#23 Highest Peak of All Time (Barkley '93 wins)

[bastillon]

Tmac x2 (therealbigthree, c-izme)
Barkley 90 (Elgee)
Moses x3 (PTB, JB, bast), lightning "leaning towards Moses" on page 1)
Barkley 93 x5 (Mufasa, Ardee, DS, fatal, Doc MJ)

+ several posters are undecided: drza, mysticbb among others. I think it's still a legit debate.

[SDChargers#1]

It is possible that I missed the deadline. If I did, then just ignore.

Vote: 1983 Moses Malone

[bastillon]

for some reason I thought the deadline was today at 9 PM, not yesterday. funny thing though since Moses could still come from behind til' 9 PM today. it's 4 vs 5 with lightning leaning towards Moses. is it possible to extend the deadline ? we've had very little player vs player comparisons in this project and it seems like we could finally have some all out debate. I'd be curious how people would respond to my arguments regarding Moses and Barkley on defense. it seems like a great comparison anyway, both players are boxscore machines with overrated impact and stylistical similarities. I know the deadline's passed but it seems I'm not the only one who confused the timeline.

whatever you think Doc is the best.

[Doctor MJ]

I'm sorry guys, we've got to have deadlines for this project, and everyone has to believe in them.

Barkley '93 takes it.

Now, I've already backed off of doing 2-day threads so we're back at 3-day threads. If people want to advocate for 4-day threads going forward, we can talk about that. This doesn't really seem like it was the issue here though.