ImageImageImageImage

Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Magic Expected To Retain Core

Moderators: Def Swami, Howard Mass, ChosenSavior, UCF, Knightro, UCFJayBird

User avatar
MagicStarwipe
RealGM
Posts: 16,911
And1: 12,064
Joined: May 19, 2007
 

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#401 » by MagicStarwipe » Tue Feb 2, 2021 4:03 am

pepe1991 wrote:
MagicStarwipe wrote:
Magicfanatic82 wrote:AG and Evan should get moved first. Birch could maybe get paired with a 2nd to get someone like Shamet or another young wing.
There us value to Vuc and Ross being on the roster. If we get a high pick, they take scoring pressure off of the young players and provide spacing for Isaac and Fultz. They also by all accounts are solid in the locker room. Same with Aminu, his value is so low he is fine as depth and a vet for us.


The teams culture won't change until Vuc is gone. With him being here so long as the centrepiece, we've taken on his personality. No matter what other players we bring in, this is Vuc's team. Time for him to go to a team where he isn't the best player and time for us to begin a new era.


Where i don't care whether or not Vuc would be traded, i find this thought process very idiotic one.
NBA is talent driven league. In past 9 years ,since Vuc has been part of organisation, not a single nba player he played with was actually better basketball player than him.
And guess what, it's not like he was man in charge of free agency, trades and failed draft decisons. He always was safe net for terrible coaches, terrible GMs and terrible presidents of basketball operations. Him being good player on it's own, despite incopetence all around him made their jobs more secured than they should be.

Your opinion would have some validity if Vuc was some hot head bully like Whiteside or Cousins that is literally bulling his path toward usage, panderin offense to him and scares coaches into defering to him. Vuc is most lay low, supportive player Magic got. Every single young player raved how much Vuc helped him, on other side, Vuc was first to defend Isaac not kneeling for national anthem and was supportive about Fultz taking over 4th quaters. For crying out loud guy celebrated Cole's buzzerbeater more than Cole lol

So in general this is very missleading comment. Magic didn't took his personality, Magic are just as good as their best player is. And that's good enough to make playoffs if they are healthy, and not good enough to win playoff series. That's what Vuc is, supporting,complimentary star. But it's not his fault "complimentary star" is closest thing to good player team got since Dwight left. It's literally fault of everybody around him, but him, including players, especially lottery picks, who flat out did not work hard enough to get there ( Gordon, Payton, Hezonja, Oladipo pre trade, Isaac, Bamba... you name it ).


Well let me elaborate on the "culture" that I'm referring to. Vuc is a good player, great guy, probably a really good teammate. All true. The other side of Vuc is he has the tendency to let his emotions get the better of him when things don't go his way which causes things to spiral down. Also, I'm not sure if winning is as important to him as it could be. His intensity and desire on defense has definitely dipped since Clifford's first season.

What I don't want to happen is for us to be fortunate enough to draft a young stud who comes in and takes a back seat to Vuc because it's his team. Nor do I want him to have the chance to be influenced by his nonchalant attitude. Now if we draft a really sure of himself, confident, mentally strong young stud who already knows how to play, all of that stuff probably won't matter much and he'll just take over naturally.
Image
RealGM Classics - Oladipo's "rude" celebration comes back to bite him: viewtopic.php?f=25&t=1358414
GelbeWand09
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,731
And1: 2,065
Joined: Apr 17, 2018
       

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#402 » by GelbeWand09 » Tue Feb 2, 2021 8:45 am

EasternMagic wrote:Fire sale time!!!

It's time!

Trade Fournier for a soda machine!
Trade Vuc for the best available offer!
Trade AG if he can come back before the deadline!

Play Cole!
Play Bamba!
Play Chuma!
Get a good draft pick!
This is the year to do it! Don't hedge the future on making the playoffs in a throwaway year.

I have never supported tanking, however, when your roster has put you in a place where tanking is the only option, may as well lean in.


