mademan wrote:MavCarter wrote:mademan wrote:
Who's this team with inferior talent? Did raps have 1 series with Casey where they had the best player? Not against the Nets, not against the Wiz, not against the Pacers.
NBA is a game of talent. Im not even saying this to disparage Nurse or prop up Casey. I think a coach can hurt you, but ultimately, youre as good as your best players. Raps won when they had the best players (2019, i think a case can be made for Philly) and lost when they didnt. Here and there a team wins without the best players, but it's a rarity.
People here prop up Nurse like he's a king or something, but it's always been Lowry. He's a RS superstar and so we're RS monsters. When the playoffs slow down, he becomes limited by his size and lack of top end athleticism. The Raps as a whole get exposed for having a lack of talent, and so they lose to objectively worse teams from the RS, like the C's last year, regardless of who's the coach.
If the "he didn't have the best player on the floor" excuse is being used for getting swept/struggling vs 7th seeds in the first round why isn't it being used when we take the superiorly talented celtics 7 games with regular season star kyle lowry? You're whole argument started by trying to discredit nurse winning a championship and using strawman argument points to put him in the same category as casey. Is it fair to say popovich is comparable to casey also because if you take away kawhi/tim duncan and all the championships and give them derozan instead they're isnt much difference? Lets just take away championships and superstars when talking about coaches now. They'll all be on the same level
The entirety of my argument was what i put in that last post. Coaches dont matter much. Bad coaches can really hurt you, but an average coach is not to different than a great coach, and it's near impossible to measure. Nurse winning and Casey losing boils down to 1 having the best team/player in every series he played and the other not having it. Thats the story of the league; the best players usually win. Nurse got put on a pedestal because of that when he shouldnt have
Answer my question, are gregg popovich and dwane casey basically comparable coaches?





















