ImageImageImageImageImage

2017 NFL ROOKIES

Moderators: CalamityX12, MHSL82

Ray_Dogg
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 4,908
And1: 269
Joined: May 09, 2014
       

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#341 » by Ray_Dogg » Wed Sep 19, 2018 8:23 pm

wco81 wrote:So have we seen all we need to see from Solomon Thomas?

#3 pick of the draft, not even playing full time?

Defensive players chosen that high include people like Miller and Rosa and he's showing nothing close to that kind of ability.

You'd expect him to be contributing by now.



Sure if you liked that pick to begin with then you would expect him to be a vastly superior contributor. I myself despised the pick but not even I expected him to be this bad. He literally doesn't fit at any position on our dline. He's not better than anyone ahead of him on our dline except Marsh but these morons have already had Thomas bulk up and he's even stiffer now. The only thing that made sense for him positionally was to try and get lean and work on his movement skills and give him a shot at LEO. Too late for that.
Ray_Dogg
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 4,908
And1: 269
Joined: May 09, 2014
       

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#342 » by Ray_Dogg » Wed Sep 19, 2018 9:24 pm

NinerSickness wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:
Bingo_AlphaMan wrote:This is for Sick:



That was petty nasty. My guy Corey Davis has had a pretty slow start as well. Can't wait to see who does better this year...

...Is Mike Williams a bust already?


Mike WIlliams bouncing back from injury w/ 81 yards week 1.

Corey Davis w/ 62; not bad.

John Ross w/ 1 catch for 3 yards on 2 targets.


NinerSickness
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,555
And1: 341
Joined: Aug 18, 2014
 

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#343 » by NinerSickness » Fri Sep 28, 2018 6:08 am

Just noticed my guy Charles Harris tearing up the league w/ 1 tackle this year.

D-MVP!!!

Image
NinerSickness
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,555
And1: 341
Joined: Aug 18, 2014
 

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#344 » by NinerSickness » Mon Oct 1, 2018 5:17 am

Ray_Dogg wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:
That was petty nasty. My guy Corey Davis has had a pretty slow start as well. Can't wait to see who does better this year...

...Is Mike Williams a bust already?


Mike WIlliams bouncing back from injury w/ 81 yards week 1.

Corey Davis w/ 62; not bad.

John Ross w/ 1 catch for 3 yards on 2 targets.




My guy Corey Davis w/ 9 catches, 161 yards & a TD. He was my favourite WR prospect since the AJ Green / Julio Jones draft.

John Ross had a nice day w/ 2 catches, 52 yards & a TD. :D
NinerSickness
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,555
And1: 341
Joined: Aug 18, 2014
 

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#345 » by NinerSickness » Wed Oct 3, 2018 7:47 am

NinerSickness wrote:Just noticed my guy Charles Harris tearing up the league w/ 1 tackle this year.

D-MVP!!!

Image


0 for 2 on my DEs. Takkarist McKinley has 5 sacks already, and he was my bust pick that year. It was a tough year to pick a bust, but there ya go.
Ray_Dogg
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 4,908
And1: 269
Joined: May 09, 2014
       

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#346 » by Ray_Dogg » Wed Oct 3, 2018 3:55 pm

NinerSickness wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:Just noticed my guy Charles Harris tearing up the league w/ 1 tackle this year.

D-MVP!!!

Image


0 for 2 on my DEs. Takkarist McKinley has 5 sacks already, and he was my bust pick that year. It was a tough year to pick a bust, but there ya go.


Bust pick was easy that year. Solomon Thomas. #3 overall instantly meant he needed to be a star. He isn’t even close.
NinerSickness
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,555
And1: 341
Joined: Aug 18, 2014
 

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#347 » by NinerSickness » Wed Oct 3, 2018 5:12 pm

Ray_Dogg wrote:Bust pick was easy that year. Solomon Thomas. #3 overall instantly meant he needed to be a star. He isn’t even close.


I thought he'd at least be good, but he's starting to look useless as a DE. They need to use him as a full-time DT, splitting time w/ bigger NTs if they went to get any production out of him at all.
Ray_Dogg
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 4,908
And1: 269
Joined: May 09, 2014
       

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#348 » by Ray_Dogg » Wed Oct 3, 2018 5:28 pm

NinerSickness wrote:
Ray_Dogg wrote:Bust pick was easy that year. Solomon Thomas. #3 overall instantly meant he needed to be a star. He isn’t even close.


I thought he'd at least be good, but he's starting to look useless as a DE. They need to use him as a full-time DT, splitting time w/ bigger NTs if they went to get any production out of him at all.


