2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread

Moderators: Doctor MJ, trex_8063, penbeast0, PaulieWal, Clyde Frazier

MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#321 » by MyUniBroDavis » Fri Sep 11, 2020 4:47 am

freethedevil wrote:
GSP wrote:
freethedevil wrote:I'd say jokic is a slight positive defensively frankly, one of the league's best pass swatters with minimal gambling, usually positionally sound, ect, but there is a positional fit issue with him being a center and not being an elite rim prtoector.

FWIW, impact metrics see him as a positive defende


I'm pretty confident he's better than davis offensively, by courtesy of being a avstly better creator. Davis is probably the best overall due to defense though.


Jokic might be a slight positive in the regular season but its obvious now that he isnt in playoff matchups

Hes been hunted on pick and roll and given up alot at the rim with his piss poor shotmaking against the Spurs, Blazers (without Nurk) and Jazz (without Bogie) now. All those series went 7 in big part due to Jokics defense being gameplanned and exposed

Well him being an elite rim prtoector would make him one of the best defenders in the league. The question here is do you have to sacrifice rim prtoection or cna he fir with good rim protectors


Looking at some film, jokic definately looks like hes being attacked defensively.

I think its insane to call his defense anything close to positive in terms of the playoffs so far, i do genuinly think hes been the worst or worst impact defender in the league so far, considering gameplans are made around his shortcomings

His lack of ability to defend the rim right now is fully based off him not rotating correctly or being engaged on D, he isnt really blitzing well at all or rotating back well when hes supposed to. Hes not meeting slashers when they drive and instead of stepping up, at least out if the restricted area, hes literally just blopped in there.

Its not even an athleticism thing its fully just bad defensive iq.

As for him fitting with another rim protector, if defensively you have this random unathletic tall person that cant protect the paint at all, it just makes him more attackable because more situations to attacj gim in defensive situations hes even less comfortable

I think if we are measuring his playoff performance, you have to factor in his defense as well. Its not just bad, its like fully been atrocious. Regardless of how well he plays on offense, hes been so bad on defense i dont see arguments for him over the legitimate two way guys that have been dominating offensively as well (davis and bron arguably more so than him)

I mean if we are talking about his performances overall, first series he was great but theres that caveat that he was genuinly pathetic defensively the whole way through and that means tou cant put his performance on the same pedestal on other guys. Second round, hes definately done better after a really bad game 1 but i definately wouldnt say hes been a positive on D

He probably is a top 5 player offensively this playoffs, but i dont see how the fact that his defense has ranged from average to catastrophically bad can be ignored
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#322 » by MyUniBroDavis » Fri Sep 11, 2020 4:49 am

And for jokic being better than AD offensively, id agree if it was RS but AD has been hilariously good this playoffs, hes literally had 1 bad game on offense and nearly every other one has been world beating good. His playmaking looks incredibly sharp to, hes not jokic as a passer but the fact that he averages 4 assists and scores 30 a game and only gets 2 turnovers a game, is insane regardless of their role differences. Its not as if ADs playing the same early ner orleans role where he was only a play finisher too, hes assisted on 55% of his shots vs 50% for jokic these playiffs

I definately dont think jokic has been very positionally sound at allthese playoffs either.
azizx
Freshman
Posts: 79
And1: 42
Joined: May 23, 2018
 

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#323 » by azizx » Fri Sep 11, 2020 4:52 am

I know some people are saying pump the brakes on Luka, but this guy has probably been the defining player of this season to me. He continually makes the right plays and he always remains in control of playoff games in a way that even other top 10 level players can't consistently replicate.
Lebron is still better and everyone knew at the beginning of the season that the road to the NBA championship would go through LA, be it LAL or LAC. but Luka has to be top 3 right now. Maybe Kawhi 2-way impact is larger and more effective but his creativity isn't on that level (neither is it required as often).
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#324 » by MyUniBroDavis » Fri Sep 11, 2020 4:58 am

azizx wrote:I know some people are saying pump the brakes on Luka, but this guy has probably been the defining player of this season to me. He continually makes the right plays and he always remains in control of playoff games in a way that even other top 10 level players can't consistently replicate.
Lebron is still better and everyone knew at the beginning of the season that the road to the NBA championship would go through LA, be it LAL or LAC. but Luka has to be top 3 right now. Maybe Kawhi 2-way impact is larger and more effective but his creativity isn't on that level (neither is it required as often).


