FlatearthZorro wrote:iggymcfrack wrote:Duke4life831 wrote:
Based on what though? I think a pretty fair way to look at this is
Ingram = Tatum (I actually have Ingram > Tatum)
#4 > Smart
Lonzo > #14
Kuzma > #20
2021 LAL pick < MEM pick
Tatum ranked 33rd and 81st in RPM the last 2 years. Ingram ranked 317th and 319th. Tatum’s also younger. There’s no way Ingram is a superior asset right now. I’d say it’s more like:
Tatum >>> #4 > Lonzo = Memphis pick > Ingram = Brown > #14 = 2021 Lakers pick > #20 > Smart
Tatum is younger, a better shooter, a better athlete, has flashed more star potential, imo will get stronger physically and has shown to be be able to make the big shot. I'd put Smart over Ball, Ball is way too injury prone, Smart's contract is cheap and he shot the 3 around .370 last season which made him respectable in that regard.
Okay the younger thing makes no sense, we are talking about a 6 month difference. He's not a better athlete, how has he flashed more star potential? Ingram's last 31 games he averaged 20/6/3.5 on 51% shooting. Has Tatum ever had a 30 game stretch like that? The he has shown to make the big shot thing is weird, Ingram has too. Im not saying its Ingram by a mile, Id also can see the argument for Tatum over Ingram, but this idea its Tatum by a mile is ridiculous to me.
Id take Smart over Ball as well, but you have Smart as the #2 in Boston's deal. No way anyone is taking Smart over the #4 pick. Also its not like Smart has been mr reliable when it comes to health, has played 70 games only twice in his 5 seasons and has missed 11 playoff games the last 2 years. Also he needs more than 1 year of shooting 36% from 3, for me to buy in he is now a 37% 3pt shooter.
Again I get the argument for the Boston deal when you include Brown. But taking Brown out, you lose a lot.