ImageImageImageImage

Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI "Re-Building" Edition)

Moderators: UCF, Knightro, UCFJayBird, Def Swami, Howard Mass, ChosenSavior

User avatar
Hotshot Hower
Veteran
Posts: 2,591
And1: 98
Joined: Jun 24, 2005
Location: Cape Canaveral, FL
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#561 » by Hotshot Hower » Mon Aug 20, 2012 3:10 pm

tiderulz wrote:well, sorry, but count me in the camp that he isnt a #1 player. And i believe that his stats benefit from playing against backups and 2nd level players for the first half of games. He is still young enough to get better, and hopefully gets better defensively. Not been impressed with his defense, all he seems to do is flop and look for the call.

I also see him as a more intelligent player, not more athletic. If he had dunked the fast break he had in the finals, they would have won that game. Instead, he couldnt and missed the layup. He also is not fast enough to guard the top level SG's and too small to guard most SF's.

he does have a good all around offensive game. He is similar to Iggy in that he can set up other players, though IMO better on offense than Iggy. Just not sure that when defense are setting up to attack him, versus when he plays with WB and KD, that he can continue to produce at such high levels.


Really? I mean, really?

Your 1st argument (Harden playing against team's 2nd units, etc) doesn't warrant that kind of opinion. For one, he played starter minutes and finished a lot of games. W/ Thabo, Scotty Brooks often looked at matchups as to who would get more mins/finish because OKC was that DEEP perimeter-wise. He's also a pretty solid one-on-one defender, stays low, doesn't gamble too often with steals. Like you said, "intelligent". "Flop"? When he's playing against bigger two's who post him up, what do you expect? LOL

Your 2nd statement I can agree with, though I think he's more capable of being athletic than he lets on. I mean, I just think Westbrook's explosiveness kind of hide, over shadow Harden's athleticism. I've watched a ton of Thunder games and team USA games/scrimmages and from what I saw, Harden can finish with the best of them. The Iggy comparison isn't fair, as Harden's a 1-2 hybrid and Iggy's a 2-3 hybrid.

I think Bensational made the Ginobili reference and I agree 100% with that. Harden, in my eyes can easily duplicate his success, stats from OKC and build on them on a team, preferably Orlando. :wink:
Image
LetItRain
Starter
Posts: 2,142
And1: 224
Joined: Jul 30, 2005

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#562 » by LetItRain » Mon Aug 20, 2012 3:40 pm

Harden is definitely not a #1 option. #2, maybe.
User avatar
BadMofoPimp
RealGM
Posts: 49,259
And1: 12,576
Joined: Oct 12, 2003
Location: In the Paint

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#563 » by BadMofoPimp » Mon Aug 20, 2012 3:46 pm

LetItRain wrote:Harden is definitely not a #1 option. #2, maybe.


Yep. He proved so in the NBA Finals. But, he is still young and may develop into a #1. You never know.
Image

Provin Ya'll Wrong!!!
User avatar
Blue_and_Whte
RealGM
Posts: 24,686
And1: 9,569
Joined: Jun 26, 2009
Location: Orlando, FL.
     

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#564 » by Blue_and_Whte » Mon Aug 20, 2012 3:52 pm

Even though im still on the "harden is a #2 option" bus imo he still growing and would be a step in the right direction if they want to rebuild quickly.
Faith, Family, & Orlando Magic
#2A
#Adopt
#MAGA
TheLastDon
Sophomore
Posts: 125
And1: 2
Joined: May 05, 2012

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#565 » by TheLastDon » Mon Aug 20, 2012 3:52 pm

LetItRain wrote:Harden is definitely not a #1 option. #2, maybe.


Rudy Gay is a lot closer to #1 option than Harden and is easily more available
RYgoBOOM
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,463
And1: 292
Joined: Jul 10, 2012

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#566 » by RYgoBOOM » Mon Aug 20, 2012 3:59 pm

TheLastDon wrote:
LetItRain wrote:Harden is definitely not a #1 option. #2, maybe.


Rudy Gay is a lot closer to #1 option than Harden and is easily more available

Why go after Gay if we have Harkless? Who could turn into gay in a few years? Just seems redundant.

Where as Harden hasn't touched his prime and is a efficient scoring SG to go a long with Hark at the 3.
User avatar
Def Swami
Forum Mod - Magic
Forum Mod - Magic
Posts: 26,009
And1: 15,407
Joined: Aug 04, 2008
Location: Huevos Bancheros Brunch
Contact:
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#567 » by Def Swami » Mon Aug 20, 2012 4:06 pm

rcklsscognition wrote:I get the feeling reading this thread that there are no free agents that will save our franchise. Is that right? It seems like we're hopeless bunch. There may be Harden on the market, maybe not, but outside of that, which NBA borderline all-star or all-star will be joining the Magic in 2014 to bring our team back into the spotlight? I don't see anyone.