I think lebron, kawhi, and davis are definately above him atm. Harden probably as well considering howbmuch the lakers are giving up to limit his numbers, Giannis maybe although hes is kind of weird with how that heat series went.
ShotCreator
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,836
And1: 2,545
Joined: May 18, 2014
Location: CF
     

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#325 » by ShotCreator » Fri Sep 11, 2020 5:27 am

Luka is not in Harden’s ballpark.

Harden right now reminds me so much of Chris Paul at the exact same age. And even LeBron. Years of playing is getting him at a mental and skill peak while retaining just enough natural athleticism to have an insane peak.

Years of built up nonsense of narratives are overshadowing an insanely good, complete season.

Harden is playing some of the best basketball for a guard ever. Kobe has never sustained this level of play in his career and it’s obvious to see.

The guy is a two-way monster. Harden is a good help, man, and post defender on bigs.

Is mentally engaged on defense like never before, being accountable and actually defensive-minded. Like he values possessions and really wants to grit out defensive possessions like a Marcus Smart or Lowry.

Getting doubled 30 feet off.

And he’s not in some particularly ideal situation. His best players are corner specialists who compete on defense(Tucker, Covington).

Now that I’m typing this out, LeBron 31 year old season was underrated because the narrative was, he was simply old and done playing defense.

Winds up singlehandedly killing the death lineup. And he really never stopped playing defense at any point that year.

It would be very hard to objectively say any wing was better as a player than Harden at this point. I think Giannis had something of a 2010 LeBron year and is best individually but that’s debatable. Too bad he didn’t get to finish that series.


With Harden being a good defender, and the best offensive player in the world right now, is there enough of a defensive gap for LeBron to make up?

Or for Kawhi to? I don’t believe so, but that’s what it should come down to when judging.

And Luka? Pssh.
Swinging for the fences.
limbo
Veteran
Posts: 2,799
And1: 2,680
Joined: Jun 30, 2019

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#326 » by limbo » Fri Sep 11, 2020 8:47 am

LeBron
Kawhi
Harden
Giannis
AD
-
Luka
Jokic
Butler
Tatum
Lillard
-
Paul
Embiid
Gobert
Bam
Lowry

This is how i feel about my Top 15 right now.
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#327 » by MyUniBroDavis » Fri Sep 11, 2020 10:24 am

ShotCreator wrote:Luka is not in Harden’s ballpark.

Harden right now reminds me so much of Chris Paul at the exact same age. And even LeBron. Years of playing is getting him at a mental and skill peak while retaining just enough natural athleticism to have an insane peak.

Years of built up nonsense of narratives are overshadowing an insanely good, complete season.

Harden is playing some of the best basketball for a guard ever. Kobe has never sustained this level of play in his career and it’s obvious to see.

The guy is a two-way monster. Harden is a good help, man, and post defender on bigs.

Is mentally engaged on defense like never before, being accountable and actually defensive-minded. Like he values possessions and really wants to grit out defensive possessions like a Marcus Smart or Lowry.

Getting doubled 30 feet off.

And he’s not in some particularly ideal situation. His best players are corner specialists who compete on defense(Tucker, Covington).

Now that I’m typing this out, LeBron 31 year old season was underrated because the narrative was, he was simply old and done playing defense.

Winds up singlehandedly killing the death lineup. And he really never stopped playing defense at any point that year.

It would be very hard to objectively say any wing was better as a player than Harden at this point. I think Giannis had something of a 2010 LeBron year and is best individually but that’s debatable. Too bad he didn’t get to finish that series.


