Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis?

Moderators: Domejandro, bwgood77, zimpy27, BombsquadSammy, GeorgeMarcus, PockyCandy, Prez, Yuri Vaultin, ken6199, Dirk

Are AD & KD better facilitators than Giannis?

Poll runs till Tue Jul 5, 2022 3:19 am

Yes, they are
22
20%
Nope, they dont watch actual games
87
80%
 
Total votes: 109

User avatar
E-Balla
RealGM
Posts: 30,798
And1: 19,119
Joined: Dec 19, 2012
Location: The Poster Formerly Known As The Gotham City Pantalones
   

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#21 » by E-Balla » Thu Oct 10, 2019 2:11 pm

AD yes, KD no.
"The hottest place in Hell is reserved for those who remain neutral in times of great moral conflict." - Martin Luther King
The_Hater
RealGM
Posts: 70,576
And1: 23,744
Joined: May 23, 2001
     

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#22 » by The_Hater » Thu Oct 10, 2019 6:17 pm

If we're talking strictly passing and creating for teammates, then Giannis is the clear leader in this group. But if we're talking about being an all-around playmaker it's KD. That guy can get a quality shot for himself practically on command.
AthensBucks wrote:Lowry is done.
Nurse is below average at best.
Masai is overrated.
I dont get how so many people believe in the raptors,they have zero to chance to win it all.


April 14th, 2019.
PistolPeteJR
Analyst
Posts: 3,025
And1: 2,530
Joined: Jun 14, 2017
 

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#23 » by PistolPeteJR » Thu Oct 10, 2019 6:46 pm

DCRYsing89 wrote:
evilpimp972 wrote:
Impuniti wrote:KD is a vastly better playmaker and it's not close. AD and Giannis are both below mediocre to even matter whose better.

Do you have the stats to back this up? KD is a mediocre playmaker. He had a serie last year in OKC where he had more turnovers than assists.

There’s turnovers from scoring and playmaking, he scores a lot, so his turnovers will accumulate from non-playmaking related incedents.
Assist to TO ratio as such is not a great way to measure playmaking

Although I veiw Giannis as better than KD, KD definetly is a solid playmaker.
Like in comparison to most non-guards, he is well above average.

Giannis could run point I feel though.

AD, nah, there’s a reason he is more effective offball.


Just to clarify bolded, you have Giannis as better than KD as a playmaker, or in general?
DCRYsing89
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,582
And1: 430
Joined: Dec 30, 2017
Location: Australia
     

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#24 » by DCRYsing89 » Thu Oct 10, 2019 8:09 pm

PistolPeteJR wrote:
DCRYsing89 wrote:
evilpimp972 wrote:Do you have the stats to back this up? KD is a mediocre playmaker. He had a serie last year in OKC where he had more turnovers than assists.

There’s turnovers from scoring and playmaking, he scores a lot, so his turnovers will accumulate from non-playmaking related incedents.
Assist to TO ratio as such is not a great way to measure playmaking

Although I veiw Giannis as better than KD, KD definetly is a solid playmaker.
Like in comparison to most non-guards, he is well above average.

Giannis could run point I feel though.

AD, nah, there’s a reason he is more effective offball.


Just to clarify bolded, you have Giannis as better than KD as a playmaker, or in general?

Damn that’s a tough question,
I like Giannis a lot more, and feel he is definetly better than 1leg KD this season,
Though going back I still think you can justify Giannis over him last season (personally I have him over KD)

But I was talking about as a playmaker with Giannis being better, in that statemenT.
After your first, you change, you mature, you dont just jump into things.

After getting dunked on for the first time, life becomes complex.
User avatar
Scalabrine
RealGM
Posts: 13,923
And1: 4,078
Joined: Jun 02, 2004
Location: NorCal
     

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#25 » by Scalabrine » Thu Oct 10, 2019 10:16 pm

This is an opinion so I don't think there is a true or false claim.

