Rollie wrote:The_Hater wrote:engelmartin wrote:Amazing that some people still think of Melo as an all-star. He's been a bum ever since he left the nuggets
Except he played the best ball of his career his first 3-4 years in NY, improved his efficiency and even led the league in scoring one season. He didn’t start fading until injuries and age hit near the end of the Knicks career.
The problem is he’s been terrible for the last 2 years, not the last 9 years.
Donovan tried to make him play like Patterson and not like Melo. Standing at the top of the key and waiting for Westbrook to kick the ball out was never going to work.
As for the Rockets, everyone talks about how he played that one game on national tv but
they never talk about how well he played leading up to it when Harden was out.
ThisMelo's best 2 years came in NY
2013 and 2014:
144 starts
38 mpg
28 ppg
7.5 reb
3 ast
1 stl
.451/.391/.840
Yes, he was good in those 3 games when Harden was out, but also played fine alongside Harden when he was getting mins.
In the 5 games he played over 30 mins, Melo was a solid option: 19.8 pts on .493/.444/.688
People kill his defense, but tons of guys don't defend and still get checks. Problem with Melo for me has always been that he is a ball stopper. Even when he was a willing passer in NY it was still out of the triple threat or post. And that doesn't fly in today's offenses
Lou Williams can't defend either and is a career .421 shooter and a poor .349 on 3PA, but he moves the ball or at least moves "with" the ball. Even in LA where he has been the go-to closer for 2 years, Lou is still averaging 5.3 ast and you almost never see him stall the ball for 5+ seconds.
If Melo is ball-stopping AND not defending, 45% shooting and 40% 3PM won't save him