With Harden being a good defender, and the best offensive player in the world right now, is there enough of a defensive gap for LeBron to make up?

Or for Kawhi to? I don’t believe so, but that’s what it should come down to when judging.

And Luka? Pssh.


Wait are you being sarcastic lol, hardens literally is the best situation for any iso scorer in nba history in terms of his own production. Hardens definately imrpoved defensively but he still has hella lapses on that end too. His d on cp3 for example wasnpretty bad

The houstan offense is designed around harden 1v1 with spacing, and d antoni is a master at getting the defense spaced out in a way that its hella isolated. Hardens probably the best 1v1 player in the league, and a great passer, but the problem is he gets so uninvolved with possessions once he passes it out. Hes not really thaaat good at passing it out of hard doubles, finishing through well positioned help defense, etc. hes a great p and r playmaker too.

But the thing is hes usually more isolated on offense than anyone else in nva history offensively.

That being said he does have clear weaknesses. He becomes really uninvolved if his initial attack doesnt work. If a team is somehow able to get their big man in the paint in good help position without leaving someone open, (which you can do theough good rotations) he becomes passive. If you can help on him hard and have the defensive communication to rotate, he becomes incredibly passive. Its really noticable that if harden makes one pass out he basically just takes the possession off at times.

Essentially his offensive game is strong but limited, and theres definately a reason why it doesnt usually translate as well to the playoffs.

The lakers started running zone a but more in games 2-4 and were generally rotating well. When they executed the rockets offense became completey stagnant, whether thats hardens fault or the rockets fault, is questionable but even though they could definstely adjusted better hardens passiveness and basically being a non factor once he passes it didnt help at all.

The rockets are the best team in the league at functionally spacing the floor, and the best team at the league in generating mismatches. If you notice, on harden drives the defense is almost never in good position to help unless they rotate early.

Contrast this to the lakers trying to score on houstan, or many teams really, where theyre facing almost an exclusively packed paint.

Lebrons kind of got harden beat handily in passing, sure hardens a top 5 passer in the league maybe top 3, but lebrons like, kind of squarely in that number one spot, the only thing he misses are lobs (this series) really, and its a pretty weird situation.

Lebron with the same level of functional spacing as harden would be as dominant on offense. I mean whenever you see lebron drive and no help appears he scores lol.

The main thing is while hardens better at breaking down his man, by nature lebrons better on mismatches if he had more room to operate because physics, hes a good deal better at kicking out even tho hardens good at that too, and hes a better finisher against good help defense.

I dont see how anyones looking at hardens series and saying hes the best wing ever or anything like that.

Also comparing wings in the 2000s and 2020s is difficult, because strong iso wings like kobe and wade would be absurdly dominant today under systems like that as well. I mean, in terms of effeciency no ones effeciency has gone up more than strong iso wings, the 2000s were actually where they were at their lowest for most players.

Offensively i mean, wade is arguably the best slasher ever and kobe is kawhi+1 in everything and a great deal more explosive with less strength but a more diverse pick and roll game.

Hardens a great player and one of the best iso players the game has ever seen

But 2 things are apparent

1. Hes not played well in important games throughout his career

- this is pretty self explanetory. 2017 obv the turnover record, 2018 he forgot how to shoot, 2019 he was fine but those 3 turnovers in 3 minutes at the end hurts, and he wasnt amazing that series, 2020 absent in game 7 and 2/11 in a crucial game 4.

2. He dissapears for stretches

Throughout this lakers series outside of game 1, yeah, he looked amazing and unplayable at times but he gets so passive once the D attavks him hard, and just disspaears for long stretches of the game. His off ball game is non existent, and while that may or may mot be by design there are fully times where a simple cur would have given an open bucket but hes standing like 5 feet from the three pine with his hands kn his hips watching gordan and westbrook iso and giving it back to them when they pass it out to him

3. He is in a system dedicated to create high effeciency iso scoring - self explanetory

That coupled with the current rigidness and lack of versatility in his offensive approach when things arent going right are gonna bring him down in an all time sense

Jts not as if the lakers are doing anything crazy on defense otherthan helping on drives or doubling and rotating well, or playing zone or random coveragesand mixing things up.

