bws94 wrote:Roy Tarpley wrote:bws94 wrote:
Well, you're not that big on Lin then. I think Lin is the one with the most intangibles. Numbers aside, when the team needed someone to step up big and come through for them in big spots, Lin did it most, followed by Marv. I think then Lee and Batum is last. Lin isn't that easy to replace. Houston still hasn't replaced him.
We won 3 playoffs games where Lin was a huge contributor, a game against Spurs we had no right winning due to Lin going nuts, Boston Lin having an insane quarter, Cavs game with Kemba out Lin and MKG combining to upset the mighty Cavs. All big teams, all Lin stepping up. Not everyone, even with good stats, can do that. I actually like a JJ Barea for Lin, but he doesn't have Lin's D and height.
I agree with Yosemiteben that Lin is the most easily replaceable from a numbers standpoint. There are surely other backup PGs out there that can give you 41% FG and 33% 3PT and 20 minutes/game. There is, however, a "potential" and a set of intangibles that Lin has that is hard to replace. The ability to step up big in big games, the ability to be explosive when necessary, plus his character and team-focused mindset.
I think this is a moot point though because from a team standpoint, the Hornets need to lock down their starting SG and PF before thinking about backup Gs. The team simply cannot afford to give too much money to a backup G.
My argument would be Lin played the essential role of 3rd facilitator on the team. The thing with Lin is, he wasn't a back-up PG. He only played PG about 36 percent when he was on the floor. He was a 6th man combo guard. If you look at him as a backup PG you're missing out on the real function he had on this team. And that was to be a rotational guy and a huge insurance for when Batum couldn't play or play well. He almost always was able to contribute well with doing what it took, be it scoring, facilitating, being another slasher with Kemba, etc. and playing good D, to help the team win. It's not his point guard skills that were that noticeable, except maybe in the game against the Cavs Kemba was out, but his ability to step in and do so many things that helped that team win. And he did that during the playoffs in a big way, and helped get Clifford 3 wins.
That is what is not easily replaceable. Seeing Lin as a "backup PG" is a mistake, that's not really the role he played on the team. And i'ts exactly that which is what the Houston Rockets hasn't replaced on their team. Lin was a similar combo guard off the bench his second season on Houston.
It's all well and good to say others can step in so Lin is not needed but why? We know what he can do. IMO, he should be the second most important FA to sign, and not for any MLE either. For real money. If possible. If it's impossible fine. But at least acknowledge the big part Lin played on the team last season. He was a really important piece of the puzzle, and only missed 3 or 4 games.
As a Lin fan for 5 years, I am already used to Lin being treated as second class citizen, and not have his contributions acknowledged. To be frank, Charlotte media and fans had been much better than the Houston counter parts. If you have to argue with anyone who does not see eye to eye with you regarding any Lin issue, you either just become a Lin fan recently, or you will lose years of your life due to anger/blood pressure related issues.
Regardless of how people assess his game or his on court contributions, he is proving all doubters wrong over time.
Before Linsanity, he is not even relevant in the NBA, despite out playing John Wall in summer league, he goes undrafted.
During Linsanity, he is a "flash in the pan", and a "scrub" who has no chance to sustain his success in the NBA.
With Houston, he "cannot play off the ball" and is such a "defensive liability" playing with Harden, he "needs" Pbev to save his ass.
With Lakers, he "cannot hold his starting job" over Ronnie Fking Price. And people blame their losing record on JLin.
With Hornets, he got a chance to play and not get iced or benched unfairly(at least not nearly as much), and showed his ability to contribute when given the chance. Thus showing the league his worth on the court, even though us Lin fans all knew he is capable of much more if given the starting opportunity.
If you have been following Lin for as long as I have or longer, you should have been used to doubters, and you should have known to not argue with every single one of them when it happens. It's not going to change their opinion. We will see how Lin decides to approach this upcoming Free Agency. Life is never fair for someone like Lin, a minority in a sports that's definitely not dominated by players of Asian decent.
If he stays with Hornets on a deep discount, then I wish him the best of luck; but if he gets a chance to start for ANY team, we will then see what he is really made of, and how good a player he really is.