ImageImage

Grade The Draft

Moderators: fatlever, JDR720, Diop, BigSlam, yosemiteben

Grade

A
24
56%
B
16
37%
C
2
5%
D
0
No votes
F
1
2%
 
Total votes: 43

bes628
Freshman
Posts: 57
And1: 20
Joined: May 10, 2012
   

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#41 » by bes628 » Sat Jun 24, 2017 1:26 am

Can't be anything but an A.
ohara
Head Coach
Posts: 7,237
And1: 167
Joined: May 24, 2008

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#42 » by ohara » Sat Jun 24, 2017 3:12 am

Once we landed Monk, I can't give anything but an A
User avatar
Eoghan
RealGM
Posts: 11,315
And1: 3,293
Joined: May 20, 2009
         

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#43 » by Eoghan » Sat Jun 24, 2017 11:43 pm

Doling out a rare 'A' for me. Monk is great value for us. I'm not a huge Bacon fan but not shedding a tear for any of the guys they passed on for him. Rich Cho should be on a contract year every year, he can actually not **** up a draft when his seat is on fire.
User avatar
Diop
Forum Mod - Hornets
Forum Mod - Hornets
Posts: 40,392
And1: 20,757
Joined: Jul 24, 2004
Location: Diop Dead Ugly
 

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#44 » by Diop » Sun Jun 25, 2017 4:29 am

I had to give them an A as well. Luck or not, they still picked Monk who was first on my wish list.
Image
GlenRiceARoni
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,695
And1: 793
Joined: Nov 29, 2016

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#45 » by GlenRiceARoni » Sun Jun 25, 2017 9:17 am

A+

We got the guy i think ends up being a top 5 player from this draft class and could end being an elite scorer. Obviously hes not a guaranteed hall of famer like lonzo ball, but monk is really being slept on if his knees arent awful.

I got Ball, Fultz, Monk, Isaac, Markkanen in that order.

Bacon seems like a blah prospect that probably isnt gonna be better than Graham.


This was looking like an 8 man draft class. So we had to hope someone drafted DSJ, Tatum, AND a rando in order to get a good player to slip to us at #11. Unreal the way it worked out. The kings made a huge mistake passing on monk because they had Buddy hield (seriously lol). Instead they trade down for Justin Jackson and Harry Giles, two guys who were debatably not even 1st rd pick worthy. Kings gonna king.


The dwight howard trade is ludicrously an A+. I mean the lakers had to give up deangelo russell just to rid themselves of mozgovs deal. We got rid of plumlee and added DWIGHT FREAKING HOWARD while upgrading our pick. Im still in shock.

This is like bizarro world for our franchise.


"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile
GlenRiceARoni
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,695
And1: 793
Joined: Nov 29, 2016

Re: RE: Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#46 » by GlenRiceARoni » Sun Jun 25, 2017 9:32 am

predators wrote:Honestly grading Basketball drafts is kind of dumb considering its only 2 rounds. And even then 5-9 of the 30 2nd round picks never play a game in the nba, only 5-9 stick long term, and some of those that stick long term were picked up for free from another team after they were cut the first time. (See Whiteside, Danny Green.) There are maybe 1-2 actual eventual NBA rotation players picked in the 2nd round. Draymond Green's are picked in the 2nd round 2-3 times a decade.

There was nobody on this board clamoring for Draymond Green or Jae Crowder when we picked Jeffrey Taylor , we all wanted Quincy Miller who is out of the league (Mac Tel-Aviv). History shows only 1 or 2 guys will really pan out annually beyond an end of the bench player and its almost never the obvious guy that everybody likes. Everyone picked in the 2nd has to fix a serious hole in their game to am You are just as likely to find a contributor that was undrafted as you are in the 2nd round.

Our other sold picks update: Jeremy Tyler is in China, and Juan Pablo Vaulet is still playing in Argentina\isn't looking like a NBA player. I read an article he is hoping to get d-league contract from the Nets. Semaj Christin and Dwight Powell have been bouncing up/down the d-league but with their original teams. Petr Conlie hasn't come over yet.