If harden has an off ball game hed be able to take advantage of these rotations more will well times cuts but hes so stagnant without the ball and it does hurt their team. Not to mention bron and ad have both been more effecient on a much, much more packed paint
LukaTheGOAT
Analyst
Posts: 3,273
And1: 2,985
Joined: Dec 25, 2019
 

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#328 » by LukaTheGOAT » Fri Sep 11, 2020 1:47 pm

WarriorGM wrote:
KTM_2813 wrote:Ultimately, I think that the main point of disagreement I have with people is that I think it's important for him to produce in the box score. He always impacts games with his gravity, but he still needs to produce with scoring and shot making, which has been a bit of an issue in the playoffs, IMO.

WarroirGM wrote:Prior to these playoffs he was top 8 all-time career average ppg in the playoffs. How much higher does he need to be in the scoring department?


I think it depends on who he’s being measured against. If we’re trying to figure out whether or not he’s the GOAT offensive player, then “only” being eighth feels a bit low to me. And I’d be interested to see more advanced measures of scoring as well. IIRC, he didn’t crack ElGee’s top ten, but I’m pretty fuzzy.


NBA & ABA Career Playoff Leaders and Records for Points Per Game

1. Michael Jordan* 33.45
2. Allen Iverson* 29.73
3. Jerry West* 29.13
4. Kevin Durant 29.09
5. LeBron James 28.89
6. Rick Barry* 27.33
7. Elgin Baylor* 27.04
8. Stephen Curry 26.50
9. George Gervin* 26.46
10. Hakeem Olajuwon* 25.90

Looking at that list who do you think above Curry is a greater all-around offensive threat?

Magic Johnson and Steve Nash often come up in discussions of great offensive players. They're not close in terms of average ppg in the playoffs. Their offensive reputation is based mainly on how they got their teammates open. Curry does similar although one step more removed.

Curry is both a great offensive scorer and a great offensive creator.

Only list I'm aware of released by ElGee is his Top 40 based on "career value" which is very favorable to longevity. Coming into the league from high school and playing past the point of retirement for most players gives a leg up on that list.


To be fair it is longevity relative to era. So it is adjusted depending on the era they played in. Curry wasn't good enough most likely to come into the NBA straight out of HS.
70sFan
RealGM
Posts: 30,202
And1: 25,475
Joined: Aug 11, 2015
 

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#329 » by 70sFan » Fri Sep 11, 2020 9:30 pm

I've been watching 1990 Lakers games recently and I though about it - imagine Giannis with James Worthy inside moves. He's basically bigger and more athletic version of Worthy physically and James was also a limited shooter. Worthy had such a good footwork though and his moves were so quick, it's a night and day between them.

I think that Giannis should have developed this kind of game, instead of hoping that he'll magically become a good shooter.
LukaTheGOAT
Analyst
Posts: 3,273
And1: 2,985
Joined: Dec 25, 2019
 

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#330 » by LukaTheGOAT » Sat Sep 12, 2020 3:23 am

I will go Kawhi. I think he was the 2nd best player during the regular season on a per game basis after Giannis. These playoffs, I would say most likely he has been the 2nd best guy after AD, but part of AD's success is that he shooting stupidly good from the mid-range. I'm not certain AD will keep this up.

Jokic would also be someone I considered for best guy in the playoffs, but I think the overall playmaking gap is quite as big as we believe because Kawhi being a perimeter player, has the ball in his hands more and gets opportunities to create a bit more than Jokic. Kawhi is the better scorer, and while their offense may be arguable, Kawhi is just straight up better on D than Jokic regardless of position. If we put these guys on random teams, I think Jokic's D might up him back just a bit more than Kawhi, who provides elite D value at the wing.