He’s shown to be ineffective at that position as well. I think there are more productive players than him at 75% of our dline spots. Meaning...Buckner, Armstead, Mitchell, Jones and Blair. Run stuffing is gonna be Mitchell and Jones > Thomas. Pass rushing DT is gonna be Buckner and Armstead > Thomas. Armstead beats him on length alone as a DT. Getting those long arms up in the passing lane.
Blair > Thomas at big end.

This leaves LEO and Marsh. Marsh is so awful they really should just put Thomas there. It’s the only spot on the line where I feel he’d be an upgrade over what we have. Then Thomas needs to work on shredding and agility. Him bulking up has done nothing but make him even stiffer.
Bingo_AlphaMan
General Manager
Posts: 9,832
And1: 229
Joined: Aug 24, 2014
     

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#349 » by Bingo_AlphaMan » Thu Oct 4, 2018 8:46 am

Ray_Dogg wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:
Ray_Dogg wrote:Bust pick was easy that year. Solomon Thomas. #3 overall instantly meant he needed to be a star. He isn’t even close.


I thought he'd at least be good, but he's starting to look useless as a DE. They need to use him as a full-time DT, splitting time w/ bigger NTs if they went to get any production out of him at all.


He’s shown to be ineffective at that position as well. I think there are more productive players than him at 75% of our dline spots. Meaning...Buckner, Armstead, Mitchell, Jones and Blair. Run stuffing is gonna be Mitchell and Jones > Thomas. Pass rushing DT is gonna be Buckner and Armstead > Thomas. Armstead beats him on length alone as a DT. Getting those long arms up in the passing lane.
Blair > Thomas at big end.

This leaves LEO and Marsh. Marsh is so awful they really should just put Thomas there. It’s the only spot on the line where I feel he’d be an upgrade over what we have. Then Thomas needs to work on shredding and agility. Him bulking up has done nothing but make him even stiffer.


I think we should go hard after Dante Fowler Jr. when he becomes a free agent.
wco81
RealGM
Posts: 26,276
And1: 11,208
Joined: Jul 04, 2013
       

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#350 » by wco81 » Thu Oct 4, 2018 8:56 pm

Bingo_AlphaMan wrote:
Ray_Dogg wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:
I thought he'd at least be good, but he's starting to look useless as a DE. They need to use him as a full-time DT, splitting time w/ bigger NTs if they went to get any production out of him at all.


He’s shown to be ineffective at that position as well. I think there are more productive players than him at 75% of our dline spots. Meaning...Buckner, Armstead, Mitchell, Jones and Blair. Run stuffing is gonna be Mitchell and Jones > Thomas. Pass rushing DT is gonna be Buckner and Armstead > Thomas. Armstead beats him on length alone as a DT. Getting those long arms up in the passing lane.
Blair > Thomas at big end.

This leaves LEO and Marsh. Marsh is so awful they really should just put Thomas there. It’s the only spot on the line where I feel he’d be an upgrade over what we have. Then Thomas needs to work on shredding and agility. Him bulking up has done nothing but make him even stiffer.


I think we should go hard after Dante Fowler Jr. when he becomes a free agent.


Hmm, UFA after this year. Doesn't he get a 5th year option?

In any event, he'll be 25 next August. So I would think if the Jags don't re-sign him to a big deal, they'd just tag him.
ChrisPozz
RealGM
Posts: 16,127
And1: 451
Joined: Sep 07, 2014
 

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#351 » by ChrisPozz » Thu Oct 4, 2018 9:52 pm

wco81 wrote:
Bingo_AlphaMan wrote:
Ray_Dogg wrote:
He’s shown to be ineffective at that position as well. I think there are more productive players than him at 75% of our dline spots. Meaning...Buckner, Armstead, Mitchell, Jones and Blair. Run stuffing is gonna be Mitchell and Jones > Thomas. Pass rushing DT is gonna be Buckner and Armstead > Thomas. Armstead beats him on length alone as a DT. Getting those long arms up in the passing lane.
Blair > Thomas at big end.

This leaves LEO and Marsh. Marsh is so awful they really should just put Thomas there. It’s the only spot on the line where I feel he’d be an upgrade over what we have. Then Thomas needs to work on shredding and agility. Him bulking up has done nothing but make him even stiffer.


I think we should go hard after Dante Fowler Jr. when he becomes a free agent.


Hmm, UFA after this year. Doesn't he get a 5th year option?

In any event, he'll be 25 next August. So I would think if the Jags don't re-sign him to a big deal, they'd just tag him.


The Jags declined his '19 option.

-----

He was arrested in March '16 on charges of an assault on an officer/EMT in Miami Beach but charges were later dropped after a completion of a pretrial diversion program.

His play in '16 steadily declined by all measures after trying to come back from the ACL tear and was disciplined/benched at times for a string of unnecessary roughness/unsportsmanlike penalties the year he came back and scolded for a handful of offside penalties which were deemed "stupid" penalties by coaches and teammates.

