Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
Moderators: Domejandro, infinite11285, Harry Garris, ken6199, Dirk, bisme37, KingDavid, bwgood77, zimpy27, cupcakesnake
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Rookie
- Posts: 1,131
- And1: 1,766
- Joined: Dec 23, 2014
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
Rockets run everything through Harden, and Harden has a historically high usage rate.
But, when the game is on the line in a pressure situation, he crumbles basically every single time, and that's one of the big reason why Rockets kept failing in PO.
For example, this is what Harden did last year against Warriors after Durant was out.
Game 5, 4th quarter. Harden played 11 minutes and scored 3 points, shooting 1-2 from the field with 1 technical free throw until the 1-minute mark. He added 2 more points with 18 seconds left when Warriors defended 3 pts line to give up a layup. In contrast, Curry dropped 12 pts in the 4th quarter. After everything happened and went through all those complaining last PO, Rockets finally got a golden chance to beat Warriors with KD out of the picture. Then, Harden completely disappeared in the 4th quarter. It was one of the most strange games I saw.
Game 6, 4th quarter. Harden played 10 minutes and scored 4 points, shooting 2-6 from the field until a 1-minute mark. He added 5 more points at the last minute, but the game was already out of the reach. In contrast, Curry carried Warriors to the conference by dropping 23 pts in the 4th quarter, 33 pts in 2nd half after going scoreless in the first half.
This happens over and over again in PO.
Harden's overall PO number isn't that horrible. But in key moments like the 4th quarter, Harden keeps pulling disappearing acts like that. Until he reverses his performances in key moments, he won't be able to shake up his reputation.
But, when the game is on the line in a pressure situation, he crumbles basically every single time, and that's one of the big reason why Rockets kept failing in PO.
For example, this is what Harden did last year against Warriors after Durant was out.
Game 5, 4th quarter. Harden played 11 minutes and scored 3 points, shooting 1-2 from the field with 1 technical free throw until the 1-minute mark. He added 2 more points with 18 seconds left when Warriors defended 3 pts line to give up a layup. In contrast, Curry dropped 12 pts in the 4th quarter. After everything happened and went through all those complaining last PO, Rockets finally got a golden chance to beat Warriors with KD out of the picture. Then, Harden completely disappeared in the 4th quarter. It was one of the most strange games I saw.
Game 6, 4th quarter. Harden played 10 minutes and scored 4 points, shooting 2-6 from the field until a 1-minute mark. He added 5 more points at the last minute, but the game was already out of the reach. In contrast, Curry carried Warriors to the conference by dropping 23 pts in the 4th quarter, 33 pts in 2nd half after going scoreless in the first half.
This happens over and over again in PO.
Harden's overall PO number isn't that horrible. But in key moments like the 4th quarter, Harden keeps pulling disappearing acts like that. Until he reverses his performances in key moments, he won't be able to shake up his reputation.
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,999
- And1: 5,559
- Joined: Mar 25, 2011
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
OP, why do you hate KD so much?
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,447
- And1: 2,217
- Joined: May 27, 2013
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
"Rise up, gather round, rock this place, to the ground"
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Junior
- Posts: 362
- And1: 427
- Joined: Jan 20, 2020
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
OP,
No one needs any stats, especially not DBPM, to tell that Kevin Durant is a much better defender than James Harden. I don’t think many people are going to be very interested in a math, deep-dive comparison on both players.
KD peaked in GS. Excluding his time there excludes his peak.
No one needs any stats, especially not DBPM, to tell that Kevin Durant is a much better defender than James Harden. I don’t think many people are going to be very interested in a math, deep-dive comparison on both players.
KD peaked in GS. Excluding his time there excludes his peak.
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 4,486
- And1: 2,757
- Joined: Nov 13, 2010
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
KD is still better. I will say this though, KD will have the better career, but Harden is going to end up with the better well-rounded numbers. If Harden wins a ring or two, an argument can be made for him being on par with KD.