I think there is almost zero chance we gonna trade Vuc. 1st because of very limited trading options for a player type like Vuc on that contract. 2nd because WeHam need him to sell the vision of a big bounceback year to the ownership & fans to save there jobs. If they trade him, its rebuild time & there legacy are 2 first round exits as 7th-8th place (the 2nd with one of the worst records ever for a playoff team), while having a top 5 salary & the same team Henny drafted, while doing literally nothing in 4years, except drafting & signing bad end of the bench vets. They probably wont survive that.
I Rasharted
Sixth Man
Posts: 1,741
And1: 942
Joined: Nov 05, 2010
 

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#403 » by I Rasharted » Tue Feb 2, 2021 2:00 pm

Quick summary of WeHam's rebuild:

basketballRob wrote:Another good benefit about eating plants is that the artery going to your penis gets unclogged and starts flowing real good.
User avatar
Ducklett
General Manager
Posts: 8,099
And1: 5,526
Joined: Jul 17, 2012
 

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#404 » by Ducklett » Tue Feb 2, 2021 2:20 pm

"The two best centers when it comes to defending without fouling are Al Horford and Vucevic, and that has been the case each of the last few years. This season so far, Vucevic is averaging just 1.7 fouls per game, which for someone who plays as many minutes as he does in a starting role is not only rare, it’s potentially historic. "

Interesting stat.
User avatar
PrimeThyme
RealGM
Posts: 10,607
And1: 14,546
Joined: May 25, 2016
Location: Doak Campbell
 

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#405 » by PrimeThyme » Tue Feb 2, 2021 2:23 pm

You know, Vuc has grown on me over the years. Particularly over the last 3 seasons when he has started to take more 3’s and really modernize his game. He’s not a player we have to move IMO.

Especially considering we should be targeting a guard in this upcoming draft && I think with his pick n roll/pop ability and his floor stretching he’s actually the perfect type of modern center to develop a guard next to offensively.

Fournier/AG are higher on the priority list for me, though you could certainly talk me into moving Vuc for draft capital if the right deal is there.

Not sure it is though.
Image
zaymon
Head Coach
Posts: 6,128
And1: 3,437
Joined: Jul 01, 2015
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#406 » by zaymon » Tue Feb 2, 2021 3:32 pm

The Effect wrote:
zaymon wrote:
The Effect wrote:Im probably the only person on this site that would want to trade isaac
I think hes too injury prone and too much of a liablity on offense to be a franchise cornerstone.
I really hate the idea of build a team around a 3&D guy who is going to miss 60% of your games and really cant create any offense outside of kickout 3s

I get hes an all-nba level defender and that hes everyones hope for a franchise player, but that does nothing for us when hes in a suit and tie every game, and really he only makes an impact at one side of the court. I get why everyone lose him, but im not in that group

Too me, my order of trading guys from out "core" would be

1 - Evan - please trade him already!
2 - Ross - cant deal with the black hole when hes in the game. the ball literally stops moving and gets forced to him to take every shot. When hes hot, sure thats alright i guess (still takes too many bad shots), but when hes off, its an automatic loss
3 - Isaac - I would say id rather trade vuc than him, but i would list him above vuc because id ASSUME he would have higher trade value.
4 - Vuc - If we can trade him for a valuable return, do it, but im not holding my breath

Gordon\Fultz\Cole - im not trading


So you literally want to trade our best players and build around worst ? Thats bold. I like Cole but he has a long way to go.



We are a perennial .500 team whos BEST hope is a 7 seed.....we our best arent exactly great
Ive explained WAY too many times why i would trade Isaac and why i dont consider him a cornerstone\franchise player so im not going to rehash all that, but to me thats the only one thats debatable. None of Evan\ross\vuc are top 3 options on a contender.

Fultz and cole are still super young and shown enough potential to be guys to build around, and gordon to me is the only guy on the team who plays with a chip on his shoulder and actually cares about wins and loses. Is he our most talented? no but he is talented. Does he have the most potential? no not anymore, but hes still young enough to devlop a bit more (no im not saying hes going to be kawhi or anything). Is he our most athletic...ok yeah this one he is, sure... but all in all he would be a guy i would build around

Who knows, maybe he just needs to be surrounded by a different type of cast. Like whos to say he couldnt be a more athletic Draymond green if surrounded by some stars instead of medicore Buddy Ball EVuc? Not trying to make excuses for him, he is what is, but to me its hard to just completely write him off considering hes played in the same offense scheme his whole career, surrounded by the same cast