TLDR: Bumping an entire letter Grade because of the 2nd round is dumb considering how unlikely it is you find a starter there.

You either like Monk or your don't, IMO.

Sadly, i was clamoring for both crowder and draymond. Crowder was #2 and draymond was the #6 prospect rated by the guys i follow for the draft.

Kawhi was #2 i believe as well when we stupidly passed on him

"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile
User avatar
TheKingofSting
RealGM
Posts: 17,830
And1: 2,165
Joined: Jun 24, 2011
       

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#47 » by TheKingofSting » Sun Jun 25, 2017 9:42 am

GlenRiceARoni wrote:A+

We got the guy i think ends up being a top 5 player from this draft class and could end being an elite scorer. Obviously hes not a guaranteed hall of famer like lonzo ball, but monk is really being slept on if his knees arent awful.

I got Ball, Fultz, Monk, Isaac, Markkanen in that order.

Bacon seems like a blah prospect that probably isnt gonna be better than Graham.


This was looking like an 8 man draft class. So we had to hope someone drafted DSJ, Tatum, AND a rando in order to get a good player to slip to us at #11. Unreal the way it worked out. The kings made a huge mistake passing on monk because they had Buddy hield (seriously lol). Instead they trade down for Justin Jackson and Harry Giles, two guys who were debatably not even 1st rd pick worthy. Kings gonna king.


The dwight howard trade is ludicrously an A+. I mean the lakers had to give up deangelo russell just to rid themselves of mozgovs deal. We got rid of plumlee and added DWIGHT FREAKING HOWARD while upgrading our pick. Im still in shock.

This is like bizarro world for our franchise.


"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile


Monk is easily Cho's second best drafted player only behind Kemba, put him on the hot seat every season.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
President of the Quinn Cook Fan Club

Bradley Beal has D Wade potential
BobsBuddy
Bench Warmer
Posts: 1,377
And1: 100
Joined: Jul 27, 2008

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#48 » by BobsBuddy » Sun Jun 25, 2017 10:12 am

:D B- only because MJ decided to add another 3 mil to his net worth. It would have been A+ if we would have kept #31 and drafted the kid from SMU .
chellis
Senior
Posts: 613
And1: 130
Joined: Jan 06, 2016
 

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#49 » by chellis » Sun Jun 25, 2017 10:24 am

GlenRiceARoni wrote:A+

We got the guy i think ends up being a top 5 player from this draft class and could end being an elite scorer. Obviously hes not a guaranteed hall of famer like lonzo ball, but monk is really being slept on if his knees arent awful.

I got Ball, Fultz, Monk, Isaac, Markkanen in that order.

Bacon seems like a blah prospect that probably isnt gonna be better than Graham.


This was looking like an 8 man draft class. So we had to hope someone drafted DSJ, Tatum, AND a rando in order to get a good player to slip to us at #11. Unreal the way it worked out. The kings made a huge mistake passing on monk because they had Buddy hield (seriously lol). Instead they trade down for Justin Jackson and Harry Giles, two guys who were debatably not even 1st rd pick worthy. Kings gonna king.


The dwight howard trade is ludicrously an A+. I mean the lakers had to give up deangelo russell just to rid themselves of mozgovs deal. We got rid of plumlee and added DWIGHT FREAKING HOWARD while upgrading our pick. Im still in shock.

This is like bizarro world for our franchise.


"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile


Dude I LOLed at this. This is extreme calling Jackson a debatable first round talent/worthy. Giles I can accept based on injury history, but if his medicals checked out then he's definitely worth a flier in the 20-30 range. I understand you're happy, but c'mon don't be absurd.

Edit: fixing autocorrect
GlenRiceARoni
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,695
And1: 793
Joined: Nov 29, 2016

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#50 » by GlenRiceARoni » Sun Jun 25, 2017 10:25 am

Its hard to really get upset about selling the pick if he is gonna use the money as a fraction of the offset on dwight and a MLE addition. Dont forget we have a trade exception as well.

