RealGM's Top 15 Wide Receivers of All Time

[Doctor MJ]

The results are complete, so without further ado...



Player (Average vote)
1. Jerry Rice (1.0, unanimous)
2. Don Hutson (3.7)
3. Lance Alworth (4.3)
4. Steve Largent (5.3)
5. Marvin Harrison (5.9)
6. Paul Warfield (7.9)
7. James Lofton (8.0)
8. Torry Holt (8.7*)
9. Raymond Berry (8.7)
10. Cris Carter (10.6)
11. Michael Irvin (11.0)
12. Tim Brown (13.3)
13. Randy Moss (13.6)
14. Lynn Swann (13.7)
15. Andre Reed (14.3)

*-Holt won the tiebreaker over Berry by virtue of being ranked ahead of Barry on the majority of ballots.

Discussion thread here:

http://www.realgm.com/boards/football/v ... .php?t=147

[J.Kim]

I'm highly dissapointed that Charlie Hennigan didn't make the list...

Though, I will keep campaigning for him.

[thierry]

Wheres T.O.??

[High 5]

No Peerless Price? Is this a joke?

[UKF]

Randy Moss ahead of Lynn Swann? Im a bit suprised....

[Basketball Jesus]

I'm highly dissapointed that Charlie Hennigan didn't make the list...

Though, I will keep campaigning for him.

As will I for my pet WR: Don Maynard.

[EG4life]

Give Harrisson two more years and he will be #2. Although i believe Tim Brown should be top 5 aty least

[ElGee]

The results are complete, so without further ado...



Player (Average vote)
1. Jerry Rice (1.0, unanimous)
2. Don Hutson (3.7)
3. Lance Alworth (4.3)
4. Steve Largent (5.3)
5. Marvin Harrison (5.9)
6. Paul Warfield (7.9)
7. James Lofton (8.0)
8. Torry Holt (8.7*)
9. Raymond Berry (8.7)
10. Cris Carter (10.6)
11. Michael Irvin (11.0)
12. Tim Brown (13.3)
13. Randy Moss (13.6)
14. Lynn Swann (13.7)
15. Andre Reed (14.3)

*-Holt won the tiebreaker over Berry by virtue of being ranked ahead of Barry on the majority of ballots.

Discussion thread here:

http://www.realgm.com/boards/football/v ... .php?t=147

The discussion thread link is dead. I'm actually surprised by these results. My list looks fairly different. Kind of a strange list frankly -- I'm wondering if the criteria people used were simply historical production. (Yuck)

[andrewww]

I'm shocked Moss is only 13th on the all time list...

As an example, if you were drafting a team of WR's right now, would you really take Harrison over Moss? I sure as hell wouldn't. Moss is arguably the greatest deep threat in the history of the NFL.

My top 3 would be..

Jerry Rice
Randy Moss
Calvin Johnson

[SkyHookFTW]

This list is a joke...at least number one is correct.

[trex_8063]

I'm not sure some of the people criticizing the list have taken stock that it was voted on before the 2007 season. Particularly everyone noting Randy Moss should be higher: he played FIVE seasons after this list was constructed (one of them a 1st-Team All-Pro year, three of them 1,000+ receiving yard seasons). That's a lot of career tacked on AFTER this list was written.