Thanks for all the great memories, LeBron! The show must go on! #Heatnation
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Senior
- Posts: 687
- And1: 1,152
- Joined: Jan 24, 2020
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
traax wrote:Durant shows up on the biggest stage, when Harden crumbles under pressure. Your cherry picked stats obviously dont show that. Leaving our Durants two titles and FMVPS, how pathetic is that?
Just like how Durant cherry picked teams?
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 14,922
- And1: 17,764
- Joined: Feb 24, 2007
- Location: Ontario, Canada
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
Who are these people of whom people keep saying they said stuff?
Maxpainmedia:
"NYC has the **** most Two Faced fans, but we ALL loved IQ,, and that is super rare, I've been a Knicks fan for 37 years, this kid is a star and he will snap in Toronto"
"NYC has the **** most Two Faced fans, but we ALL loved IQ,, and that is super rare, I've been a Knicks fan for 37 years, this kid is a star and he will snap in Toronto"
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
- stormi
- General Manager
- Posts: 7,623
- And1: 7,650
- Joined: Jun 04, 2019
- Location: The Royal Capital: Leyndell
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
Lockdown504090 wrote:Drygon wrote:Obviously, KD is easily among the greats in NBA history & even his biggest haters will admit it.
But whenever KD & Harden are compared to eachother, people says he's clearly better than Harden without elaborating it.
Just looking into playoff statistics when KD and Harden had same level of supporting casts on OKC & Houston Rockets respectively while being undisupted most valuable/impactful player, Harden actually has an edge on KD. Simply due to playmaking skills & having slightly better TS% despite KD's scoring were heavily assisted.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kevin Durant at Oklahoma City Thunder (2009-2016)
Playoffs
- 28.9 PPG, 8.0 RPG, 3.7 APG
- 45.5 FG%, 32.9 3P%, 84.8 FT% on 57.5 TS% (46.2% of 2Ps & 73.9% of 3Ps assisted)
- 0.177 WS/48
- 6.3 BPM
- 0 Rings
- 0 Finals MVPs
James Harden at Houston Rockets (2012-2020)
Playoffs
- 28.4 PPG, 5.7 RPG, 7.1 APG
- 42.1 FG%, 32.4 3P%, 87.1 FT% on 57.8 TS% (15.0% of 2Ps & 30.8% of 3Ps assisted)
- 0.173 WS/48
- 7.6 BPM
- 0 Rings
- 0 Finals MVPs
Durant is obviously a better playoff perfoemer because of the variety in how he scores harden's numbers are inflated by houstons system..... thats what I thought at first.
But watch Harden before he started completely buying into the moneyball system. its staggering how much the warriors are guessing and struggling to defend him.
;t=79s&ab_channel=ColliderSports
I wonder now if harden just wasted 3-4 years of his prime playing in a grade school offense with a coach who plays too much 2k. the man looked like he was on his way to being better than wade, before the Morey and D'antoni convinced him to change his game.
Mind boggling how talented this guy is
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
- LOUiS-D
- Assistant Coach
- Posts: 4,134
- And1: 1,900
- Joined: Jan 19, 2006
- Location: melbourne, australia
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
If people are questioning whether an MVP and future hall of famer is better than you, you're probably pretty damn good. They're both masters. I have no shade to throw.
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,532
- And1: 4,452
- Joined: Aug 02, 2016
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
I honestly see them as basically being the same. Neither of them have a signature moment where they really defied expectations and carried a team to ridiculous heights. I look for these guys to have a game like Luka did against the Clippers or LeBron had against the Pistons in 2007 where he scored 29 of his teams last 30 points or anything like that. Instead, generally when things got hard or above their literal day to day level of ability, they just folded or lost or came up short. Harden has more epic failures, but also generally a bit more on his shoulders. You can kinda put Steph in here too. For me it's like the Barkley/Karl Malone tier.