...I voted no, btw.
Go Knicks!
PistolPeteJR
Analyst
Posts: 3,025
And1: 2,530
Joined: Jun 14, 2017
 

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#26 » by PistolPeteJR » Thu Oct 10, 2019 10:39 pm

DCRYsing89 wrote:
PistolPeteJR wrote:
DCRYsing89 wrote:There’s turnovers from scoring and playmaking, he scores a lot, so his turnovers will accumulate from non-playmaking related incedents.
Assist to TO ratio as such is not a great way to measure playmaking

Although I veiw Giannis as better than KD, KD definetly is a solid playmaker.
Like in comparison to most non-guards, he is well above average.

Giannis could run point I feel though.

AD, nah, there’s a reason he is more effective offball.


Just to clarify bolded, you have Giannis as better than KD as a playmaker, or in general?

Damn that’s a tough question,
I like Giannis a lot more, and feel he is definetly better than 1leg KD this season,
Though going back I still think you can justify Giannis over him last season (personally I have him over KD)

But I was talking about as a playmaker with Giannis being better, in that statemenT.


How can you have Giannis over a healthy KD last season? What is the justification there? From a playmaking standpoint, they are not that far apart at all. From a defensive standpoint, while Giannis can be an anchor on that end and is a better defender for sure, KD is no scrub there, particularly the last 2-3 seasons. From a scoring standpoint, this is where it is not even close at all, and it is in KD’s favour. They aren’t even remotely close in the same tier.
Drygon
Rookie
Posts: 1,077
And1: 1,934
Joined: Dec 18, 2018

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#27 » by Drygon » Thu Oct 10, 2019 10:40 pm

PistolPeteJR wrote:
DCRYsing89 wrote:
PistolPeteJR wrote:
Just to clarify bolded, you have Giannis as better than KD as a playmaker, or in general?

Damn that’s a tough question,
I like Giannis a lot more, and feel he is definetly better than 1leg KD this season,
Though going back I still think you can justify Giannis over him last season (personally I have him over KD)

But I was talking about as a playmaker with Giannis being better, in that statemenT.


How can you have Giannis over a healthy KD last season? What is the justification there? From a playmaking standpoint, they are not that far apart at all. From a defensive standpoint, while Giannis can be an anchor on that end and is a better defender for sure, KD is no scrub there, particularly the last 2-3 seasons. From a scoring standpoint, this is where it is not even close at all, and it is in KD’s favour. They aren’t even remotely close in the same tier.


KD is also several tiers above Giannis as a shooter.
HurricaneKid
Head Coach
Posts: 7,364
And1: 4,390
Joined: Jul 13, 2010
Location: Sconnie Nation
 

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#28 » by HurricaneKid » Thu Oct 10, 2019 11:01 pm

This is insanity. Toronto didn't guard BroLo out to 25 and defended Giannis with the best wing defender possibly ever with a recent DPoY helping him at the rim and somehow one of the best seasons the league has ever seen has been largely deleted.

Giannis is a FAR better passer than either. It's not really all that close. His length and ability to get to the rim REQUIRES help and he is an creative assassin on the pass. Probably not at LeBrons level but he is getting there. KD is a better scorer but puts his head down and rarely makes anything but the easy pass. AD... that's just absurd. He isn't awful but it's not really a strength as compared to KD much less GA. He still struggles near the hoop with multiple defenders. His strength is playing off other playmakers. He will be outstanding with LBJ but he just isn't a guy you give the ball to and get out of the way.

Unless you believe playmaking is simply ability to score including shooting from distance this isn't remotely competitive. Also, an agent building up his guy isn't really as much an opinion as a statement designed to alter others' opinions.

Sent from my SM-G955U using RealGM mobile app
fishnc wrote:If I had a gun with two bullets and I was in a room with Hitler, Bin Laden, and LeBron, I would shoot LeBron twice.
User avatar
SeniorWalker
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,958
And1: 781
Joined: Jan 14, 2009
Location: at the event horizon and well on my way in, but you're wondering when i'll get there

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#29 » by SeniorWalker » Thu Oct 10, 2019 11:10 pm

HurricaneKid wrote:This is insanity. Toronto didn't guard BroLo out to 25 and defended Giannis with the best wing defender possibly ever with a recent DPoY helping him at the rim and somehow one of the best seasons the league has ever seen has been largely deleted.

