HotelVitale wrote:zeebneeb wrote:Daddy 801 wrote:Nationalism at sporting events makes me want to puke. The national anthem shouldn't be sung. I don't stand and sing as a spectator at events and I wouldn't be standing if I was a player. I have respect for any player willing to go through the backlash of ignorant fans who will say stupid crap like "if you don't love America why don't you leave?". Unfortunately America is full of these people.
Why does it make you want to puke? It's an American league, on American soil, and they play the national anthem of the leagues home base. Loving your country is vomitous to you? It's not ignorant to be angry at someone who hates their own country, or does something that seems to belittle the country they love...
Daddy didn't phrase this too well, but patriotism doesn't make any sense: it makes sense to love your family and some people in your neighborhood and some other folks you know, and it makes sense to dislike and even hate things that seem to threaten it in idea or reality. But saying 'I love and would die for the country I happened to be born in' is a weird irrational thing. I'm sure you know there weren't really nations or countries before like the 1500s, and that countries developed as basically just economic and military entities; the idea of 'rights' for the non-ruling classes only came around in the 1700s, when the economy was getting much more complex and large amount of non-aristocrats started to have money, status, etc and started claiming that they deserved a say in government.
Anyway, point is that 'patriotism' for your country isn't a natural impulse or anything, and it makes a WHOLE lot more sense logically to say you like your family and friends and whatever else but are critical of what some other people in your country do. When most people say they 'love their country' they actually mean a certain vision or ideal of what it is, not that they love every part of the country and every person and system within it.
Also, I only heard about a minute of Kaepernick's lockerroom speech (it was pretty boring) but he was explicit about saying 'this country is supposed to stand for liberty and justice and it's not doing its job.' In other words, he 'loves' the ideas behind the nation and doesn't think the people in charge of carrying them out are doing their job. Not a super advanced critique but it's not unpatriotic, and it's exactly why the ideals behind the declaration and constitution exist.
It is absolutely not irrational to say "I live and would die for my country" as its a country your family and friends live in, and affords safety and a place to raise your family without fear. It's defending that which affords you and yours saftey.
Without borders and nations (this isn't the 1500's) we would have villages and warlords.
Nationalism is the heart of modern society and the very reason we are having a discussion on a messege board and not running from the next angry horde that would cut us down in the night. Does it have its problems? Yes, but let's not be disingenuous and pretend it's bad, or illogical to want to protect those rights, and safeties this country affords that many absolutely do not.
Modern liberalism has completely lost the plot, and pretending that the world would come together and sing kumbaya and not butcher each other mercilessly is pure and utter nonsense.
pure and utter nonsense.