shangrila wrote:LKN wrote:shangrila wrote:Not to de-rail too much but I've never understood why people would be against things like this. There was some talk of it in Australia years back (one senator didn't like that new legislation wouldn't allow welfare recipients to spend that money on smokes, porn and alcohol for example) but...like, this stuff isn't free. You need to know you're not just giving it to someone so they can piss it away on whatever vices might have landed them in that situation to begin with. Welfare is more or less to keep you alive. To keep you fed and sheltered. It's not, nor should it ever be, simply a wad of cash handed to people who can't support themselves.
Would it be insulting to some people? Sure, I can imagine being annoyed by it myself. But it's necessary to ensure the system functions properly and everyone follows the rules.
EDIT: I'll amend this slightly. Didn't realise it was food stamps and not general welfare, which would already be a measure to ensure people are using the stuff correctly. So yeah, drug tests on top might be excessive. I'm not sure I'd call it cruel though.
I can tell you exactly why we shouldn't do it (some places have tried it and it's done almost nothing)
- It doesn't work (almost no one tests positive - so it saves almost no money)
- It's stupid to starve people's kids because they do drugs
- It's a giant waste of money (since again, almost no one tests positive so the money spent to test people is wasted)
- It's means treating anyone who needs help like a subhuman.
Stigmatizing being poor is just dumb and counterproductive.
I won't go in too deep because I don't want to de-rail. All I'll say is that I disagree that tests like this inherently stigmatize being poor and even just the threat of them can serve a purpose.
It's probably a topic for the CA board - I will tell you there is almost no evidence that supports your point of view and a mountain of evidence that supports mine. (I actually am against this more for practical reasons than moral reasons... I just see it as a useless waste of money and resources)




