I also want to give a shoutout to Luka because I think I feel pretty confident in proclaiming his as the best offensive player in the league. The sample size of him in the PS is small and he is likely a slight negative on D, which might put him behind Kawhi, but Luka really led the best RS offense ever (not relative to era) and that to me deserves some praise. We always praise guys like Nash and Magic for leading GOAT level offenses during the RS and I believe Luka is not only next in line but will surpass the both of them.

Overall, I expect most people in this thread will agree with me that Kawhi is POY after he dispatches the Lakers.
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#331 » by MyUniBroDavis » Sat Sep 12, 2020 6:50 am

LukaTheGOAT wrote:I will go Kawhi. I think he was the 2nd best player during the regular season on a per game basis after Giannis. These playoffs, I would say most likely he has been the 2nd best guy after AD, but part of AD's success is that he shooting stupidly good from the mid-range. I'm not certain AD will keep this up.

Jokic would also be someone I considered for best guy in the playoffs, but I think the overall playmaking gap is quite as big as we believe because Kawhi being a perimeter player, has the ball in his hands more and gets opportunities to create a bit more than Jokic. Kawhi is the better scorer, and while their offense may be arguable, Kawhi is just straight up better on D than Jokic regardless of position. If we put these guys on random teams, I think Jokic's D might up him back just a bit more than Kawhi, who provides elite D value at the wing.

I also want to give a shoutout to Luka because I think I feel pretty confident in proclaiming his as the best offensive player in the league. The sample size of him in the PS is small and he is likely a slight negative on D, which might put him behind Kawhi, but Luka really led the best RS offense ever (not relative to era) and that to me deserves some praise. We always praise guys like Nash and Magic for leading GOAT level offenses during the RS and I believe Luka is not only next in line but will surpass the both of them.

Overall, I expect most people in this thread will agree with me that Kawhi is POY after he dispatches the Lakers.


Im pretty sure that most people think jokic is a better playmaker, and lukas offense is also the best in the league with him off the floor
LukaTheGOAT
Analyst
Posts: 3,273
And1: 2,985
Joined: Dec 25, 2019
 

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#332 » by LukaTheGOAT » Sat Sep 12, 2020 7:27 pm

MyUniBroDavis wrote:
LukaTheGOAT wrote:I will go Kawhi. I think he was the 2nd best player during the regular season on a per game basis after Giannis. These playoffs, I would say most likely he has been the 2nd best guy after AD, but part of AD's success is that he shooting stupidly good from the mid-range. I'm not certain AD will keep this up.

Jokic would also be someone I considered for best guy in the playoffs, but I think the overall playmaking gap is quite as big as we believe because Kawhi being a perimeter player, has the ball in his hands more and gets opportunities to create a bit more than Jokic. Kawhi is the better scorer, and while their offense may be arguable, Kawhi is just straight up better on D than Jokic regardless of position. If we put these guys on random teams, I think Jokic's D might up him back just a bit more than Kawhi, who provides elite D value at the wing.

I also want to give a shoutout to Luka because I think I feel pretty confident in proclaiming his as the best offensive player in the league. The sample size of him in the PS is small and he is likely a slight negative on D, which might put him behind Kawhi, but Luka really led the best RS offense ever (not relative to era) and that to me deserves some praise. We always praise guys like Nash and Magic for leading GOAT level offenses during the RS and I believe Luka is not only next in line but will surpass the both of them.

Overall, I expect most people in this thread will agree with me that Kawhi is POY after he dispatches the Lakers.


Im pretty sure that most people think jokic is a better playmaker, and lukas offense is also the best in the league with him off the floor


I know Jokic is the best playmaker, but I am saying the shots created by him are likely not vastly more than Kawhi. For example, Jokic has a Backpicks Box Creation of 9.8 shots per game, while Kawhi has a Backpicks Box Creation of 10.2 shots per game. These are estimates, but the fact of the matter, Jokic doesn't seem to be creating much more than Kawhi. Jokic definitely gets more high value assists through layup passes (he has a relative layup percentage of 10% while Kawhi is at 1%) and of course that matters...but at the end of the day Jokic is a big who relies on guards getting him the ball because he doesn't start with it on the perimeter. This therefore stunts his global impact a bit as an offensive player.

