Undefeated wrote:ontnut wrote:Not clearly better, based on team construction, team performance, career success:
Stevens
Hollins
Clifford
Blatt
Shaw
Kerr (rookie coach, GSW success mostly due to the quality of their players)
Vogel (Everyone was riding him, but look at Indy. They lost George and Lance, but to go from 1st to a 16-30 record?)
Scott
Spoelstra
Kidd
Saunders
Williams
Fisher
Brooks
Vaughn
Brown
Hornacek (maybe better)
Stotts
Corbin
Snyder
Wittman
In terms of X's and O's, Spo, Stotts, and Kerr are all better than Casey.
Kerr did benefit by inheriting great roster, but his ability to tweak the offense running a more motion based offense adding sets from the Triangle and etc has made the Warriors offense nearly unstoppable. They're the only team along with the Hawks that mirrors what the Spurs run.
In terms of X's and O's maybe, yes, they are better, but team success is ultimately how we define "better", right? If a guy draws up "stupid" plays all the time, but the team scores 90% of the time, do we call that coach/play a genius, or lucky or bad? What I'm trying to say is that the solution isn't necessarily to fire Casey, or to blame him for JV not getting run in the 4th.
If he was handed GS' roster, I think he'd be hailed as one of the greatest coaches in the league, similar to how you say Kerr, or Budenholzer, or any other coach of a top 15 team in the league is one now A lot of "bad coaching" can be shielded by having a great team. It is a two way street, of course - great coaching can uplift a team - but really, the only "great" coach right now imo is Pop.
Put another way, how many coaches, coaching bottom 15 rosters, do you consider to be top level coaches, coaching bad rosters? SVG couldn't FORCE Detroit to play better than the sum of their parts, until they got rid of Smith...sort of how like we got rid of Gay and suddenly we're better and it goes from Fire Casey to extend Casey. We consider SVG a top 5 coach, but he's had some pretty good talent in his time too. All coaches make mistakes every so often - having a great team makes those potential mistakes in judgment, fewer and farther between.
If JV went into beast mode every single game, every possession, Casey would certainly play him in the 4th. I have no doubt. Do I want to see JV play more? Yes. Do I understand why Casey might not trust the guy quite yet, yes. JV is still young, he makes mistakes at a high rate. He's going to be good, but Casey is focused on winning, and when every possession matters, he'd rather give the ball to some others to get a win. I can understand that, and think that is generally the norm.