In the end it matters who will want to stay with us. I dont think AG will want to resign after his contract is over. He seems more interested in himself and art than our team. I also think he is very hard to build around. Average shooter average passer, average dribbler, awful touch. I dont agree we have bad players around him, actually Vucevic and Fournier are quite good fits to hide his deficiences,.without them he would be even worse. I respect your opinion but in the nba you need to go with upside. All star center and dpoy forward have higher ceiling than below average pg and role player high flying forward. Yes we must gamble on Isaac health, but i wouldnt say its such a bad gamble. Cole and Okeke are interesting. We moved Dj to play Cole now we must move AG to play Isaac and Okeke.
My money is on Banchero going number 1 !
yoyojw17
Lead Assistant
Posts: 5,840
And1: 3,448
Joined: Dec 26, 2011
Location: Gainesville,FL
 

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#407 » by yoyojw17 » Tue Feb 2, 2021 3:48 pm

pepe1991 wrote:
MagicStarwipe wrote:
Magicfanatic82 wrote:AG and Evan should get moved first. Birch could maybe get paired with a 2nd to get someone like Shamet or another young wing.
There us value to Vuc and Ross being on the roster. If we get a high pick, they take scoring pressure off of the young players and provide spacing for Isaac and Fultz. They also by all accounts are solid in the locker room. Same with Aminu, his value is so low he is fine as depth and a vet for us.


The teams culture won't change until Vuc is gone. With him being here so long as the centrepiece, we've taken on his personality. No matter what other players we bring in, this is Vuc's team. Time for him to go to a team where he isn't the best player and time for us to begin a new era.


Where i don't care whether or not Vuc would be traded, i find this thought process very idiotic one.
NBA is talent driven league. In past 9 years ,since Vuc has been part of organisation, not a single nba player he played with was actually better basketball player than him.
And guess what, it's not like he was man in charge of free agency, trades and failed draft decisons. He always was safe net for terrible coaches, terrible GMs and terrible presidents of basketball operations. Him being good player on it's own, despite incopetence all around him made their jobs more secured than they should be.

Your opinion would have some validity if Vuc was some hot head bully like Whiteside or Cousins that is literally bulling his path toward usage, panderin offense to him and scares coaches into defering to him. Vuc is most lay low, supportive player Magic got. Every single young player raved how much Vuc helped him, on other side, Vuc was first to defend Isaac not kneeling for national anthem and was supportive about Fultz taking over 4th quaters. For crying out loud guy celebrated Cole's buzzerbeater more than Cole lol

So in general this is very missleading comment. Magic didn't took his personality, Magic are just as good as their best player is. And that's good enough to make playoffs if they are healthy, and not good enough to win playoff series. That's what Vuc is, supporting,complimentary star. But it's not his fault "complimentary star" is closest thing to good player team got since Dwight left. It's literally fault of everybody around him, but him, including players, especially lottery picks, who flat out did not work hard enough to get there ( Gordon, Payton, Hezonja, Oladipo pre trade, Isaac, Bamba... you name it ).


Lol... it's crazy how much flack Vuc gets for just going out there and doing his best. And so much is taken out of context and dissected. :-/ "We haven't won since vuc has been here"... lol... I'm sure no one was saying that about AD when he couldn't drag the pelicans into contention on his lonesome. haha
The Effect
Magic Forum Mock Draft Co-Champ
Posts: 4,891
And1: 2,119
Joined: Jul 09, 2004

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#408 » by The Effect » Tue Feb 2, 2021 3:55 pm

zaymon wrote:
The Effect wrote:
zaymon wrote:
So you literally want to trade our best players and build around worst ? Thats bold. I like Cole but he has a long way to go.



We are a perennial .500 team whos BEST hope is a 7 seed.....we our best arent exactly great
Ive explained WAY too many times why i would trade Isaac and why i dont consider him a cornerstone\franchise player so im not going to rehash all that, but to me thats the only one thats debatable. None of Evan\ross\vuc are top 3 options on a contender.

