dandridge 10 wrote:Its funny how adament some people are on this board about who is the better player out of Beal, MKG and Robinson. Bottom line is nobody on this board knows what type of player Beal, MKG or Robinson will become. Beal could be the next Wade or could be the next Randy Foye. MKG could be the next Gerald Wallace/Shawn Marion or the next Chris Singleton. Robinson could be the next David West or the next Tyler Hansborough/Trevor Booker. Who knows. I recall people knocking Harden coming out of college because he was not "athletic" and could struggle getting to the rim. Turns out they were flat out wrong.
My preference is Beal, Robinson and then MKG in that order only because I think all three have about equal potential/intangibles, but Beal and Robinson would fill a bigger need. But, it wouldn't shock me if MKG was the best out of the three. I'm just glad I don't have to make the decision, because notwithstanding all the "experts" on this board, it is really a crapshoot between the 3 on who is going to be the better player in the long run.
+1 although I sorta disagree about which of TRob/MKG fills a bigger need. You say
TRob who I think we can agree will be a 4. I think between the 3 and 4, we have a
bigger hole to fill or put another way, more room to improve, at the 3. I also think
MKG, a 3, probably has higher ceiling whereas TRob has a higher floor than MKG.
I really hope we end up with Beal. I think he will be an ideal running mate to
Wall in the medium to long term future ie 3-5 years.
so with Beal, MKG and TRob projecting as a 2, 3, and 4 respectively, I think the
need based valuation is the same order, 2, 3 then 4. TRob's best asset is rebounding
which is a definite need. But Beal could actually help address that from the backcourt.
I think your essential point though about it being a crapshoot is dead on. We won't know
for a while who was right. I feel the same about Vesely right now. I think it's quite possible
that in 2-4 years, 3-4 teams might be wondering why they passed on him. He's got
great intangibles and instincts and he plays really hard. Just like MKG.