Jackson was years from helping and we have briante and Cat scratch Barber

"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile
chellis
Senior
Posts: 613
And1: 130
Joined: Jan 06, 2016
 

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#51 » by chellis » Sun Jun 25, 2017 10:28 am

BobsBuddy wrote::D B- only because MJ decided to add another 3 mil to his net worth. It would have been A+ if we would have kept #31 and drafted the kid from SMU .


I'm sure MJ wished he got $3M. I believe I read pick 31 was sold for $1.2M and pick 40.
GlenRiceARoni
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,695
And1: 793
Joined: Nov 29, 2016

Re: RE: Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#52 » by GlenRiceARoni » Sun Jun 25, 2017 3:54 pm

chellis wrote:
GlenRiceARoni wrote:A+

We got the guy i think ends up being a top 5 player from this draft class and could end being an elite scorer. Obviously hes not a guaranteed hall of famer like lonzo ball, but monk is really being slept on if his knees arent awful.

I got Ball, Fultz, Monk, Isaac, Markkanen in that order.

Bacon seems like a blah prospect that probably isnt gonna be better than Graham.


This was looking like an 8 man draft class. So we had to hope someone drafted DSJ, Tatum, AND a rando in order to get a good player to slip to us at #11. Unreal the way it worked out. The kings made a huge mistake passing on monk because they had Buddy hield (seriously lol). Instead they trade down for Justin Jackson and Harry Giles, two guys who were debatably not even 1st rd pick worthy. Kings gonna king.


The dwight howard trade is ludicrously an A+. I mean the lakers had to give up deangelo russell just to rid themselves of mozgovs deal. We got rid of plumlee and added DWIGHT FREAKING HOWARD while upgrading our pick. Im still in shock.

This is like bizarro world for our franchise.


"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile


Dude I LOLed at this. This is extreme calling Jackson a debatable first round talent/worthy. Giles I can accept based on injury history, but if his medicals checked out then he's definitely worth a flier in the 20-30 range. I understand you're happy, but c'mon don't be absurd.

Edit: fixing autocorrect

Jackson is definitely a debatable first round pick.

22 year old who couldn't hit a college 3 until this year. Low steals and rebounds. Slight frame. Very Low upside player. Very unlikely to be an impact player and not definitively good enough to crack a rotation.

"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile
Braggins
RealGM
Posts: 14,479
And1: 9,275
Joined: Jan 05, 2014

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#53 » by Braggins » Sun Jun 25, 2017 5:02 pm

I couldnt bring myself to give an A just because of how obviously silly our handling of the 2nd round was. So B+ for me.
chellis
Senior
Posts: 613
And1: 130
Joined: Jan 06, 2016
 

Re: RE: Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#54 » by chellis » Sun Jun 25, 2017 5:15 pm

GlenRiceARoni wrote:
chellis wrote:
GlenRiceARoni wrote:A+

We got the guy i think ends up being a top 5 player from this draft class and could end being an elite scorer. Obviously hes not a guaranteed hall of famer like lonzo ball, but monk is really being slept on if his knees arent awful.

I got Ball, Fultz, Monk, Isaac, Markkanen in that order.

Bacon seems like a blah prospect that probably isnt gonna be better than Graham.


This was looking like an 8 man draft class. So we had to hope someone drafted DSJ, Tatum, AND a rando in order to get a good player to slip to us at #11. Unreal the way it worked out. The kings made a huge mistake passing on monk because they had Buddy hield (seriously lol). Instead they trade down for Justin Jackson and Harry Giles, two guys who were debatably not even 1st rd pick worthy. Kings gonna king.


The dwight howard trade is ludicrously an A+. I mean the lakers had to give up deangelo russell just to rid themselves of mozgovs deal. We got rid of plumlee and added DWIGHT FREAKING HOWARD while upgrading our pick. Im still in shock.

This is like bizarro world for our franchise.


"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile


Dude I LOLed at this. This is extreme calling Jackson a debatable first round talent/worthy. Giles I can accept based on injury history, but if his medicals checked out then he's definitely worth a flier in the 20-30 range. I understand you're happy, but c'mon don't be absurd.

Edit: fixing autocorrect

Jackson is definitely a debatable first round pick.