Giannis is a FAR better passer than either. It's not really all that close. His length and ability to get to the rim REQUIRES help and he is an creative assassin on the pass. Probably not at LeBrons level but he is getting there. KD is a better scorer but puts his head down and rarely makes anything but the easy pass. AD... that's just absurd. He isn't awful but it's not really a strength as compared to KD much less GA. He still struggles near the hoop with multiple defenders. His strength is playing off other playmakers. He will be outstanding with LBJ but he just isn't a guy you give the ball to and get out of the way.

Unless you believe playmaking is simply ability to score including shooting from distance this isn't remotely competitive. Also, an agent building up his guy isn't really as much an opinion as a statement designed to alter others' opinions.

Sent from my SM-G955U using RealGM mobile app

This completely. Especially with AD: What playmaking are people thinking they are seeing with him? He's not an offensive initiator at all which is partly why he's not been carrying teams as far as one of his supposed talent level might be expected to. As dominant as he can be in some respects, his offensive impact is limited without another playmaker. AD will never be the best player in the league for this reason; he's not carrying anyone to a title. He's really a souped-up #2 option to be frank. Which isn't a bad thing, but he's just not capable of being an anchor like Giannis where you can just dump him the ball and get points off dunks and kick outs until the defense shifts on him.

Giannis may not yet have a reliable jumpshot, but he does not need anyone to set up his offense, and playmakes for his entire team. The bucks current problem is literally 1) his unreliable jumpshot and 2) they dont have a secondary ballhandler for when Giannis gets triple/quadruple teamed, and the offense stalls. (Actually those should be reversed because Giannis will still need a reliable #2 even with a solid jumpshot if he wants to win consistently).
"And always remember: one fish, two fish, red fish, blue fish, knick knack, paddy whack, give a dog a bone, two thousand, zero, zero, party, oops! Out of time, my bacon smellin' fine."
Duke4life831
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 18,983
And1: 28,159
Joined: Jun 16, 2015
   

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#30 » by Duke4life831 » Thu Oct 10, 2019 11:25 pm

Has AD ever been considered a good playmaker though? I mean he has a career average of 2.1 assists a game to 1.9 TOs. Last year was the first year he ever averaged more than 2 assists a game. Then if you want to consider playmaking for himself as well into the conversation. Well 69% of his shots are assisted on, that's really high for a superstar player.

Giannis on the other hand, his career assist average is twice as AD with 4.1 assists and last year he averaged 6 assists a game. Giannis is also assisted on only 46% of his shots.

So Giannis creates for himself more often (and at a higher efficiency), while also creating for others at a higher rate as well. I also thought playmaking was one of AD's biggest weaknesses.
IAMZOOTED2
Rookie
Posts: 1,063
And1: 399
Joined: Mar 05, 2017
 

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#31 » by IAMZOOTED2 » Thu Oct 10, 2019 11:35 pm

Look, Giannis takes this by default. At least for last year. He handles the rock more often and racks up more assists, too. Looking like that will be the case moving into this fresh season for a repeat
Amare_1_Knicks
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,920
And1: 1,620
Joined: Aug 07, 2010

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#32 » by Amare_1_Knicks » Fri Oct 11, 2019 12:41 am

AD is clearly behind KD and Giannis, though he has become a good passer in his own right. The numbers give the edge to KD and he certainly has more at his disposal because he can score from anywhere and let his passing game work off of that. I think Giannis is a more gifted natural passer though, fwiw. I see more remarkable, spectacular passes from him and you get the feel he could average 7-8 no problem.
triple_threat
Starter
Posts: 2,212
And1: 1,422
Joined: Aug 04, 2009

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#33 » by triple_threat » Fri Oct 11, 2019 3:18 am

Impuniti wrote:KD is a vastly better playmaker and it's not close. AD and Giannis are both below mediocre to even matter whose better.