Also I know the Mavs had an extremely good offense without Luka, however the fact that Luka was able to BOOST that offense to the best ever when playing, along with the fact that Porzingis was unimpressive offensively for most of the year, and the lack of a great secondary playmaker/initiator is absurd. I do not believe Magic/Nash/Lebron are doing anything close to that at a similar age.
MyUniBroDavis
General Manager
Posts: 7,827
And1: 5,034
Joined: Jan 14, 2013

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#333 » by MyUniBroDavis » Sat Sep 12, 2020 10:59 pm

LukaTheGOAT wrote:
MyUniBroDavis wrote:
LukaTheGOAT wrote:I will go Kawhi. I think he was the 2nd best player during the regular season on a per game basis after Giannis. These playoffs, I would say most likely he has been the 2nd best guy after AD, but part of AD's success is that he shooting stupidly good from the mid-range. I'm not certain AD will keep this up.

Jokic would also be someone I considered for best guy in the playoffs, but I think the overall playmaking gap is quite as big as we believe because Kawhi being a perimeter player, has the ball in his hands more and gets opportunities to create a bit more than Jokic. Kawhi is the better scorer, and while their offense may be arguable, Kawhi is just straight up better on D than Jokic regardless of position. If we put these guys on random teams, I think Jokic's D might up him back just a bit more than Kawhi, who provides elite D value at the wing.

I also want to give a shoutout to Luka because I think I feel pretty confident in proclaiming his as the best offensive player in the league. The sample size of him in the PS is small and he is likely a slight negative on D, which might put him behind Kawhi, but Luka really led the best RS offense ever (not relative to era) and that to me deserves some praise. We always praise guys like Nash and Magic for leading GOAT level offenses during the RS and I believe Luka is not only next in line but will surpass the both of them.

Overall, I expect most people in this thread will agree with me that Kawhi is POY after he dispatches the Lakers.


Im pretty sure that most people think jokic is a better playmaker, and lukas offense is also the best in the league with him off the floor


I know Jokic is the best playmaker, but I am saying the shots created by him are likely not vastly more than Kawhi. For example, Jokic has a Backpicks Box Creation of 9.8 shots per game, while Kawhi has a Backpicks Box Creation of 10.2 shots per game. These are estimates, but the fact of the matter, Jokic doesn't seem to be creating much more than Kawhi. Jokic definitely gets more high value assists through layup passes (he has a relative layup percentage of 10% while Kawhi is at 1%) and of course that matters...but at the end of the day Jokic is a big who relies on guards getting him the ball because he doesn't start with it on the perimeter. This therefore stunts his global impact a bit as an offensive player.

Also I know the Mavs had an extremely good offense without Luka, however the fact that Luka was able to BOOST that offense to the best ever when playing, along with the fact that Porzingis was unimpressive offensively for most of the year, and the lack of a great secondary playmaker/initiator is absurd. I do not believe Magic/Nash/Lebron are doing anything close to that at a similar age.


The thing is relatively speaking luka didnt boost the offense to best ever, he boosted a offense thats the best ever without their star to be really good with their star

Its impressive he boosted it but it isnt that insane of a boost.

But relatively speaking, the 2017 cavs with lebron or kyrie, 2016,2017,2018,2019 warriors with curry, 2017,2018 rockets with harden are all better than the 2020 mavs with luka.

Even in 2020, the clips with kawhi are a better offense than the mavs with luka as well.