The next off-season their DC, Todd Walsh, was interviewed and credited him for "maturing a lot" and being more focused on football details. That was on June 19th. Not one month later, on July 18th, he was arrested on misdemeanor charges of simple battery and mischief for getting out of his car, hitting a man, knocking off his glasses, and stepping on them. He also was accused of taking the man's groceries and throwing them into a lake after said man criticized Fowler's driving.

Later that day it was revealed that Fowler had been issued at LEAST 10 traffic tickets dating back to December '15. An investigation revealed he once was caught driving 98 MPH in a 55 zone and another citation was for careless driving, causing $1,500 in property damage.

Weeks later, training camp opened. More disciplinary issues with Fowler. He was ordered to run laps for slapping the ball out of Chad Henne's hand and was sent to the sideline during a joint practice after committing a bad face-mask penalty and "getting into it with the Patriots."

Then it was revealed he would, in fact, be charged with 3 misdemeanors for the aforementioned issue. He ended up pleading no contest to "simple battery and mischief charges" for the incident and was sentenced to probation and community service.

He graded out across the board as one of the worst DEs in football that year despite 8 sacks.

---

He sat out the entire '18 off-season program with an upper body injury.

He was then suspended in July for the opener for the stomping incident.

One month later in August, he and Ramsey were suspended one week of practice for fighting and a violation of team rules.

----

He's played limited snaps after the week 1 suspension but has finally put some good grades together it appears but in limited time. He's played in only 62 snaps this season (50 passing, 11 run).

----

Maybe he finally puts everything together but you're really taking on a lot with him.

----

And I'll admit. Pre-draft I was into his ability and the on-field package. I liked him a fair bit. I didn't love the fit he got and I didn't advocate for him as high as he went but I liked parts to his game.

I wouldn't be a big advocate for him any more now after all the trouble and chances he's gotten.

There's NO WAY the Jaguars tag him any more regardless of ALMOST anything he does this season barring one of the biggest comebacks in NFL history IMO. Up until a couple weeks ago, it seemed as if it was a virtual certainty he was headed out the door and there'd be a divorce after this season, according to every single report I've been able to find to read.

If he finally strings something together maybe they'll revisit it, and maybe he'd be willing to rehab his image in Jacksonville since they are the ones most familiar with him, but he's got a LONG ways to go before too many people should get too excited about him IMO.
wco81
RealGM
Posts: 26,276
And1: 11,208
Joined: Jul 04, 2013
       

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#352 » by wco81 » Thu Oct 4, 2018 10:49 pm

Hmm nvm then.

No like his numbers are mind boggling, 13 career sacks on that defense.
Bingo_AlphaMan
General Manager
Posts: 9,832
And1: 229
Joined: Aug 24, 2014
     

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#353 » by Bingo_AlphaMan » Sun Jan 13, 2019 8:03 pm

ChrisPozz wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:
I_am_1z wrote:Chris Godwin is about to absolutely crap on some of you posters pre-draft expectations:

http://m.buccaneers.com/news/article-smith/Chris-Godwin-The-Look-of-a-Vet/aa7c6405-c7db-4c06-b9a3-837e448f5f7e


:-? Who was trashing Chris Godwin?


Trashing might be the wrong word; strong in some respects, but I'm right here saying I didn't care for him for a bunch of teams which some may remember. If he proves me wrong, I'll be around.


1z is a fool. Still waiting on Godwin to be a dominant player in the league.

I_am_1z wrote:Mike Williams my top receiver last year had a disappointing season. After hearing he had an injection in his back to avoid surgery, I kind of gave up on his potential #1 WR status from there. You only get steroid injections to calm inflammation, but inflammation will almost always come back, especially in a contact sport like football.

Chris Godwin looks just as I said, one of the better #2 receivers in the league. Posts 200+ yards in his two starts week 16 & 17 with 10 receptions.

Was never a fan of Corey Davis. Never understood the hype. I would consider still taking the risk and downgraded Mike Williams over Corey Davis. But would definitely take Godwin over both. Guess who's the youngest of the bunch ...?

Bingo_AlphaMan
General Manager
Posts: 9,832
And1: 229
Joined: Aug 24, 2014
     

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#354 » by Bingo_AlphaMan » Sun Jan 13, 2019 9:24 pm

This is how to approach the draft. Not only should you evaluate players in the current draft, a good GM must also look a year ahead by taking into account prospects at each particular positions. Something we should have done last year...

Tua Tagovailoa - QB - Crimson Tide

The Miami Dolphins are prepping for a full rebuild and are targeting the 2020 QB class that features Oregon's Justin Herbert and Alabama's Tua Tagovailoa.

