AFM wrote:Chocolate City Jordanaire wrote:Lowry is better than Wall. Lowry was more deserving of All Star than Wall, mainly because of the Raptors' record.
Lowry proved his point in the win.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using RealGM Forums mobile app
No shame in that. Lowry is a very good player.
Players like Lowry and Dragic (and Calderone) will never get the respect they deserve compared to the Walls and Westbrooks.
Precisely, AFM.
Lowry was really good even on the Villanova Final Four team. Foye got more credit. Kyle Lowry is finally getting to be a star. He's not an all star only because of others being hyped more.
Dragic had stud numbers and IIRC once had like 20 plus points in a half of a playoff game. He was behind either Nash or on another team. Two years back I assessed Goran Dragic to be slightly better than Wall. Others will disagree vehemently with me.
My rationale: I view Wall as about as good as Caron Butler at Caron's best for the Wizards. Flawed but certainly all star offensively at his peak. John's defensive ability reminds me of peak Larry Hughes, when Hughes was putting up similar numbers to Gilbert Arenas. At the time, Eddie Jordan almost coached the all star game. IIRC Hughes led the league or was near the top in steals. However, Hughes gambled for steals. He had no answer for Dwayne Wade. Larry Hughes made all defensive team. HOWEVER, his defensive ability was less than DeShawn Stevenson's. DS really was a physical defender. He tried to stay right in Lebron's grill and even called James "overrated." Stevenson has huge ones. Later as a Maverick, DeShawn and Shawn Marion clowned on James as Dallas beat Miami in the Finals. Wall's not like DeShawn defensively IMO. He's more like Hughes wss.
Wall's defense is overrated and his floor game at "ISO Balll Time" is generally more miss than hit. I rate Lowry or Dragic high because they're stronger in SOME AREAS than Wall.
If any of my haters are still reading, the Great News is that John Wall is a young buck. He's IMO a puppy who if he gets tougher and smarter, keeps working hard, and stays humble; Wall's potential is sky freaking high!
He has been in the league three years and over a half. But then again, coaching and his GM and owner have been slow to surround Wall to be able to excel. Wall ain't a Magic Johnson or an MJ or a Kobe. He could be a Payton or Cassell or Kidd with extreme athleticism. Wall's got no Durant or Harden next to him like Russell Westbrook had his formative years.
So, despite my hard grade I remain hopeful. My only criticism might be I don't think next season Wall will produce like a max deal player. I hope petulance or pride don't form to keep Wall from improving. He's still got a LOT to learn.
Sent from my SGH-M919 using RealGM Forums mobile app