What seperates them is those teams go to bottom of the league tier without their main star, while the mavs are quite literally still the best offense in the league without luka

Sure what hes doing is still insane but saying hes leading the GOAT offense is misleading when the offense with luka on the court is barely cracking the top 10 over the past 5 years compared to the other top offenses with their stars on the court, and not even first this tear
Doctor MJ
Senior Mod
Senior Mod
Posts: 53,684
And1: 22,631
Joined: Mar 10, 2005
Location: Cali
     

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#334 » by Doctor MJ » Sat Sep 12, 2020 11:31 pm

So, I posted a bit ago saying I'd make a list when all the 2nd round series were done, but I'm realizing there's so much uncertainty that I don't think I'll do that. Instead I'll just put thoughts down, starting now.

Players listed below are not ranked, but the guys springing to mind first are generally going to be higher ranked:

LeBron James & Kawhi Leonard - obviously the POY is likely to be one of these two guys. To me there were 3 top players through the season, and with the Bucks lost, these two guys seem the cream of the crop. Not a ton to say here.

Anthony Davis - has a clear route to at least getting to the top 3. Will consider him above LeBron if he plays well enough, and if he does that on the way to the title, he could end up #1. Upcoming series will ultimate define how we see his performance this year, but to this point, I'd say he's done superbly.

Giannis Antetokounmpo - it will be tough to slot Giannis in. Once definitely the case is that how Miami does in the next round, and how the ECF champ does in the finals will influence me. If Miami gets killed, and then Boston gets killed, I might have a Top 5 that's entirely from the West. On the other hand, if Miami wins the title, maybe Giannis and the Bucks won't look so bad. I do find myself thinking in general that it's an overreaction to move any other 1st or 2nd round exit ahead of him.

Jayson Tatum & Jimmy Butler - it seems likely that whoever is the best player of the ECF will have a strong case for Top 5 and being put ahead of Giannis. I'll be thinking on that a lot though.

James Harden & Nikola Jokic - Presuming their out in the 2nd round, they have good Top 5 candidacies, but they're on the borderline though.

Chris Paul, Luka Doncic & Damian Lillard - And then there are the 1st round exits who seem very much on the same tier as Harden & Jokic. Interested to hear thoughts as we get deeper into the playoffs.

I'll note that I typically do a straight 1-5 ranking, and then name 5 other guys "Honorable Mention" as the other "Top 10 guys". I've already mentioned 11 guys though, and then there's Kyle Lowry. This is a deep year!
Getting ready for the RealGM 100 on the PC Board

Come join the WNBA Board if you're a fan!
User avatar
GSP
RealGM
Posts: 19,561
And1: 16,036
Joined: Dec 12, 2011
     

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#335 » by GSP » Sat Sep 12, 2020 11:44 pm

Doctor MJ wrote:So, I posted a bit ago saying I'd make a list when all the 2nd round series were done, but I'm realizing there's so much uncertainty that I don't think I'll do that. Instead I'll just put thoughts down, starting now.

Players listed below are not ranked, but the guys springing to mind first are generally going to be higher ranked:

LeBron James & Kawhi Leonard - obviously the POY is likely to be one of these two guys. To me there were 3 top players through the season, and with the Bucks lost, these two guys seem the cream of the crop. Not a ton to say here.

Anthony Davis - has a clear route to at least getting to the top 3. Will consider him above LeBron if he plays well enough, and if he does that on the way to the title, he could end up #1. Upcoming series will ultimate define how we see his performance this year, but to this point, I'd say he's done superbly.

Giannis Antetokounmpo - it will be tough to slot Giannis in. Once definitely the case is that how Miami does in the next round, and how the ECF champ does in the finals will influence me. If Miami gets killed, and then Boston gets killed, I might have a Top 5 that's entirely from the West. On the other hand, if Miami wins the title, maybe Giannis and the Bucks won't look so bad. I do find myself thinking in general that it's an overreaction to move any other 1st or 2nd round exit ahead of him.

Jayson Tatum & Jimmy Butler - it seems likely that whoever is the best player of the ECF will have a strong case for Top 5 and being put ahead of Giannis. I'll be thinking on that a lot though.