KD is proof of why in a way he was right to go to GSW. There are people that will reward him for the move. He's a champion now, but really, put any top 10 player there they still likely win. I really don't look at him any differently than I did when he was in OKC. There's no arc. No narrative. He couldn't beat 'em, so he joined 'em. LeBron and MJ added stuff/elements to their game (MJ did Triangle offense and played off ball more, LeBron improved his jumper, got a post game, became smarter reading the game) and pushed themselves to new levels. KD never did. Harden added a floater, but more or less the same stuff.
KD is proof of why in a way he was right to go to GSW. There are people that will reward him for the move. He's a champion now, but really, put any top 10 player there they still likely win. I really don't look at him any differently than I did when he was in OKC. There's no arc. No narrative. He couldn't beat 'em, so he joined 'em. LeBron and MJ added stuff/elements to their game (MJ did Triangle offense and played off ball more, LeBron improved his jumper, got a post game, became smarter reading the game) and pushed themselves to new levels. KD never did. Harden added a floater, but more or less the same stuff.
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
- LarsV8
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,621
- And1: 3,836
- Joined: Dec 13, 2009
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
Roughly equivalent caliber players.
No one will admit since they are completely biased.
And lol at the playoff numbers, they are almost identical.
Only difference is Harden lost to better teams, Durant lost to worse teams.
No one will admit since they are completely biased.
And lol at the playoff numbers, they are almost identical.
Only difference is Harden lost to better teams, Durant lost to worse teams.
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,254
- And1: 9,770
- Joined: May 19, 2017
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
I love how defense doesn't matter when KD is compared to another player... Yes Durant is better than Harden.
Sent from my SM-G960U1 using RealGM mobile app
Sent from my SM-G960U1 using RealGM mobile app
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,693
- And1: 9,035
- Joined: Mar 29, 2005
- Location: So long Wizturdz.
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
traax wrote:Durant shows up on the biggest stage, when Harden crumbles under pressure. Your cherry picked stats obviously dont show that. Leaving our Durants two titles and FMVPS, how pathetic is that?
Is it cherry picking, or is it simply an attempt to normalize those numbers to make a more apples to apples comparison?
At least what the op used to frame his argument is quantifiable, unlike things like "intangibles", "shows up at the biggest stage", "crumbles under pressure" etc.
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
- PhilBlackson
- RealGM
- Posts: 27,817
- And1: 42,158
- Joined: May 02, 2017
- Location: No Wastemans Land
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
I'll gladly take KD over the biggest choking "superstar" maybe of all time.
>>>SCOTTIEALLSTARSEASON<<< -- U KNOW THE VIBEZ Club Shai Shai
Taking names of who OG will be better than Shaedon: DelAbbott, ThaCynic, pingpongrac, Los_29, OakleyDokley
Taking names of who OG will be better than Shaedon: DelAbbott, ThaCynic, pingpongrac, Los_29, OakleyDokley
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
- King4Day
- RealGM
- Posts: 13,037
- And1: 9,191
- Joined: Dec 11, 2010
- Location: Pandora
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
His defense/effort is the difference between the 2.
"Sometimes, the dragon wins" #RallyTheValley
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
- iLLmatic860
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,232
- And1: 15,165
- Joined: Jan 23, 2013
- Location: Tampa
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
Harden most likely will be better than ruptured acchillies kd from now on
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,736
- And1: 4,723
- Joined: Dec 18, 2018
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
GregOden wrote:KD is a generational elite shot maker, whereas James Harden is elite at playing the refs. Let's just compare them on Team USA. Kevin Durant is the #1 option and entire opposing teams scheme to stop him, whereas James Harden is basically a scrub in FIBA because he can't march his way to the FT line.
How can you say that when it's other way around?
James Harden in playoffs (2012-2020): 57.8 TS% (15.0% of 2Ps & 30.8% of 3Ps assisted)
Kevin Durant in playoffs (2010-2016): 57.5 TS% (46.2% of 2Ps & 73.9% of 3Ps assisted)
DaPessimist wrote:Drygon wrote:DaPessimist wrote:Peak KD was a tier above Harden.
