Hendrix wrote:With such a stacked draft class this year, it's kind of worry-some to draft a guy that is being compared to a player that does have some flaws.
I dunno... To me, in a stacked draft class I have a problem drafting the 'next Melo' 1st overall. But, drafting a player that could be Dirk-esque, or Durant-esque offensively is a pretty easy sell.
To me with Jabari there are three ways the pick can fail if picked 1st
The Derrick Williams: To put it bluntly, he just is a mediocre, bench caliber player despite a huge college career and hyped up draft pick. A disastrous pick no matter what else happens in the draft.
The Rashard Lewis: Jabari becomes a fantastic player and lower level all-star, thanks to his scoring skill and size. Whether this is a good pick depends on where he goes and the quality of the draft. If it's the 2000 draft picking Shard first looks good. But if Jabari becomes Rashard-like at the 1st pick and Kobe and Duncan go in the top 5 after him, the pick absolutely blows enough for our grandchildren to know about it.
The Carmelo Anthony: This is the situation you outlined above. Jabari gets picked 1st and is a top 10 player and franchise player and fringe MVP and best player on a title team talent (if everything goes right). However if a generational player or two like Lebron or Duncan get picked after him it's still a bad pick, albeit not a national embarrassment.
I would say the Carmelo situation is the least likely by far. This draft class is a lot of hype but the chances of any of these guys being superstars is still small to me. There just aren't enough players at a tier above-Melo level, to be that confident in anyone getting there barring a Lebron and Shaq draft situation where it's too obvious. Especially in Jabari's case where he certainly appears less talented than Melo without the dynamic athleticism, nor do any of Wiggins, Embiid, Randle, Smart look flawless (imo), I think we all get by now the Wiggins generational/Lebron hype coming in was dumb
The biggest fear with Jabari 1st is the Rashard one. It's unlikely he all out busts, but if he becomes a good player instead of an elite player the potential for disaster is huge depending on who goes below him. Same goes for the other prospects - Wiggins could be "just" Iguodala and Embiid could be "just" Hibbert and Randle could be "just" David West, but even drafting an all-star caliber player like that 1st/2nd, could be a REALLY bad pick if you pass on the wrong player. That's why this draft is far from can't miss. It's the high roller's table - bigger stakes means bigger winners and bigger losers