Fultz and cole are still super young and shown enough potential to be guys to build around, and gordon to me is the only guy on the team who plays with a chip on his shoulder and actually cares about wins and loses. Is he our most talented? no but he is talented. Does he have the most potential? no not anymore, but hes still young enough to devlop a bit more (no im not saying hes going to be kawhi or anything). Is he our most athletic...ok yeah this one he is, sure... but all in all he would be a guy i would build around

Who knows, maybe he just needs to be surrounded by a different type of cast. Like whos to say he couldnt be a more athletic Draymond green if surrounded by some stars instead of medicore Buddy Ball EVuc? Not trying to make excuses for him, he is what is, but to me its hard to just completely write him off considering hes played in the same offense scheme his whole career, surrounded by the same cast

In the end it matters who will want to stay with us. I dont think AG will want to resign after his contract is over. He seems more interested in himself and art than our team. I also think he is very hard to build around. Average shooter average passer, average dribbler, awful touch. I dont agree we have bad players around him, actually Vucevic and Fournier are quite good fits to hide his deficiences,.without them he would be even worse. I respect your opinion but in the nba you need to go with upside. All star center and dpoy forward have higher ceiling than below average pg and role player high flying forward. Yes we must gamble on Isaac health, but i wouldnt say its such a bad gamble. Cole and Okeke are interesting. We moved Dj to play Cole now we must move AG to play Isaac and Okeke.


Most of that was very true, but this is where i have to disagree with you
Id say this is the biggest gamble in the NBA if the plan is to build around HIM. I mean not even getting into his severely limited offensive game, but how do you build around a guy who cant stay on the court? I mean the next time he steps on the court, he will have missed more games than hes play, which, if he was a 2nd year guy, ok no big deal, even 3rd year you can make the argument, but the next time he plays he will be in his 5th season and only played 136 games, im sorry but theres no way you can count on that to both remain healthy and play at the same level (and in isaacs case, youd be predicting tremendous growth) as before he was injured. I mean you look at some of the greatest players ever who went on bad injury runs like this and they are never the same.
You see guys like Derrick Rose who went from 22 year old league MVP to almost out of the league (hes now rebounded nicely in detroit, but that many years)
You see guys like brandon roy whos knees were never the same after his acl injuries
Grant Hill
Penny

To have blind faith that isaac will stay heathy, not lose his athleticism (which is a huge factor on why hes a good defender) and improve enough to be a superstar on both sides of the ball is way to risky for me. If you can get someone else to buy into that notion enough to trade for him, you need to do it
zaymon
Head Coach
Posts: 6,128
And1: 3,437
Joined: Jul 01, 2015
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#409 » by zaymon » Tue Feb 2, 2021 4:20 pm

Isaac doesnt have degenerative knee condition like Roy, he also doesnt rely on athletecism like Rose. We are also far more advanced in medicine than when Hardaway and Hill played.
Isaac relies mostly on his length, motor, lightning fast reflexes and coordination. Aside from another freak injury i expect him to be perennial dpoy candidate. On offense he wont be the engine, but if he can be average 3 point shooter than thats more than enough.
Vucevic will be in his prime propably for the next 3-4 years so we have:
*/*/*/dpoy/allstar.
I am in the trade AG resign Fournier camp so we have:
*/shooter/*/dpoy/allstar.
I was quite pleased with Okeke. His shooting is for real and his rim protection was underrated. He also showed some passing potential. If he doesnt pan out we have solid defensive forward in Aminu. Next piece is Fultz, i am not so high on him. When the pressure went up his play went down. He looked almost relieved to be injured. I dont like that we extended him. Cole is a fighter i like him more than Fultz already.
The positive side of all the injuries is that we can have a top 5 pick without trading our veterans. Thats unique situation with very high potential. Our front office needs to be careful to balance between chemistry and losing. We still have young guys to develop and some veteran to resign. Best case scenario we will have a top 5 talent and strong team to develop him. Not one prospect fits with Gordon or Fultz but almost all fit with Vucevic and Fournier.
Your plan seems to be not taking into consideration our future and present prospects
My money is on Banchero going number 1 !
pepe1991
RealGM
Posts: 23,326
And1: 19,412
Joined: Jan 10, 2016
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#410 » by pepe1991 » Tue Feb 2, 2021 4:32 pm

yoyojw17 wrote:
pepe1991 wrote:
MagicStarwipe wrote:
The teams culture won't change until Vuc is gone. With him being here so long as the centrepiece, we've taken on his personality. No matter what other players we bring in, this is Vuc's team. Time for him to go to a team where he isn't the best player and time for us to begin a new era.


