Chocolate City Jordanaire wrote:Wall is a third-year, #1 overall pick who has been coached for years by Sam Cassell and before him Flip Saunders. He has played with Gilbert Arenas and Kirk Hinrich. In his first two years, Wall's PER was 15.8 and 17.7. This season so far, his PER is 17.1. This season, Wall has no knucklehead teammates, and he has veteran big men with size, veteran wings with size, and players who started last season deep on the bench. Wall has had time to improve.
Damien Lillard is coached by first-year coach, Terry Stotts. Outside of LaMarcus Aldridge, Wesley Matthews, and Nicolas Batum (himself relatively unproven); Lillard is the leader of his team. Lillard's PER is 16.4, slightly better than Wall's first season. Portland is 25-24 with Lillard leading the way.
So what exactly are you saying here? That Wall is playing with better teammates and a better coaching staff? I hope you're not really trying to make that point, because we all know that's a flat out lie. Aldridge alone is much better than anyone Wall has the benefit of playing with. So is Matthews and Batum. Heck, even JJ Hickson has played better than anyone on the Wizards this season. So to even suggest that Wall plays with an equal cast is just being ridiculous. As for coaching, Wall has had two different ones, none of which were good...I don't see why you even brought that up because it doesn't advance your argument any sort of way.
And Aldridge leads that team, not Lilliard. Lilliard gets the benefit of playing with an all-star big man...Wall doesn't.
I love how you pick and choose stats, numbers, records, or anything that basically helps you make a point, all the while ignoring that same exact stat when it doesn't serve your purpose. You were all about PER in another thread involving Cousins, talking about Cousins superior PER, yet ignoring his terrible TS% and efg% that you use against Wall all the time. Not only that, you've NEVER mentioned just how terrible the Kings are with Cousins leading the way. 24-58, 22-44 with Westphal getting fired, and now 17-33. How is that possible, when Cousins, according to you is the most talented big man in the NBA?
I guess when you have the benefit of picking and choosing what you use to prove a point, everyone is right 100% of the time.
TGW, the stat I care about more than PER is WS/48. Win score per 48 minutes for Wall is .057. Win score per 48 for Lillard is .098.
Win score for Jose Calderon is .150. Win score for Goran Dragic is .118. Win score for Mario Chalmers is .122—would you take these 3 over Lillard as well?
Lillard is a much better outside shooter than John Wall. Is he better? TGW, I would say right now he is definitely having a better rookie season than Wall, and he probably IS better.
LIllard has made 111 3PT shots this season. John made 3 all year last year and 1 this year.
John gets to the basket and he has superior court vision that gives him more assists.
Damian Lillard actually knows how to shoot and he is just a rookie, though he's the same age as John Wall.
Lillard is having a good season. And yes, he does shoot better than Wall. Wall has significant issues with his game...with that being said, you hold Wall to standards that you hold no one else to, because of obvious bias. This is blatantly apparent, especially when you come in threads propping Demarcus Cousins on a pedestal that he doesn't deserve to be on. You will make 1,243,430 excuses for Cousins when he plays like crap or does something idiotic, but you NEVER extend the same cortesy to wall. You are super-biased and I will continue to call you out on it.