James Harden & Nikola Jokic - Presuming their out in the 2nd round, they have good Top 5 candidacies, but they're on the borderline though.

Chris Paul, Luka Doncic & Damian Lillard - And then there are the 1st round exits who seem very much on the same tier as Harden & Jokic. Interested to hear thoughts as we get deeper into the playoffs.

I'll note that I typically do a straight 1-5 ranking, and then name 5 other guys "Honorable Mention" as the other "Top 10 guys". I've already mentioned 11 guys though, and then there's Kyle Lowry. This is a deep year!


What about Rudy Gobert? He had a fine season and a great playoffs too

Hes clearly the 2nd best center in the league this season to Jokic IMO
User avatar
eminence
RealGM
Posts: 17,123
And1: 11,909
Joined: Mar 07, 2015

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#336 » by eminence » Sun Sep 13, 2020 12:00 am

Agree with Doc MJ on other 1st/2nd round exits not passing Giannis.
I bought a boat.
Doctor MJ
Senior Mod
Senior Mod
Posts: 53,684
And1: 22,631
Joined: Mar 10, 2005
Location: Cali
     

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#337 » by Doctor MJ » Sun Sep 13, 2020 5:11 am

GSP wrote:What about Rudy Gobert? He had a fine season and a great playoffs too

Hes clearly the 2nd best center in the league this season to Jokic IMO


I don't think it's crazy to bring him up certainly. I will say that while the Jazz were winning their playoff series, it felt like Mitchell's show to me.
Getting ready for the RealGM 100 on the PC Board

Come join the WNBA Board if you're a fan!
ardee
RealGM
Posts: 15,320
And1: 5,397
Joined: Nov 16, 2011

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#338 » by ardee » Sun Sep 13, 2020 10:56 am

I am in line with Doctor MJ on this a fair bit. Right now I would go:

1. LeBron James
2. Kawhi Leonard
3. Anthony Davis
4. Giannis Antetokounmpo
5. Luka Doncic

Harden is a close 6th.

I imagine this will probably be the top 5 in some order when it's said and done unless the Clippers completely wet the bed and Jokic makes the WCF. I don't envision Tatum or Butler playing their way into the top 5 under any circumstances: they simply did not have the RS chops.

The top 3 is in flux and could likely end in any order.
Jordan Syndrome
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,814
And1: 1,425
Joined: Jun 29, 2020
 

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#339 » by Jordan Syndrome » Sun Sep 13, 2020 12:53 pm

limbo wrote:LeBron
Kawhi
Harden
Giannis
AD
-
Luka
Jokic
Butler
Tatum
Lillard
-
Paul
Embiid
Gobert
Bam
Lowry

This is how i feel about my Top 15 right now.


Are your '-' used to separate tiers or simply every 5 players?
BelgradeNugget
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,872
And1: 3,886
Joined: Jun 16, 2018
 

Re: 2019-2020 Player of the Year Discussion Thread 

Post#340 » by BelgradeNugget » Sun Sep 13, 2020 1:03 pm

MyUniBroDavis wrote:On jokic:

I havent watched the nuggets much outside of a few games against the jazz but the knock on him vs the others is always gonna be his defense. I mean he was kind of atrocious on D when i saw him and i remember dray did a segment on it to, he just really sucked at rotating. Has that changed?

- i dont like net rtg over small samples but jesus christ his defense is +23 lmfao

For as good as he is offensively, and to be perfectly honest i definately dont think hes been better than davis on that end so far, theres just kind of a huge gap on D

Lebrons not even a conversation really. Its really impressive how he handled gobert, but its kinda offset by being part of the opposing teams offensive gameplan too

It usualy takes more than a few games to form a good opinion. He is a much better defender than he showed in the first part of the Utah series. Was it due to having COVID before bubble or the Nuggets missing Harris it is questionable. The Nuggets and Jokic were much better defensively in the Clippers series, mostly due to more effort, better pnr defense (2 man game) better game plane...

Return to Player Comparisons