Quake Griffin wrote:Neddy wrote:Ranma wrote:Howie Kendrick is near the top of the standard defensive metrics with a high fielding percentage, but it is surprising to see his rating and ranking drop so low in the advance metrics, especially considering our front office supposedly have liked him for a while due to sabermetrics. Also, it's funny to see Dee Gordon atop the advanced rankings but near the middle in the standard rankings.
I still miss Dee and, to be honest, a big part of me still wishes we hadn't traded him even though we got a big haul for him, including Howie.
I don't, and I'll tell you why.
Howie in 10 years in the bigs, posted better than average OPS+ 70% of the time and this year is no exception. he is also hitting the long ball at the pace of his prime and well on his way to justify his spot in the lineup. Dee is hitting above 100 OPS+ for the first time in his career, and has failed more than 25 % of the time with his SB attempts. yeah Dee is right now looking about 0.020 points better in OPS, but he has not proven to keep his production deep into a season, and Kendrick has. I really don't care if Dee steals 60 bases this season, he will have more than 20 CS and in the end he still can't get on bases unless he hits. not a good formula for success. If and When Dee goes on a slump, you get nothing in return.
besides, Dee's advance stat stud-ness comes from the same sample size that made Kershaw lead the league in HRs per FB ratio. I just don't buy into the validity of that measurement.
Any explanation for Howie's poor defensive metrics?
I pretty much agree on the Dee commentary. He will slump and he will come down to earth because he only hits his way on.
But we were supposed to be getting the whole package in Howie. Why are his defensive metrics so poor according to fangraphs? Or is it nothing to worry about? Small sample size?
he still performs at a decent level defensively, it's not like we got Steve Sax throwing for first base and landing it on upper deck.
Defensive stats require a very large sample size to make a reasonable judgement, a half a season is not going to give you an accurate picture but even if what's shown so far is who Howie has become, I would guess the father time is finally catching up with him at least on the field. I am not so worried about that tho. we have a logjam in infield the way we did last year with the outfield. next year, we will still have Turner/Seager/Oliveras/Gonzo/****/Guerrero still in the mix, and Sweeney/Torreyes in the minors. I just don't see us resigning Howie, and Jimmy will probably just retire.
althougn last mornings conclusion of the suspended game was directly impacted by him losing the ball in the sun, it wasn't Jose Conseco bad... it happens.
for this year, Kendrick is still doing just fine.
missing Dee is understandable, he was a very likable kid, with Magic-like smile on his face in every interview. great story of a home grown player too. but I get very frustrated watching players who can't get on base unless they hit, a la Juan Encarnacion/Juan Pierre types... or the entire current Seattle Mariners.
ehhhhh f it.