The best route is certainly building through the draft.
TheLastDon
Sophomore
Posts: 125
And1: 2
Joined: May 05, 2012

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#568 » by TheLastDon » Mon Aug 20, 2012 4:13 pm

RYgoBOOM wrote:
TheLastDon wrote:
LetItRain wrote:Harden is definitely not a #1 option. #2, maybe.


Rudy Gay is a lot closer to #1 option than Harden and is easily more available

Why go after Gay if we have Harkless? Who could turn into gay in a few years? Just seems redundant.

Where as Harden hasn't touched his prime and is a efficient scoring SG to go a long with Hark at the 3.



Simple: Harkless is a lot closer to Nicholson potential than Gay... Gay is proven scorer and can be had and also is 3yrs in to similar deal you would have to give Harden. Oh yea, OKC still will hold right to match any offer he recieves
User avatar
OrlandoMajinBuu
Junior
Posts: 464
And1: 19
Joined: Jul 02, 2012
Location: Puerto Rico
Contact:

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#569 » by OrlandoMajinBuu » Mon Aug 20, 2012 4:15 pm

VGOSWAMI wrote:
rcklsscognition wrote:I get the feeling reading this thread that there are no free agents that will save our franchise. Is that right? It seems like we're hopeless bunch. There may be Harden on the market, maybe not, but outside of that, which NBA borderline all-star or all-star will be joining the Magic in 2014 to bring our team back into the spotlight? I don't see anyone.

The best route is certainly building through the draft.

^ This.
Image
User avatar
tiderulz
RealGM
Posts: 36,944
And1: 14,872
Joined: Jun 16, 2010
Location: Atlanta
 

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#570 » by tiderulz » Mon Aug 20, 2012 4:51 pm

Hotshot Hower wrote:
tiderulz wrote:well, sorry, but count me in the camp that he isnt a #1 player. And i believe that his stats benefit from playing against backups and 2nd level players for the first half of games. He is still young enough to get better, and hopefully gets better defensively. Not been impressed with his defense, all he seems to do is flop and look for the call.

I also see him as a more intelligent player, not more athletic. If he had dunked the fast break he had in the finals, they would have won that game. Instead, he couldnt and missed the layup. He also is not fast enough to guard the top level SG's and too small to guard most SF's.

he does have a good all around offensive game. He is similar to Iggy in that he can set up other players, though IMO better on offense than Iggy. Just not sure that when defense are setting up to attack him, versus when he plays with WB and KD, that he can continue to produce at such high levels.


Really? I mean, really?

Your 1st argument (Harden playing against team's 2nd units, etc) doesn't warrant that kind of opinion. For one, he played starter minutes and finished a lot of games. W/ Thabo, Scotty Brooks often looked at matchups as to who would get more mins/finish because OKC was that DEEP perimeter-wise. He's also a pretty solid one-on-one defender, stays low, doesn't gamble too often with steals. Like you said, "intelligent". "Flop"? When he's playing against bigger two's who post him up, what do you expect? LOL

Your 2nd statement I can agree with, though I think he's more capable of being athletic than he lets on. I mean, I just think Westbrook's explosiveness kind of hide, over shadow Harden's athleticism. I've watched a ton of Thunder games and team USA games/scrimmages and from what I saw, Harden can finish with the best of them. The Iggy comparison isn't fair, as Harden's a 1-2 hybrid and Iggy's a 2-3 hybrid.

I think Bensational made the Ginobili reference and I agree 100% with that. Harden, in my eyes can easily duplicate his success, stats from OKC and build on them on a team, preferably Orlando. :wink:


Geez, its like people read the first part of a sentence and dont bother to read the entire thing. I didnt say he only gets his stats against 2nd tier players and that he only plays back up minutes. Just that he benefits IN THE FIRST HALF playing against other teams backups. He comes in a majority of the time when opposing teams are sending in their backups to give their starters a rest. He is of course starter material, but for some reason, similar to Ginobli I guess, he or his coach prefer to have him come in off the bench. I never said he pads his entire stats against 2nd string players. I said he finishes games against opposing teams best players. And you also saw where i said "I believe" right? am i not entitled to my own opinion?

But sorry, Harden is a mad flopper and not just against players bigger than him trying to back him down. He does it on the perimeter against smaller players too.
ChildishGambino
Banned User
Posts: 2,185
And1: 48
Joined: Feb 14, 2012
Location: St. Barts

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#571 » by ChildishGambino » Mon Aug 20, 2012 4:56 pm

Rudy Gay and Harden is ON THE SAME LEVEL....why are people treating Rudy like a superstar?.....he's a great player but he's not all that better then Harden if at all.....
Nyce_1
RealGM
Posts: 12,969
And1: 6,114
Joined: Jun 29, 2009
Location: Tampa
 

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#572 » by Nyce_1 » Mon Aug 20, 2012 4:58 pm

fendilim wrote:http://www.740thegame.com/pages/openmike.html?article=10356733

Otis knew Dwight was leaving long before...