I assume you're talking about KD's peak at OKC, right?
His 2nd year with the Warriors he was the best scorer in the league and a DPOY candidate. One of the most complete players I've ever seen play the game.
KD was never DPOY candidate in GSW.
During 2018, his DRPM was -0.65, 357th out of 521 players in the NBA and 59th out of small forwards
http://www.espn.com/nba/statistics/rpm/_/page/9/sort/DRPM
DarkXaero wrote:OP, why do you hate KD so much?
I don't hate KD, I'm just being objective here.
IzzyT wrote:OP,
No one needs any stats, especially not DBPM, to tell that Kevin Durant is a much better defender than James Harden. I don’t think many people are going to be very interested in a math, deep-dive comparison on both players.
KD peaked in GS. Excluding his time there excludes his peak.
KD definitely peaked in GSW as a player, although Harden would also get inflated numbers playing with Curry & Klay.
People is discreding KD's rings anyway, so why suddenly give credit for the stats KD was putting up?
You can't eat your cake and have it
When both Harden & KD didn't have a stacked deck, Harden was better than KD & the stats proves it.
Run DLC wrote:KD is still better. I will say this though, KD will have the better career, but Harden is going to end up with the better we’ll-rounded numbers. If Harden wins a ring or two, an argument can be made for him being on par with KD.
Harden's scoring is equal with KD, but has better TS%. And Harden is superior playmaker, how does it make KD better?
I do also think KD's career is better than Hardens, but only due to joining GSW.
LOUiS-D wrote:If people are questioning whether an MVP and future hall of famer is better than you, you're probably pretty damn good. They're both masters. I have no shade to throw.
Kawhi has no MVP & only 55% HOF probability (barely above Blake Griffin's 54% HOF, a player who won't be a HOFer).
And I'd still rate Kawhi over KD.
Karate Diop wrote:I love how defense doesn't matter when KD is compared to another player... Yes Durant is better than Harden.
Sent from my SM-G960U1 using RealGM mobile app
Harden's DBPM is higher than KD, which I already stated in my thread lol.
Also, a good offensive player that's average defensively is always going to more valuable than a good defensive player that's average offensively. Its just too much of a cliche to say "defense is half of the game" because its not. Harden during his worst defensive years was a better player than Draymond Green for example.
PhilBlackson wrote:I'll gladly take KD over the biggest choking "superstar" maybe of all time.
You do realize KD himself was a choker, even blowing a 3-1 lead to GSW. The same team KD joined in very next off season.
DaT WaVeY RiCaN wrote:Harden most likely will be better than ruptured acchillies kd from now on
That's not much of accomplishment. Harden was objectivly better playoff performer than OKC's version of KD.
Nobody is backing up their arguments with stats on why KD > Harden other than anedoctal evidence
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,736
- And1: 4,723
- Joined: Dec 18, 2018
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
LarsV8 wrote:Roughly equivalent caliber players.
No one will admit since they are completely biased.
And lol at the playoff numbers, they are almost identical.
Only difference is Harden lost to better teams, Durant lost to worse teams.
It just shows how much KD's 2 "worthless" rings has improved his legacy & will go down as top 15 player in NBA history.
Nobody talked about KD reaching those heights in all-time ranking during his days at OKC.
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
-
- Sophomore
- Posts: 104
- And1: 59
- Joined: Oct 04, 2020
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
Can't stand KD but he is clearly a tier ahead of Harden. Harden, Westbrook and PG would make a fine playoff big 3 one would think
Sent from my SM-G960F using RealGM mobile app
Sent from my SM-G960F using RealGM mobile app
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
- Clay Davis
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,492
- And1: 6,688
- Joined: Nov 06, 2013
Re: Is Kevin Durant overrated when people says he's clearly above James Harden?
Yesss OP
Steelo Green wrote:People are expecting way too much from Barnes out of the get go. He is a project player who will need 2-3 years before he makes a major impact.