Polynice4Pippen wrote:AKfanatic wrote:Polynice4Pippen wrote:
But those are all clearly inferior lineups to a backcourt of Rose and Martin. Rose/Hinrich/Butler in the 4th quarter against an elite defensive team is not going to cut it, sorry. Rose and Martin together allows you the option of adding a defensive guy with them (Butler, Hinrich) or a shooter (McDermott, Snell) or even another offensive guy (Brooks). As long as Butler and Noah are on the floor we'd be closing out games with defense.
Are they the inferior option to Thibs though? That's the real question.
If he doesn't trust Martin on the defensive end of the court, does anyone really believe he'd be closing games? As I said, we as fans can scream until we're blue in the face as to whom should be closing out a game, and I'm sure there will be many times we disagree with whom he (Thibs) has out there in crunch time, in the end it'll be Thibs making the decision. I'd be willing to bet, if we had Martin, Butler, Snell, Hinrich, and a healthy Rose, that more often than not Martin would be grabbing pine next to Snell at the end of games.
So then why did Thibs ride Korver at the end of games over superior defenders like Bogans, Brewer and Butler? Martin would be out there at the end of games with Derrick and it would give us an offensive dynamic we haven't had since the Rose/Gordon/Salmons run when even the great Celtics defense had trouble containing that offense.
1. Korver actually tried on defense, Martin has yet to meet a defensive set he couldn't lazily screw up. Then again, maybe it's a lack of actual defensive teams around him...I don't know.
2. Bogans and Brewer brought absolute zero on the offensive end, Butler had yet to prove himself capable. There's a solid chance Butler shows to be closer to year 2 Butler than last season Butler. If that's the case, he'll be in games.
Regardless of what I, you, or anyone else assumes and speculates on, we don't know. Maybe Martin joins the Bulls and we become an arse kicking machine, maybe Thibs chokes him out after multiple defensive lapses. I wouldn't mind him + pieces for Taj. I wouldn't swap the two straight up at this point. Not without knowing what Niko can give us. As of right now our depth in the front court consists of 3 guys, two of which have been battling injuries. I could just imagine the all caps posts pertaining to GarPax if Noah went down, Niko wasn't ready, and we had no Taj. Though I suppose Nazr or Chris Richards could always be waiting in the wings to save our front court.