Where i don't care whether or not Vuc would be traded, i find this thought process very idiotic one.
NBA is talent driven league. In past 9 years ,since Vuc has been part of organisation, not a single nba player he played with was actually better basketball player than him.
And guess what, it's not like he was man in charge of free agency, trades and failed draft decisons. He always was safe net for terrible coaches, terrible GMs and terrible presidents of basketball operations. Him being good player on it's own, despite incopetence all around him made their jobs more secured than they should be.

Your opinion would have some validity if Vuc was some hot head bully like Whiteside or Cousins that is literally bulling his path toward usage, panderin offense to him and scares coaches into defering to him. Vuc is most lay low, supportive player Magic got. Every single young player raved how much Vuc helped him, on other side, Vuc was first to defend Isaac not kneeling for national anthem and was supportive about Fultz taking over 4th quaters. For crying out loud guy celebrated Cole's buzzerbeater more than Cole lol

So in general this is very missleading comment. Magic didn't took his personality, Magic are just as good as their best player is. And that's good enough to make playoffs if they are healthy, and not good enough to win playoff series. That's what Vuc is, supporting,complimentary star. But it's not his fault "complimentary star" is closest thing to good player team got since Dwight left. It's literally fault of everybody around him, but him, including players, especially lottery picks, who flat out did not work hard enough to get there ( Gordon, Payton, Hezonja, Oladipo pre trade, Isaac, Bamba... you name it ).


Lol... it's crazy how much flack Vuc gets for just going out there and doing his best. And so much is taken out of context and dissected. :-/ "We haven't won since vuc has been here"... lol... I'm sure no one was saying that about AD when he couldn't drag the pelicans into contention on his lonesome. haha


Kevin Garnett is best example. He was most energetic, no BS, constantlly locked in, hustle and heart guy out there and you can bet that nobody from his team ever picked up bad habbits from him when it comes to work ethic and pure desire to compete, yet in 11 years he gave to Wolves, they passed first round of playoffs...once. Including missing playoffs 3 times in a row before finally gettnig traded to Boston.
Guy holds almost every single T wolves personal record, he was always DPOY candidate and one of best nba players. Yet, if your incompentent front office, coaching and ownership can't find ANYTHING around you, you are bound to be trapped in horrible situation for years. Those guys are victims of their loyality. Beal is lasted one.
Life is what happens when you're busy making other plans. -John Lennon
basketballRob
RealGM
Posts: 37,394
And1: 14,964
Joined: May 05, 2014
     

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#411 » by basketballRob » Tue Feb 2, 2021 5:03 pm

Ducklett wrote:"The two best centers when it comes to defending without fouling are Al Horford and Vucevic, and that has been the case each of the last few years. This season so far, Vucevic is averaging just 1.7 fouls per game, which for someone who plays as many minutes as he does in a starting role is not only rare, it’s potentially historic. "

Interesting stat.
Vuc purposely doesn't try hard on defense, because he's afraid of picking up fouls and he won't be able to put up offensive stats if he's taken out of the game. I'm surprised you didn't know that about him.

Sent from my SM-G950U using RealGM mobile app
User avatar
MartinsIzAfraud
Head Coach
Posts: 6,445
And1: 4,829
Joined: Mar 07, 2017
Location: Work
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#412 » by MartinsIzAfraud » Tue Feb 2, 2021 5:48 pm

basketballRob wrote:
Ducklett wrote:"The two best centers when it comes to defending without fouling are Al Horford and Vucevic, and that has been the case each of the last few years. This season so far, Vucevic is averaging just 1.7 fouls per game, which for someone who plays as many minutes as he does in a starting role is not only rare, it’s potentially historic. "

Interesting stat.
Vuc purposely doesn't try hard on defense, because he's afraid of picking up fouls and he won't be able to put up offensive stats if he's taken out of the game. I'm surprised you didn't know that about him.