#TankForTua is in full effect. The Dolphins arguably have the least blue chippers in the NFL and a total rebuild is warranted. Miami currently holds the No. 13 overall pick in the 2019 NFL Draft, which likely puts them out of the Dwayne Haskins bidding, but that's okay if they are eyeing for the future. The 2020 QB class is widely considered superior to the 2019 class, and the Dolphins could easily be drafting closer to the top of the draft next year as well.
Source: ESPN

Jan 13 - 12:36 PM
Ray_Dogg
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 4,908
And1: 269
Joined: May 09, 2014
       

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#355 » by Ray_Dogg » Sun Jan 13, 2019 10:22 pm

Bingo_AlphaMan wrote:
ChrisPozz wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:
:-? Who was trashing Chris Godwin?


Trashing might be the wrong word; strong in some respects, but I'm right here saying I didn't care for him for a bunch of teams which some may remember. If he proves me wrong, I'll be around.


1z is a fool. Still waiting on Godwin to be a dominant player in the league.

I_am_1z wrote:Mike Williams my top receiver last year had a disappointing season. After hearing he had an injection in his back to avoid surgery, I kind of gave up on his potential #1 WR status from there. You only get steroid injections to calm inflammation, but inflammation will almost always come back, especially in a contact sport like football.

Chris Godwin looks just as I said, one of the better #2 receivers in the league. Posts 200+ yards in his two starts week 16 & 17 with 10 receptions.

Was never a fan of Corey Davis. Never understood the hype. I would consider still taking the risk and downgraded Mike Williams over Corey Davis. But would definitely take Godwin over both. Guess who's the youngest of the bunch ...?



I like all three and think they are all good. Injuries have played a major role for two of them statistically. Davis has been stuck in an inept offense with his QB always hurt.
Ray_Dogg
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 4,908
And1: 269
Joined: May 09, 2014
       

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#356 » by Ray_Dogg » Sun Jan 13, 2019 10:25 pm

Bingo_AlphaMan wrote:This is how to approach the draft. Not only should you evaluate players in the current draft, a good GM must also look a year ahead by taking into account prospects at each particular positions. Something we should have done last year...

Tua Tagovailoa - QB - Crimson Tide

The Miami Dolphins are prepping for a full rebuild and are targeting the 2020 QB class that features Oregon's Justin Herbert and Alabama's Tua Tagovailoa.

#TankForTua is in full effect. The Dolphins arguably have the least blue chippers in the NFL and a total rebuild is warranted. Miami currently holds the No. 13 overall pick in the 2019 NFL Draft, which likely puts them out of the Dwayne Haskins bidding, but that's okay if they are eyeing for the future. The 2020 QB class is widely considered superior to the 2019 class, and the Dolphins could easily be drafting closer to the top of the draft next year as well.
Source: ESPN

Jan 13 - 12:36 PM


I’d put their tank philosophy to the test. Offer them Solly and our 2020 first for the 13th pick. It makes them worse and gives them another 2020 first rounder. Haha
I_am_1z
Starter
Posts: 2,172
And1: 68
Joined: Aug 22, 2014
     

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#357 » by I_am_1z » Tue Jan 15, 2019 5:36 am

Bingo_AlphaMan wrote:
ChrisPozz wrote:
NinerSickness wrote:
:-? Who was trashing Chris Godwin?


Trashing might be the wrong word; strong in some respects, but I'm right here saying I didn't care for him for a bunch of teams which some may remember. If he proves me wrong, I'll be around.


1z is a fool. Still waiting on Godwin to be a dominant player in the league.

I_am_1z wrote:Mike Williams my top receiver last year had a disappointing season. After hearing he had an injection in his back to avoid surgery, I kind of gave up on his potential #1 WR status from there. You only get steroid injections to calm inflammation, but inflammation will almost always come back, especially in a contact sport like football.

Chris Godwin looks just as I said, one of the better #2 receivers in the league. Posts 200+ yards in his two starts week 16 & 17 with 10 receptions.

Was never a fan of Corey Davis. Never understood the hype. I would consider still taking the risk and downgraded Mike Williams over Corey Davis. But would definitely take Godwin over both. Guess who's the youngest of the bunch ...?




HEY YOU KNOW WHAT YOU'RE WRONG ABOUT...*Squints* huh are you trying to make my case for me? Godwin > both those players.
NinerSickness
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,555
And1: 341
Joined: Aug 18, 2014
 

Re: 2017 NFL ROOKIES 

Post#358 » by NinerSickness » Mon Sep 9, 2019 4:40 am

Witherspoon is easily the most imporoved player of the offseason. I still want the Niners to trade for Jaylen Ramsey, but it's nice to have 2 CBs playing well.

Return to San Francisco 49ers