Oden2 wrote:Wizenheimer wrote:Oden2 wrote:
Personally I prefer crabbe at the same price due to his 3 point shooting ability & defense
what defense? Harkless is a much, much better defender then Crabbe
Crabbe was an underrated perimeter defender. Haven't looked at advanced statistics though to be honest.
who is underrating him and how?
look at some of the team numbers:
defensive rating:
Ed Davis 104
Mason Plumlee 104
Cliff Alexander 107
Noah Vonleh 107
Al-Farouq Aminu 107
Maurice Harkless 108
Tim Frazier 109
Meyers Leonard 109
Gerald Henderson 109
Chris Kaman 110
Allen Crabbe 110
Damian Lillard 110
C.J. McCollum 110
this is a team-centric stat more then an individual one. Portland's team rating was 108. Harkless matched the team rating, Crabbe was 2 points worse
Defensive Win Shares:
1 Mason Plumlee 2.7
2 Ed Davis 2.3
3 Al-Farouq Aminu 2.3
6 Maurice Harkless 1.3
7 Allen Crabbe 1.2
raw win shares are cumulative stats. Crabbe played 2105 minutes while Harkless played 1457. The fact that Harkless topped Crabbe in def win shares only playing 2/3 the minutes is kind of revealing
Defensive Box Plus/Minus:
1 Mason Plumlee 3.0
2 Ed Davis 2.5
3 Al-Farouq Aminu 0.7
4 Maurice Harkless 0.2
7 Meyers Leonard -1.0
8 Allen Crabbe -1.1
then there are the league-wide DRPM stats. Harkless finished 36th among 81 SF's with a DRPM of -0.02. Crabbe finished 84th among 96 SG's with a DRPM of -2.58
the only thing I've seen Crabbe do well defensively is that he does get his hands in passing lanes. He deflects some balls and gets some steals, but Harkless actually averaged more steals/36 and had a higher steal rate. Harkless also more then tripled Crabbe's blocked shot rate, but that's to be expected
I mentioned this yesterday in another thread, but in the Golden State series, in game 1, the Blazers tried to guard Klay Thompson with CJ and Crabbe. The result was Klay scored 37 point and had 5 assists. After that game, the Blazers put Harkless on Thompson and tried to hide Cj & Crabbe on less dynamic scorers
I can understand if you prefer Crabbe because of 3-point shooting. But defensively, it's all Harkless