22 year old who couldn't hit a college 3 until this year. Low steals and rebounds. Slight frame. Very Low upside player. Very unlikely to be an impact player and not definitively good enough to crack a rotation.

"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile


Well, that's your opinion. I respectfully disagree. I'm not going to get into a debate as I believe your opinions on him aren't going to change since you hold such a negative view of him.

I see his improvement as his willingness to take constructive criticism of his game and work on improving. Will he be an All-Star. I don't think so, but I do think He should have a fine career in the league in a team's rotation.
GlenRiceARoni
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,695
And1: 793
Joined: Nov 29, 2016

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#55 » by GlenRiceARoni » Sun Jun 25, 2017 5:55 pm

I think most of his improvement comes from being a 22 yo playing against high school players.

He's miles behind jeremy lamb as a scorer and rebounder and lamb was a fringe rotation player for a non playoff team last year

"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile
Mystical Apples
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,393
And1: 1,349
Joined: Jul 06, 2015
 

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#56 » by Mystical Apples » Sun Jun 25, 2017 6:06 pm

GlenRiceARoni wrote:I think most of his improvement comes from being a 22 yo playing against high school players.

He's miles behind jeremy lamb as a scorer and rebounder and lamb was a fringe rotation player for a non playoff team last year

"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile


Yeah I had Justin Jackson in the 30's.
geometry
predators
Senior
Posts: 744
And1: 319
Joined: Jun 13, 2014
     

Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#57 » by predators » Mon Jun 26, 2017 2:06 pm

MPM wrote:
predators wrote:Honestly grading Basketball drafts is kind of dumb considering its only 2 rounds. And even then 5-9 of the 30 2nd round picks never play a game in the nba, only 5-9 stick long term, and some of those that stick long term were picked up for free from another team after they were cut the first time. (See Whiteside, Danny Green.) There are maybe 1-2 actual eventual NBA rotation players picked in the 2nd round. Draymond Green's are picked in the 2nd round 2-3 times a decade.

There was nobody on this board clamoring for Draymond Green or Jae Crowder when we picked Jeffrey Taylor , we all wanted Quincy Miller who is out of the league (Mac Tel-Aviv). History shows only 1 or 2 guys will really pan out annually beyond an end of the bench player and its almost never the obvious guy that everybody likes. Everyone picked in the 2nd has to fix a serious hole in their game to am You are just as likely to find a contributor that was undrafted as you are in the 2nd round.

Our other sold picks update: Jeremy Tyler is in China, and Juan Pablo Vaulet is still playing in Argentina\isn't looking like a NBA player. I read an article he is hoping to get d-league contract from the Nets. Semaj Christin and Dwight Powell have been bouncing up/down the d-league but with their original teams. Petr Conlie hasn't come over yet.

TLDR: Bumping an entire letter Grade because of the 2nd round is dumb considering how unlikely it is you find a starter there.

You either like Monk or your don't, IMO.


Completely respect your viewpoint - it's understandable - but I have a different take. If excellence on the court (or in business) is your goal, you do whatever it takes to increase your chances of success - despite the odds. Meaning, despite knowing that only a few second rounders will pan out as solid rotation players (and I think most on this board understand this), you still do whatever you can to increase your chances of landing one of those assets. Selling a 31 for a 40 does not accomplish this. I think the approach is what irks people - it's not a winning approach. It doesn't strive, it settles.



I get that sentiment, but my point is Bacon is just as likely to be the 2nd round steal as the guys we passed on. Look at how ridiculous the Draymond Green Draft express profile looks now.

Unfortunately, Green's defensive deficiencies have become even more pronounced as a senior. At 6'7, he is too small to guard elite post players, and lacks the lateral quickness to defend perimeter players, even face-up power forwards at the NCAA level. While his effort and aggressiveness will never be questioned, it is difficult to project him as an adequate NBA defender at this time. - Source: http://www.draftexpress.com/profile/Draymond-Green-5859/ ©DraftExpress
DoItALL9
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,918
And1: 1,336
Joined: Oct 08, 2016
       

Re: RE: Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#58 » by DoItALL9 » Mon Jun 26, 2017 4:23 pm

MPM wrote:
predators wrote:Honestly grading Basketball drafts is kind of dumb considering its only 2 rounds. And even then 5-9 of the 30 2nd round picks never play a game in the nba, only 5-9 stick long term, and some of those that stick long term were picked up for free from another team after they were cut the first time. (See Whiteside, Danny Green.) There are maybe 1-2 actual eventual NBA rotation players picked in the 2nd round. Draymond Green's are picked in the 2nd round 2-3 times a decade.