Sent from my SM-G950U using RealGM mobile app

he's the least physical center in the league. We could possibly pull up how many offensive fouls he wins and it'd likely be bottom 3 for C
A scoring guard.. never heard of one. :roll:
pepe1991
RealGM
Posts: 23,326
And1: 19,412
Joined: Jan 10, 2016
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#413 » by pepe1991 » Tue Feb 2, 2021 6:22 pm

MartinsIzAfraud wrote:
basketballRob wrote:
Ducklett wrote:"The two best centers when it comes to defending without fouling are Al Horford and Vucevic, and that has been the case each of the last few years. This season so far, Vucevic is averaging just 1.7 fouls per game, which for someone who plays as many minutes as he does in a starting role is not only rare, it’s potentially historic. "

Interesting stat.
Vuc purposely doesn't try hard on defense, because he's afraid of picking up fouls and he won't be able to put up offensive stats if he's taken out of the game. I'm surprised you didn't know that about him.

Sent from my SM-G950U using RealGM mobile app

he's the least physical center in the league. We could possibly pull up how many offensive fouls he wins and it'd likely be bottom 3 for C


Well, that's also BS. NBA brushers are thing of past.
Center position is still phyisical by default. Every time center is screening, he is taking contact of 180-220 pounds guard or wing.
Every time center is boxing out, he is pushing another +230 pound body away.

Why nobody bangs low any more ? Well it's very simplistic and obvious answer. It hurts like MFer. There is nothing to enjoy from taking contact of running 200 pounds of muscles hitting you right in mid section and torso just to have your guard run around you and take shot.
It's even less "sexy" stand under a rim, waiting until some 250 pound monster in dunk attemp serves you knee in nuts or belly.

As far as fouling thing goes, it's part of gameplan. Magic don't turn the ball over and don't foul. Last 3 years Orlando has been second lowest fouling nba team in nba. But if you look at elite defensive center such is Adebayo, he only fouls 2,5 times a game. Former DPOY runnerup, from last year, Anthony Davis, is averaging 0,1 foul a game more than Vuc... Data thrown out there is most "no context - no meaning"data you can find. It's like figuring out who has biggest pinky finger in class. It means something... i guess, but has no meaning to anything.
Life is what happens when you're busy making other plans. -John Lennon
The Effect
Magic Forum Mock Draft Co-Champ
Posts: 4,891
And1: 2,119
Joined: Jul 09, 2004

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#414 » by The Effect » Tue Feb 2, 2021 6:59 pm

zaymon wrote:Isaac doesnt have degenerative knee condition like Roy, he also doesnt rely on athletecism like Rose. We are also far more advanced in medicine than when Hardaway and Hill played.
Isaac relies mostly on his length, motor, lightning fast reflexes and coordination. Aside from another freak injury i expect him to be perennial dpoy candidate. On offense he wont be the engine, but if he can be average 3 point shooter than thats more than enough.
Vucevic will be in his prime propably for the next 3-4 years so we have:
*/*/*/dpoy/allstar.
I am in the trade AG resign Fournier camp so we have:
*/shooter/*/dpoy/allstar.
I was quite pleased with Okeke. His shooting is for real and his rim protection was underrated. He also showed some passing potential. If he doesnt pan out we have solid defensive forward in Aminu. Next piece is Fultz, i am not so high on him. When the pressure went up his play went down. He looked almost relieved to be injured. I dont like that we extended him. Cole is a fighter i like him more than Fultz already.
The positive side of all the injuries is that we can have a top 5 pick without trading our veterans. Thats unique situation with very high potential. Our front office needs to be careful to balance between chemistry and losing. We still have young guys to develop and some veteran to resign. Best case scenario we will have a top 5 talent and strong team to develop him. Not one prospect fits with Gordon or Fultz but almost all fit with Vucevic and Fournier.
Your plan seems to be not taking into consideration our future and present prospects

