MrFortune3 wrote:dougthonus wrote:MrFortune3 wrote:I follow college recruiting heavily so that may cloud my judgement on the perception of the draft but no one was saying this draft was supposed to be weak from the things I usually read.
Only when the season kicked off and guys struggled was there talk of weaker draft.
As I said "no clear top picks" is code for "weak draft". Every draft prospectus I could find either did not comment on the strength of the draft at all or made some statement like the above. Do you have anything from what you read that mentioned it as a strong draft?
I don't know that people often mention drafts as weak, because they never know who will emerge, but they often mention them as strong when they know they are good going in. It may certainly be the case that this was just a class where there was no clear great players, and maybe someone emerges and one does. It hinted at being weak early and as time went on, it got worse and worse.
I don't know much about the 2021 class either. I've just heard people say its a strong class. I remember at my draft party last year people saying 2020 wasn't a good class but 2021 was. That said, unlikely you, I do not follow college recruiting. I can not even name a guy in the 2021 draft without looking it up. I don't know that its true that it will be strong and am only repeating (in both cases) what I have heard others say.
My primary issue with that is the perception. People usually refer to a draft as extremely strong when there is a generational talent.
2012 had Davis and he was the clear #1 but the overall draft itself was weak yet it produced AD, Beal, Dame and Drummond in the 1st. Also Draymond, Middleton and Barnes.
2015 was considered stronger but no clear top pick until late when KAT was deemed the top guy due to defensive potential(lol)
It still produced KAT, Russell, Porzingis and Booker. Also Turner, Oubre Jr, Rozier.
Weak vs Strong produces nearly identical results from a sheer number of valuable players perspective. LeBron's draft year is an outlier similar to the 1983 and 2004 NFL drafts that produced legendary QB's.
I do think you are right that people tend to grade a draft by the value of its top few prospects, a counter would be 2018 was viewed as a strong draft, lots of good players in it but no obvious franchise star even though it is possible a couple emerged. 2019 had a couple franchise talents but wasn't viewed as a strong class overall.


















