Post#249 » by I_Like_Dirt » Tue Sep 20, 2016 9:25 pm
I'm not convinced that it will work out for the best, but I get what the Magic are trying to do. As a team, they were really in a position where they needed to pick their guys and decide who they believed in long term the most. I don't think it was realistic for them to keep all 3 of Fournier, Oladipo and Hezonja - they really needed to settle on who they believed had the best potential as starters long term. I also don't think it was particularly realistic to keep Oladipo and Payton as both guys are so ball dominant and while Oladipo can shoot a bit, he isn't even really a good shooter and the combination of the two makes for a somewhat problematic pair unless they stock shooting up front, which they would have to give up assets to get in the first place, particularly given Aaron Gordon and now Biyombo offering nothing in the way of spacing up front. Same goes for Harris, who I think they overpaid for a bit last offseason, yet he stood right in the way of Fournier, Hezonja and Gordon.
Could the Magic have gotten more for their players? I tend to think they overpaid in a rather bad way, but I do also realize that they were in tough, because not many teams are actively looking to trade the best player in a trade, particularly not if they aren't willing to take on bad attitudes or the like, which can be a dangerous game on such a young team. And basically almost any player they take back tends to get in the way of another player they want to give an opportunity to. Even Ibaka basically immediately puts Gordon in a tough spot this upcoming season, although Ibaka sliding and becoming a free agent may not worry them so much if they believe in Gordon.
What makes or breaks the Magic here is if they bet on the right guys. Would they have been better off keeping some of the guys they traded and instead dumping some of their less proven guys who may never be as good as the guys they moved? It's tough to say, but personally I tend to think the Magic got it right on Harris, not that he's a bad player, because he definitely isn't, but he's more of a Jeff Green/Rudy Gay type player who isn't quite as good as his volume stats would suggest. Oladipo, I like a little more, but I also feel he's a touch overrated at this point; he isn't a PG and he isn't a great SG, either - he's more of a utility guy than a star. That said, while I like Fournier, Gordon, Hezonja, Payton, etc. to varying degrees, I don't see any bigtime stars there, either. If I'm wrong, the Magic will come out fine. If I'm right, the Magic might have been in a situation where they didn't really have any good options and chose to wipe some of the slate clean, which is a danger in rebuilding.
Personally, I see the Magic and Bucks as modern versions of the old school Clippers teams with Odom, QRich, Maggette, Brand, etc. who never quite put things together despite a lot of so called experts loving them every year. In terms of trying to win this coming season, I like what the Magic have done more. I see more floor spacing on their wings where the Bucks just have Middleton, and while Giannis is really good, he's very much in the vicinity of a young Odom, or a young Kirilenko with less defense. I like Payton more than MCW, although I think they have similar weaknesses. And while the Bucks have scoring up front in Parker and Monroe, Vucevic isn't half bad, and Biyombo/Ibaka/Gordon is a lot better on the defensive side of things. I'm not sure the Magic make the playoffs, but they should have good interior defense and reasonable wing play on both sides of the ball. Their season is probably make or break on the play of Payton and Fournier, though, and I'm not sure I believe in Payton enough at this point.
Bucket! Bucket!