shangrila wrote:Uh, no, I'd say that's pretty far from being equivalent. Chris Paul changing positions is not at all equal to asking Rubio to stand in a corner and hit 3s at a decent clip. Not even remotely similar.
And this is the problem with Rubio, ever since he joined the league really; his skillset has been so narrow that doing anything other than letting him completely dominate the ball on offence renders him useless. He can't hit 3s, he can't hit layups, he can't post up against other PGs, he doesn't make off ball cuts, etc. Once the ball has left his hands he might as well go chill out in the front row because he's not going to be doing much else. I mean, notice how far out of your way you had to go to come up with a scenario where another good player was similarly handicapped?
Don't get me wrong, he's playing very well lately and I hope it continues. But to act like his early season struggles were entirely on Thibs is just too much. He was bad early on, some of it from the role Thibs gave him, some of it from his own struggles.
LOL. I didn't *have to* go that far to present a similar scenario, I chose to. Nice try though.
It's absurd to say that Rubio is useless without the ball in his hands just because he hasn't been a reliable scorer through his career. And this is a problem we see each and every day in the Wolves board, year after year, with a group of you. It's made debating anything completely pointless, whether it's about Ricky, Wiggins, KAT, LaVine... you name it. First of, you're taking half the game, which is defense, out of the equation, which is foolish to a fault, and it's even worse when it comes from a Timberwolves fan, considering how Minnesota's defense has sucked for years and how the Wolves keep the longest running playoff drought in the league. Then you're forgetting about basically every aspect of an offense that doesn't count as an assist or a made shot.
Rubio is often in motion so he can draw a defender to a certain place (cause no, nobody is letting him run around the court just forgetting about him cause he's not a scorer), receive a hand-off from a big like Dieng, or give Wiggins an out when he picks up his dribble, even if he then passes the ball and doesn't hold onto it, just to keep the offense moving. That's not dominating an offense, but it's also not sitting someone in a corner like these are the Spurs in the mid 2000s and he's a 36 year old Bruce Bowen. Then you have him setting screens for Wiggins (and doing a damned good job at it), which is extremely common when they're both operating at the top of the key while one big stays inside and the other (usually Gorgui) goes to a corner. He now is once again able to position everyone into the offense (since Thibs is not calling the plays anymore) even when he doesn't have the ball, as he's always directing guys not just on defense but on both ends of the court (of course you would have to pay attention to see that and understand what you can do on the floor to lead a team beyond scoring, which plenty of people don't). There's also this thing called offensive rebounding, where he's one of the best in the league (currently 6th among starting PGs in OREB%) and often comes away with clutch extra possessions.
There's a ton of things that go into a basketball game in both ends of the floor, a lot of things happening all the time, but unfortunately for a lot of people it all comes down to what happens on one end, and then you reduce it to passing (or better yet, assists), shooting (or rather scoring averages), and rebounding (if you're talking about a big guy, otherwise everybody knows it's not really that important).
That's an extremely shortsighted take on this sport, but at this point I guess it is what it is. Just don't expect to be right about it.
PS: One other thing about Ricky needing to be ball dominant (which is laughable if you ever saw his impact under Adelman). Thibodeau putting the ball in the hands of a different player wasn't the problem. His ISO heavy sets, with Wiggins dominating the ball half the time, stagnating the offense with his inability to run a play or create anything for others, was the key. When you top that with giving strictly a shooting role to a non-shooting player, you have yourself a recipe for disaster. That start of the season cost the Wolves the chance to fight for the playoffs, and it cost them to throw Ricky's value down the drain before the deadline. There's no other way around that.