SideshowBob wrote:RebelWithACause wrote:Why is Curry clearly below LeBron, Jordan and Shaq at their peak ( I think you have them at +8, LeBron at 8.5?!)
Shouldn't he be equal or even better as of now?
I have peak Lebron below both Shaq (better portability due to defense) and Jordan (health; 100% vs. 95% RS), all three at +8. Don't think Curry's combination of offense and defense makes him a better player than those guys at their peaks, but his offense alone is in a different stratosphere and at worst is slightly better than current GOAT level offense (Magic 87).RSCD3_ wrote:Where does that fall with your peaks lists, Were the seasons of 09 LeBron/91 Jordan/00 Shaq all 8's?
00 Shaq +5.50 O | +2.50 D | +8.00
91 Jordan +6.50 O | +1.50 D | +8.00
90 Jordan +6.50 O | +1.50 D | +8.00
13 James +5.75 O | +2.25 D | +8.00
10 James +6.00 O | +2.00 D | +8.00
92 Jordan +6.50 O | +1.75 D | +7.75 << Curry fits in right after here, maybe higher after the postseason as I'll hone-in a little more
93 Jordan +6.50 O | +1.00 D | +7.50
09 James +5.50 O | +2.00 D | +7.50
89 Jordan +6.25 O | +1.25 D | +7.50
01 Shaq +5.50 O | +2.00 D | +7.50
One season per player he's looking at the #4 spot.
I'm not familiar with this metric. What is it and why are you allowed to just estimate the numbers? Is it selfmade or something?