There was nobody on this board clamoring for Draymond Green or Jae Crowder when we picked Jeffrey Taylor , we all wanted Quincy Miller who is out of the league (Mac Tel-Aviv). History shows only 1 or 2 guys will really pan out annually beyond an end of the bench player and its almost never the obvious guy that everybody likes. Everyone picked in the 2nd has to fix a serious hole in their game to am You are just as likely to find a contributor that was undrafted as you are in the 2nd round.

Our other sold picks update: Jeremy Tyler is in China, and Juan Pablo Vaulet is still playing in Argentina\isn't looking like a NBA player. I read an article he is hoping to get d-league contract from the Nets. Semaj Christin and Dwight Powell have been bouncing up/down the d-league but with their original teams. Petr Conlie hasn't come over yet.

TLDR: Bumping an entire letter Grade because of the 2nd round is dumb considering how unlikely it is you find a starter there.

You either like Monk or your don't, IMO.


Completely respect your viewpoint - it's understandable - but I have a different take. If excellence on the court (or in business) is your goal, you do whatever it takes to increase your chances of success - despite the odds. Meaning, despite knowing that only a few second rounders will pan out as solid rotation players (and I think most on this board understand this), you still do whatever you can to increase your chances of landing one of those assets. Selling a 31 for a 40 does not accomplish this. I think the approach is what irks people - it's not a winning approach. It doesn't strive, it settles.

Estimate what're the percentage differences between finding that person at #40 vs #31? It seems to be negligible.

& At that point maybe the cash difference gives the team a better shot at improving statistically (if used towards it obviously)
Not even necessarily roster but maybe shooting coach, injury specialist, dietician etc.
DoItALL9
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,918
And1: 1,336
Joined: Oct 08, 2016
       

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: Grade The Draft 

Post#59 » by DoItALL9 » Mon Jun 26, 2017 4:31 pm

GlenRiceARoni wrote:
predators wrote:Honestly grading Basketball drafts is kind of dumb considering its only 2 rounds. And even then 5-9 of the 30 2nd round picks never play a game in the nba, only 5-9 stick long term, and some of those that stick long term were picked up for free from another team after they were cut the first time. (See Whiteside, Danny Green.) There are maybe 1-2 actual eventual NBA rotation players picked in the 2nd round. Draymond Green's are picked in the 2nd round 2-3 times a decade.

There was nobody on this board clamoring for Draymond Green or Jae Crowder when we picked Jeffrey Taylor , we all wanted Quincy Miller who is out of the league (Mac Tel-Aviv). History shows only 1 or 2 guys will really pan out annually beyond an end of the bench player and its almost never the obvious guy that everybody likes. Everyone picked in the 2nd has to fix a serious hole in their game to am You are just as likely to find a contributor that was undrafted as you are in the 2nd round.

Our other sold picks update: Jeremy Tyler is in China, and Juan Pablo Vaulet is still playing in Argentina\isn't looking like a NBA player. I read an article he is hoping to get d-league contract from the Nets. Semaj Christin and Dwight Powell have been bouncing up/down the d-league but with their original teams. Petr Conlie hasn't come over yet.

TLDR: Bumping an entire letter Grade because of the 2nd round is dumb considering how unlikely it is you find a starter there.

You either like Monk or your don't, IMO.

Sadly, i was clamoring for both crowder and draymond. Crowder was #2 and draymond was the #6 prospect rated by the guys i follow for the draft.

Kawhi was #2 i believe as well when we stupidly passed on him

"Get Out the Way, Let the Real F. Ballas thru" - Juvenile

Who do you follow?

Return to Charlotte Hornets