mistake because just like Gasol, Trunks was trying to play a perfect game but although it was perfect, it was still imperfect against the opposing team. Trunks in his attempt to unlock the perfect solution within his body ends up forgetting to look at who his opponent is.

The only comparable element this has to Lebron, is that Lebron might have also tried to play a perfect game and forgot to factor in the way Dallas is and the way Miami is as a roster. That resulted in him becoming more passive. He thought he was being the perfect Pippen to Wade with the triple doubles and the play making and he completely forget that the way Miami was built, they needed Lebron to simply contribute to the team.

The problem with the comparison is that Lebron is on Gohan's level. Even if SSJ2 Gohan went USSJ2, he could have hurt Cell. More importantly, Gohan would realize that at his power level, he needn't go USSJ2 to compensate for the power level since SSJ2 was enough. He just has to get mad.

Instead Gohan does an about face and Wade err... Goku ends up having to bail his ass out there and thankfully the NBA Finals isn't a do or die game but nonetheless Wade ends up injurying himself trying to compensate for Lebron and unfortunately Lebron didn't unleash the beast. Of course the comparison ends there since Dallas is in no way the Perfect Cell of the NBA.


I can't believe this post did not get enough props. I was both LMAO and amazed throughout this gem. You sir are on some serious drugs.
Image

Props to Jeff1624 for the sig
venky
Junior
Posts: 260
And1: 0
Joined: May 31, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#138 » by venky » Tue Jul 12, 2011 1:31 am

It's a shame that Akira Toriyama caved to the fans and his editors by making Goku beat a weaker Buu in the end. His plan all along was to have Gohan be the hero at the end, but the fans just had to cry. :x

/Gohan-fan
RojanRando
Banned User
Posts: 648
And1: 0
Joined: Apr 03, 2011

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#139 » by RojanRando » Tue Jul 12, 2011 1:35 am

venky wrote:It's a shame that Akira Toriyama caved to the fans and his editors by making Goku beat a weaker Buu in the end. His plan all along was to have Gohan be the hero at the end, but the fans just had to cry. :x

/Gohan-fan


Its terrible how Gohan got his mystic powerup and then was forced to fight Buutenks. Just like how every character except for Goku is smacked right after they power up. I will never forget how when Piccolo became a Super Namek and all the rumors up to that point was that Super Nameks **** on Super Saiyans and yet he frickin got destroyed by Semi-Perfect Cell. Not Perfect Cell, or Super Perfect Cell FRICKIN SEMI-PERFECT CELL
User avatar
wilhelmthe1st
Pro Prospect
Posts: 839
And1: 178
Joined: Jun 18, 2010

Re: Will too much muscle mess up your skills? 

Post#140 » by wilhelmthe1st » Tue Jul 12, 2011 3:27 am

RojanRando wrote:
Hon-essim wrote:
bigboi wrote:To all my dbz boys, Broly is the strongest one there is, fact. Buu is probably the closest to Broly. Broly only got killed because Goku gets the most retarted powerups


That's like saying Kobe is probably the closest to Shaq. Oh and Hakeem did not get retarted powerups.


Mystic Gohan is the strongest fools


SSJ3 Goku is the strongest actually. He could have ended it easily, but he wanted the others to finally save the f***ing day instead of taking all the glory himself. Which he ends up doing anyways.

Return to The General Board