Payt10 wrote:dice wrote:Payt10 wrote:Absolutely, I do. They're both vastly superior players. Just like I think there is no way in hell Toronto even comes close to sniffing a championship with Jimmy Butler instead of Kawhi Leonard last year.
Jimmy is a great player, but he's clearly a tier below the true elites in the league. It's not impossible to win without one of those guys, but the odds are not in his favor.
toronto is still excellent after losing kawhi. you don't think that team could come close to sniffing a title by adding back in jimmy butler?
i don't think it's clear at all that kawhi is a different class of player. better, but not by a lot
Kawhi is a 2-time NBA Finals MVP, and averaged 30 a game in the playoffs last year. Regular season, post-season, Kawhi is just better, and I don't think it's particularly close, especially after last year.
That Kawhi was a lucky bounce away from losing to Jimmy's team last year. And, Kawhi had 2 healthy all-star types(Siakam, Lowry) while Jimmy had 2 promising stars but flawed and the other semi-injured(didn't Embiid miss a game?)
In overall perception, Kawhi is better than Jimmy. But, that's because Kawhi has been on good/great teams for most of his career. Jimmy was on a good team for the first time in Philadelphia in his career and maybe the 2015-16 dysfunctional/injured Bulls. He did well in both circumstances.
I think people underestimate Jimmy because he didn't get to be a top option immediately and was not a lottery pick and he strikes a different nerve with Bulls fans.
And, because Miami has so many rookie types, Jimmy will still be looked down upon next year.