Amish Mafioso wrote:Hard to criticize MJ when we know the results of his leadership.
It shouldn't be though, it's utter naivety to think that Jordan knew exactly what he was doing and was pushing each player in just the way that was needed despite all indications that his approach resembled less an effective CEO and more an abusive father.
Jordan has an excellent case as the GOAT because of myriad huge things in his benefit - and yes some of those things involved his alpha personality. Where we get into trouble with him in a historical context is when people basically refuse to acknowledge that something that looked stupid involving him probably was stupid and instead build a narrative around it and worship it like the shroud of Turin.
I think Parish's anecdote here is a pretty clear cut thing. Parish is older than Jordan and had been a vital part of elite teams for years, and he's also bigger than Jordan. Jordan's approach here isn't any kind of "crazy like a fox" thing, it's a guy who simply gets angry and yells at people when they make a mistake, and then gets angrier and yells louder if they don't cower, and then hits the people in question unless they are bigger than he is. An interaction like this doesn't make anyone on that team think "Wow, Jordan knows what he's doing.", they just always know that Jordan's the best player on the planet, and so sometimes he'll act ridiculous and the coach won't do anything about it. Find a way to deal with that or you don't get to play on the best player's team.