Thanks for posting. I miss SVG. Very smart guy and Vaughn definitely has some big shoes to fill.
TDJacksonville
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,229
And1: 242
Joined: Jun 29, 2012
Location: Your girlfriends panties

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#573 » by TDJacksonville » Mon Aug 20, 2012 5:35 pm

OrlandoMajinBuu wrote:
VGOSWAMI wrote:
rcklsscognition wrote:I get the feeling reading this thread that there are no free agents that will save our franchise. Is that right? It seems like we're hopeless bunch. There may be Harden on the market, maybe not, but outside of that, which NBA borderline all-star or all-star will be joining the Magic in 2014 to bring our team back into the spotlight? I don't see anyone.

The best route is certainly building through the draft.

^ This.

^^this
Trailblazers
PG:
SG:
F:
F:
C:
Wzajan89 @ gmail . com
TheLastDon
Sophomore
Posts: 125
And1: 2
Joined: May 05, 2012

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#574 » by TheLastDon » Mon Aug 20, 2012 5:37 pm

ChildishGambino wrote:Rudy Gay and Harden is ON THE SAME LEVEL....why are people treating Rudy like a superstar?.....he's a great player but he's not all that better then Harden if at all.....


They are similar players as far as market value(Max Players). I feel Gay is easier to get than Harden cause Gay is already 3yrs into a similar contract that would have to be given to Harden and still makes us players in 2014 FA class. BTW, OKC can simply match any offers ala Hornets matching Gordon, Portland matching Batum, and Indiana matching Hibbert. If we were to trade for Gay now rather than in 2014, I feel you should definitely look at it.
TDJacksonville
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,229
And1: 242
Joined: Jun 29, 2012
Location: Your girlfriends panties

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#575 » by TDJacksonville » Mon Aug 20, 2012 5:38 pm

ChildishGambino wrote:Rudy Gay and Harden is ON THE SAME LEVEL....why are people treating Rudy like a superstar?.....he's a great player but he's not all that better then Harden if at all.....
i would say hes good but hes not great. i mean hes only averaged 20 points a Game ONCE in his Career. hes not gonna make our team into a Playoff Contender that wins us the championship. the Best way to Win a Championship is to Draft well and develop your players. we need to develop our own star first then maybe go out and acquire a star or 2 more but imo should build the Majority of the roster thru the draft and spend Money Smartly.
TheLastDon
Sophomore
Posts: 125
And1: 2
Joined: May 05, 2012

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#576 » by TheLastDon » Mon Aug 20, 2012 6:09 pm

TDJacksonville wrote:
ChildishGambino wrote:Rudy Gay and Harden is ON THE SAME LEVEL....why are people treating Rudy like a superstar?.....he's a great player but he's not all that better then Harden if at all.....
i would say hes good but hes not great. i mean hes only averaged 20 points a Game ONCE in his Career. hes not gonna make our team into a Playoff Contender that wins us the championship. the Best way to Win a Championship is to Draft well and develop your players. we need to develop our own star first then maybe go out and acquire a star or 2 more but imo should build the Majority of the roster thru the draft and spend Money Smartly.



By himself, of course not. The reason I would is because of 17 mil TPE and he is a proven commodity. Another ,major factor is that Gay could be had now and it will not hamper our flexibility. Also, Gay is major FA in 2014, so I believe if you can get him now, you'll know if you can build with him, Affalo, Nickolson because ANY pro draft is a CRAPSHOOT!!!
ChildishGambino
Banned User
Posts: 2,185
And1: 48
Joined: Feb 14, 2012
Location: St. Barts

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#577 » by ChildishGambino » Mon Aug 20, 2012 6:15 pm

TheLastDon wrote:
TDJacksonville wrote:
ChildishGambino wrote:Rudy Gay and Harden is ON THE SAME LEVEL....why are people treating Rudy like a superstar?.....he's a great player but he's not all that better then Harden if at all.....
i would say hes good but hes not great. i mean hes only averaged 20 points a Game ONCE in his Career. hes not gonna make our team into a Playoff Contender that wins us the championship. the Best way to Win a Championship is to Draft well and develop your players. we need to develop our own star first then maybe go out and acquire a star or 2 more but imo should build the Majority of the roster thru the draft and spend Money Smartly.



By himself, of course not. The reason I would is because of 17 mil TPE and he is a proven commodity. Another ,major factor is that Gay could be had now and it will not hamper our flexibility. Also, Gay is major FA in 2014, so I believe if you can get him now, you'll know if you can build with him, Affalo, Nickolson because ANY pro draft is a CRAPSHOOT!!!

