Johnny Firpo wrote:There are plenty of examples for pure skill players becoming superstars, stars, All-Stars in the NBA without being elite athletes. Mullin, Bird, Pierce (definitely older Pierce), Nash, Gasol, Dirk, Kukoc, Stojakovic, NBA Sabonis, Andre Miller, etc, etc. You could go on and on. Your problem is of course is not unusual, you think athleticism equals jumping the highest and being the most explosive imaginable, even though fluidity and coordination are actually much more important.
I completely agree with you in general, however, some of these guys are actually extremely athletically talented, just in different ways. For example, Gasol, Dirk & Kukoc are/were capable of doing some pretty remarkable things for their heights. You could also argue that Nash had great athleticism, just not the things that usually stand out.
Pierce can be used as a very nice example, Doncic is quite similar to him, same for Mullin. Doncic is basically a Pierce-Mullin mix.
Andre Miller is interesting also because Doncic already appears to be extremely strong, posting up grown men at 17. He's also crafty under the basket, so if he can perfect this in a way Andre Miller did, it can become his bread and butter. Imagine Andre Miller with a very nice shooting ability ... absolutely deadly.
That's also why I don't think there's any real chance (disregarding injuries, obviously) of Doncic being a bust. His strength and body control are always going to allow him to bully himself to points (or nice passess), one way or another. He's not going to be overpowered (something that happened to otherwise skilled players who ended up being busts).