Jose Calderon or John Wall ?

espismark · Post #1 » by **espismark** » Sun Jan 6, 2013 10:57 am

My team:
PG: Chris Paul, Grievis Vasquez, Jason Kidd
SG:JJ Reddick, Jose Calderon, Paul George
SF: Danny Green, MWP
PF: Paul Millsap, Joakiam Noah, Kenneth Faried
C: Roy Hibbert, Larry Sanders

8 teams, 9 cat roto

Who do you think is better ?

TheToothFairy · Post #2 » by **TheToothFairy** » Sun Jan 6, 2013 4:53 pm

It's a weighted question because I don't have your league info/settings

Calderon is a very efficient player with questionable minutes

Wall is not efficient but has the keys to the franchise

espismark · Post #3 » by **espismark** » Sun Jan 6, 2013 5:07 pm

TheToothFairy wrote:It's a sighted question because I don't have your league info/settings

Calderon is a very efficient player with questionable minutes

Wall is not efficient but has the keys to the franchise

Edited it.

Spicy P · Post #4 » by **Spicy P** » Sun Jan 6, 2013 5:34 pm

John Wall. He's got more potential and Calderon is sharing minutes with Lowry.

TheToothFairy · Post #5 » by **TheToothFairy** » Sun Jan 6, 2013 5:48 pm

Well if it's roto I like Calderon, but why do u need 4 PG's ?

WhiteMambaLol · Post #6 » by **WhiteMambaLol** » Sun Jan 6, 2013 7:22 pm

Ya don't think you should have 4 point guards, especially since you have cp3 and Vasquez who get a ton of assists, combined with Kidd getting anywhere from 4-8 you should be winning assists often.

But for your question, it depends on whether you need improvement in stat production (pts, rebounds, assists) vs. efficiency (fg%, 3pt%, and less TO).

Calderon is a lot more efficient, but Wall might have a very big production edge especially since Lowry will be getting more time than Calderon since he is a better player.

Apathy · Post #7 » by **Apathy** » Mon Jan 7, 2013 2:10 am

Wall obv. Let him come back and sell him off. Everyone overrates Wall.

sweet_jesus · Post #8 » by **sweet_jesus** » Mon Jan 7, 2013 3:48 am

In a few weeks this thread is going to look silly. Calderon minutes are going sink down to at/below 20 mins with a healthy Lowry so unless he gets shipped off with Bargs, I don't see him retaining a ton of value long term.

Apathy · Post #9 » by **Apathy** » Mon Jan 7, 2013 4:37 am

Calderon will always be t100. He's been in seemingly **** situations for the past couple of years, but even coming off the bench 5+apg and 2 or fewer TOs always plays. Always always always.

And he's a strong bet to get traded.

I have no probs with Calderon, who is the perfect place-holder. Wall's just so ez to trade for value, though. Has connotations of name, upside and PPG.