Why would Gay want to come to the start of a rebuild in the middle of his prime? i know i'm assuming but Henny wants guys that WANT to be here....not sure if Gay wants to waste a couple prime years for a chance to become a contender later.....maybe i'm wrong
TDJacksonville
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,229
And1: 242
Joined: Jun 29, 2012
Location: Your girlfriends panties

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#578 » by TDJacksonville » Mon Aug 20, 2012 6:16 pm

TheLastDon wrote:
TDJacksonville wrote:
ChildishGambino wrote:Rudy Gay and Harden is ON THE SAME LEVEL....why are people treating Rudy like a superstar?.....he's a great player but he's not all that better then Harden if at all.....
i would say hes good but hes not great. i mean hes only averaged 20 points a Game ONCE in his Career. hes not gonna make our team into a Playoff Contender that wins us the championship. the Best way to Win a Championship is to Draft well and develop your players. we need to develop our own star first then maybe go out and acquire a star or 2 more but imo should build the Majority of the roster thru the draft and spend Money Smartly.



By himself, of course not. The reason I would is because of 17 mil TPE and he is a proven commodity. Another ,major factor is that Gay could be had now and it will not hamper our flexibility. Also, Gay is major FA in 2014, so I believe if you can get him now, you'll know if you can build with him, Affalo, Nickolson because ANY pro draft is a CRAPSHOOT!!!
hes got a Player option in 2014. i wouldnt pay him near 20 million and stunt the Development of our young guys. your nuts to think that Henny would trade our most valuable Asset into an almost immoveable contract. i think henny is going to use it for a Few Players and get some draft picks with the player. henny with a Bunch of picks should make our team good with Player development.

draft is a crap shoot but so are trades and Fa Signings. everything is a Crap Shoot. if im picking a crap shoot then im gonna take the draft approach because atleast it wont hurt us Long term with contracts. Gay will NOT Make us into a Playoff contender. ESPN thinks that we will Barely be better than the Bobcats so adding him will not help us much other than to have a worse pick to find a Superstar.
TDJacksonville
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,229
And1: 242
Joined: Jun 29, 2012
Location: Your girlfriends panties

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#579 » by TDJacksonville » Mon Aug 20, 2012 6:18 pm

ChildishGambino wrote:
TheLastDon wrote:
TDJacksonville wrote:i would say hes good but hes not great. i mean hes only averaged 20 points a Game ONCE in his Career. hes not gonna make our team into a Playoff Contender that wins us the championship. the Best way to Win a Championship is to Draft well and develop your players. we need to develop our own star first then maybe go out and acquire a star or 2 more but imo should build the Majority of the roster thru the draft and spend Money Smartly.



By himself, of course not. The reason I would is because of 17 mil TPE and he is a proven commodity. Another ,major factor is that Gay could be had now and it will not hamper our flexibility. Also, Gay is major FA in 2014, so I believe if you can get him now, you'll know if you can build with him, Affalo, Nickolson because ANY pro draft is a CRAPSHOOT!!!

Why would Gay want to come to the start of a rebuild in the middle of his prime? i know i'm assuming but Henny wants guys that WANT to be here....not sure if Gay wants to waste a couple prime years for a chance to become a contender later.....maybe i'm wrong


U sir are correct. why would a Player who is in his Prime want to stick around for a rebuild when he can probably join a Contender in FA in 2014 if he opts out.
Trailblazers
PG:
SG:
F:
F:
C:
Wzajan89 @ gmail . com
TheLastDon
Sophomore
Posts: 125
And1: 2
Joined: May 05, 2012

Re: Official Speculation Thread (Pt. XLVI 

Post#580 » by TheLastDon » Mon Aug 20, 2012 6:30 pm

By himself, of course not. The reason I would is because of 17 mil TPE and he is a proven commodity. Another ,major factor is that Gay could be had now and it will not hamper our flexibility. Also, Gay is major FA in 2014, so I believe if you can get him now, you'll know if you can build with him, Affalo, Nickolson because ANY pro draft is a CRAPSHOOT!!![/quote]

Why would Gay want to come to the start of a rebuild in the middle of his prime? i know i'm assuming but Henny wants guys that WANT to be here....not sure if Gay wants to waste a couple prime years for a chance to become a contender later.....maybe i'm wrong[/quote]

U sir are correct. why would a Player who is in his Prime want to stick around for a rebuild when he can probably join a Contender in FA in 2014 if he opts out.[/quote]


I bet if I substitute Harden for Gay, you all would be in favor!!! The same Harden who contract ends this upcoming season, which OKC will place qualifying offer on Harden and simply match MAX offer. Oh, and to answer question, if Gay leaves you still have the cap space REGARDLESS!!! Money is no object for Magic and here's why.

http://sports.yahoo.com/nba/news?slug=ycn-9742249

We have 3rd richest owner in NBA

Return to Orlando Magic