AussieCeltic wrote:
I already mentioned that MJ at 39/40 torched Shawn Marion. Jason Kidd wasn't playing any defense at that stage and Tyson Chandler was ok but doesn't hold a candle to the bigs MJ had to face (Hakeem, Robinson, Ewing, Zo, Mutumbo etc).
LBJ has "torched" teams with Jason Kidd, Shawn Marion, Tyson Chandler and many NBA greats in the regular season also - so why would Michael Jordan going off against Shawn Marion in the RS mean anything? (if that even happened)
Jason Kidd wasn't playing defense in 2011? Okay, well, you clearly are just going off of narratives if you think that is true because that is hilariously incorrect. Jason Kidd was still one of the best defensive guards. You are just saying he was bad because he was older and not considered a superstar anymore - but the idea that Jason Kidd wasn't playing defense is just....what exactly do you think he was doing?
Olajuwon and Robinson were not in the same conference as Michael Jordan. Jordan never played Zo Mournin in a playoff series. Mutumbo only had one series against Michael Jordan (because Mutumbo was also in the Western conference) and Michael Jordan didn't score well. The only center you listed there that Jordan had any history with was Patrick Ewing, and the Knicks lost because Ewing mediocre offensive help, they defended the Bulls quite well. On top of that, what does any of them have to do with Tyson Chandler? They are better defenders yes, that doesn't mean Tyson Chandler was not a great defender.
The majority of the centers you listed, Michael Jordan never played against in the playoffs.
That is not to mention that none of those players played on the same team at the same time and were not coached by Rich Carslile so I don't know what relevance that has. Zone defense isn't one vs one defense either, and the Mavericks used zone to stop the Heat.
It seems like people here are not aware that 1 vs 1 defense and team defense are two different things. Shawn Marion isn't even famous for being a 1 vs 1 defender, so even if Jordan did torch him (which my guess is that you looked up that Jordan had high PPG against the Suns, which is not the same thing as him scoring on Marion at will) it doesn't say anything about who is the better 1 vs 1 guy.
Zone defense is not 1 vs 1 defense.
On top of that, we are basically over analyzing one series that happened in LBJ's career that will likely last 20 seasons of all-nba play and deep post season runs. That seems rather silly.