Bs. Check him out on OKC.
triple_threat
Starter
Posts: 2,212
And1: 1,422
Joined: Aug 04, 2009

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#34 » by triple_threat » Fri Oct 11, 2019 3:19 am

Johnny Firpo wrote:
evilpimp972 wrote:
Impuniti wrote:KD is a vastly better playmaker and it's not close. AD and Giannis are both below mediocre to even matter whose better.

Do you have the stats to back this up? KD is a mediocre playmaker. He had a serie last year in OKC where he had more turnovers than assists.


Remember, playmaking includes scoring too, but I get your point.


I think youre missing the point. Rebounding and stealing are also playmaking.
og15
Forum Mod - Clippers
Forum Mod - Clippers
Posts: 34,113
And1: 13,538
Joined: Jun 23, 2004
Location: NBA Fan
 

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#35 » by og15 » Fri Oct 11, 2019 3:31 am

GregOden wrote:Giannis has bigger hands than Kawhi, they allow him to easily control the ball and recover while trying things off the dribble. Whereas AD's manlet hands really limit his ballhandling.

Man, sometimes I wonder how all these guards and small guys can even dribble the ball with their small hands :wink:
User avatar
GregOden
Pro Prospect
Posts: 872
And1: 687
Joined: Aug 11, 2010

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#36 » by GregOden » Fri Oct 11, 2019 3:34 am

og15 wrote:
GregOden wrote:Giannis has bigger hands than Kawhi, they allow him to easily control the ball and recover while trying things off the dribble. Whereas AD's manlet hands really limit his ballhandling.

Man, sometimes I wonder how all these guards and small guys can even dribble the ball with their small hands :wink:


Better hand to eye coordination due to shorter paths for nervous system :D
dhsilv2
RealGM
Posts: 17,954
And1: 6,967
Joined: Oct 04, 2015

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#37 » by dhsilv2 » Fri Oct 11, 2019 3:53 am

og15 wrote:
GregOden wrote:Giannis has bigger hands than Kawhi, they allow him to easily control the ball and recover while trying things off the dribble. Whereas AD's manlet hands really limit his ballhandling.

Man, sometimes I wonder how all these guards and small guys can even dribble the ball with their small hands :wink:


Reminds me of when I thought a 6'0 slim guy could make the nba since stockton was so good. Then I saw his hands....
User avatar
Baski
Veteran
Posts: 2,613
And1: 1,859
Joined: Feb 09, 2017
   

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#38 » by Baski » Fri Oct 11, 2019 7:36 am

What?! No!
Funniest Nicknames for NBA players I've ever heard on realgm:
1. Nicholas Kaboom
2. Lasoftus Aldridge
3. Glass
4. LeBaby
5. Zaza Pacheapshot
6. Stone Cold Steve Adams
7. Rapestaps Rapezingis :lol: :lol: :lol:
8. Yawnnis Icantshootthough
User avatar
Baski
Veteran
Posts: 2,613
And1: 1,859
Joined: Feb 09, 2017
   

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#39 » by Baski » Fri Oct 11, 2019 7:42 am

Tomazan wrote:Who out of these players is the best center?

Paul, Curry or Irving?

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

But for real a similar question could be posed for these 3 guards in regards to rebounding and it wouldn't be silly either.

If you really wanna laugh compare their rim protection lol.
Funniest Nicknames for NBA players I've ever heard on realgm:
1. Nicholas Kaboom
2. Lasoftus Aldridge
3. Glass
4. LeBaby
5. Zaza Pacheapshot
6. Stone Cold Steve Adams
7. Rapestaps Rapezingis :lol: :lol: :lol:
8. Yawnnis Icantshootthough
In SVG We Trust
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,691
And1: 1,155
Joined: Mar 14, 2016
   

Re: Are AD & KD really better playmakers than Giannis? 

Post#40 » by In SVG We Trust » Fri Oct 11, 2019 7:54 am

KD as first option and running an offense is a mess. When he's not playing with the 2 best shooters of the NBA history, he's a losing balls machine. When Tony Allen or Chris Paul defended him close, he wasn't able to put the ball on the floor

Return to The General Board