7footMONSTER wrote:TheNetsFan wrote:7footMONSTER wrote:In a league without Shaq, we don’t really need two Dikembe Mutombos on the roster, so one asset we could use in a trade is Allen (since DJ has no value), but what can we realistically get back for Allen, since any team that really wants him can just wait a year and get him for nothing in free agency?
Same thing with Dinwiddie. 1 year left means he would be a rental. I think we need to lower our demands a little bit.
That's not true. Bird rights matter. Getting a guy in early to sell him on staying matters. Unless you think Dinwiddie and Allen are getting MLE money or less, there are going to be limited suitors with the cap space to offer them a big contract. If you want Dinwiddie, but won't have $16+ mil in cap space, your only options are trade for him early and use bird rights, or engage the Nets in a S&T using their bird rights.
If you're a team with cap space that will be looking to add multiple players, and you think Dinwiddie will fetch around $20mil, bird rights help, because his cap hold would be a few million less.
There’s a lot of moving parts for that to work. For example if Atlanta signs Dinwiddie with cap space, they have no incentive to make it a S&T. They could do Dinwiddie a favor so he can keep his Bird Rights and send us a conditional draft pick, and we would get a TPE, but even that often doesn’t amount to anything useful.
I completely respect your point of view, I just personally would prefer something more concrete, like getting a player with multiple years left on his contract. I especially do not want to go into next off season where both Dinwiddie and Allen could be lost for nothing.
What moving parts? It's normal NBA dealings. Atlanta is one of a small number of teams with cap space. For them, unless they believe he won't consider them in FA without getting him there ahead of time or they have plans to sign 1 or 2 additional FAs and need the additional cap space, there's no reason to trade. In either scenario, that trade only makes sense this year. Once he's a FA, they have no incentive to S&T.
But for teams with little or no cap space, e.g. Indiana, Milwaukee, Orlando, etc. they would need to trade for him.
That being said, if Tsai is willing to bring back multi-year salary, he can simply spend that money on our incumbents instead. From my perspective, I just think the likelihood of Dinwiddie getting a Rozier type offer & walking for a starting gig is strong. So if you're going to move one in a trade, it's him.