Kerrsed wrote:letsgosuns wrote:This is the offer I would give for Butler: 4th pick, 28th pick, and Knight. I would consider adding Goodwin or maybe the rights to Bogdanovich. I absolutely would not give up Len or Warren. The reason why is because the Suns are nowhere near a contender. They are not even close. If they give up a massive package for Butler (who is not Lebron or Durant), they will have nothing left and the team will still suck. And you cannot bank on the Suns being able to sign better free agents just because of Butler's presence on the roster.
Then think about this. Knight averages 20 ppg, 5 ast, and 4 rbs. He shoots 42% fg and 34% 3 pts. Butler averages 21 ppg, 5 ast, and 5 rbs. He shoots 45% fg and 31% 3 pts. Their per game stats are nearly identical. Knight is also over two years younger. So the Suns are giving the Bulls an immediate replacement for Butler. Most other teams cannot do that. So they get their replacement for Butler who is 24 and the fourth pick in the draft, plus another first round pick.
Now the package can be flexible such as if they do not want the 28th pick, maybe you offer the 2018 top-7 protected Miami pick or something. However, I do not offer them some kind of insane package like picks 4 and 13, Knight, Len, and Goodwin or Warren. That is nuts.
You forgot to add in that Knight is a defensive juggernaut just like Butler and a 2X All-star like Butler.......![]()
Look, Knight averaged what he did as a PG (aka ball in his hands whenever he wanted it) on a horrible team (4th worst). Butler did it as a 3rd option BEHIND Rose and Gasol. Look at the usage ratings. Knight was our top guy and Butler was below both Rose and Gasol. He also did it on a Bulls team that BARELY missed the playoffs. So Calling Knight a "immediate replacement" is laughable.
Now i agree with you on not offering #4/#13/Knight/Len/Goodwin or Warren, but if the #13 pick was removed and we kept Warren, i would take it.
As for being nowhere near a contender, it all has to start somewhere. Having Bledsoe/Booker/Butler all locked in for the next 4 years is a damn good start to being a contender. Trading a unknown player (#4), a spare PG (Knight) and a young big with potential that he has yet to realize (Len) for a young 2X All-star and 2X All NBA Defensive Team member is a no brainer for me.
I would probably do 4, 28, Knight, and Warren if he is the deal breaker but I am extremely hesitant to give up Len. He is only 22. The thought of him becoming an all star center one day and doing it on another team would be horrible for the Suns. Every team in the league wants a young 7 foot big man and the Suns already have it. With the lack of quality centers in the league, Len would probably get a max contract from a team if he was a free agent this offseason. The Suns control him for at least the next five years too since he will be a restricted free agent. It is just too much to give up.