I will never understand how people on this board underrate how important athleticism is to Isaacs defensive game. He isnt half the defender he is if he had say the athleticism of Chuma. His ability to run down plays, slide, recover is what makes him a great defender. Wingspand is great, but you need that athletic ability to go with it or youre gonna be average. And speaking of chuma, look at his recovery from an ACL, looks how much that has effected his quickness, and that was his first injury. Isaac has the same injury (worse actually) on top of numerous other injuries to his legs\feet. To assume hes not going to suffer athletically would be very naive. Even if its just for one season, now we are looking at his 6th season before hes back to being to what he was last year (which to me is not a superstar level)
I know people here love him, but thats alot of faith to put in a guy who hasnt shown to be a superstar on both sides of the court

As for Gordon and fultz, sorry but what "type of players fit" with them? we really have no idea because we've never seen them with any other types of players besides buddy ball and the ball hog. Whos to say that Gordon and Fultz as the 2nd and 3rd option to a superstar wouldnt work. Like hypothetically, say we somehow traded gordon and fultz for porzingis, you dont think those 2 would flurish playing with Luka? or Beal? or a guy who can be a focal point of an offense? Because i personally think thats the PERFECT role for gordon. Like if we traded gordon to the warriors (his hometown team) and he replaced Draymond, the narrative on AG would be vastly different. He has the skillset to be a very good player (sure not a superstar), just not in this system with this cast

and honestly, keeping fournier? talk about a mistake, what has he ever done except maybe try to play hero-ball to boost his numbers while ignoring team ball, unless its buddy ball?
pepe1991
RealGM
Posts: 23,326
And1: 19,412
Joined: Jan 10, 2016
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#415 » by pepe1991 » Tue Feb 2, 2021 8:02 pm

Magic don't have player to build around. Isn't that most obvious, not debatable points anybody can make?

Isaac- 136 games in 4 years.
Fultz even less, 113 in 4 years.
Gordon- poor's man, Ben Simmons without BBIQ or elite level of defense
Vuc- 30, complimentary star, not player to be centerpeace of rebuild

Okeke- college role player
Cole- poor man's Dj Augustin.
Bamba -rofl
Life is what happens when you're busy making other plans. -John Lennon
MagicFan101
RealGM
Posts: 11,262
And1: 6,575
Joined: Jul 04, 2012
 

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#416 » by MagicFan101 » Tue Feb 2, 2021 8:15 pm

pepe1991 wrote:Magic don't have player to build around. Isn't that most obvious, not debatable points anybody can make?

Isaac- 136 games in 4 years.
Fultz even less, 113 in 4 years.
Gordon- poor's man, Ben Simmons without BBIQ or elite level of defense
Vuc- 30, complimentary star, not player to be centerpeace of rebuild

Okeke- college role player
Cole- poor man's Dj Augustin.
Bamba -rofl


... yet we still have quite a few “fans” on here holding strong against tanking in what is widely considered the strongest draft in years.
Bensational
Retired Mod
Retired Mod
Posts: 31,462
And1: 13,812
Joined: Apr 10, 2001
     

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#417 » by Bensational » Tue Feb 2, 2021 9:10 pm

I don’t care if Vuc stays or goes but I’d love it if he took the rest of the season off so Bamba can get some burn and exposure and hopefully become a moveable asset as well.

Looking at OKC, NOP and PHX, having a veteran PG and C is a big help to transitioning a young team into a playoff team. Vuc can play that role for us just fine, though his defense in the new defensive scheme has been terrible.
MasterGMer
Analyst
Posts: 3,639
And1: 756
Joined: Dec 09, 2011
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#418 » by MasterGMer » Tue Feb 2, 2021 9:26 pm

We are not trading Vuc now. If we do, Magic is tanking. But we are not.

Everybody wanted to trade AG before the season started. But he came in as one of the best defender in the league. I agree, AG is very inconsistent. And now the injury. SMH.

The best trade piece is Evan. We can not afford to have him long term because of the luxury tax.

The worst part is we have no cap space for next offseason. This team is not a winning team and have a ceiling. And we can not improve it. So, the Front Office? Make a trade!
zaymon
Head Coach
Posts: 6,128
And1: 3,437
Joined: Jul 01, 2015
   

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#419 » by zaymon » Tue Feb 2, 2021 9:43 pm

The Effect wrote:
zaymon wrote:Isaac doesnt have degenerative knee condition like Roy, he also doesnt rely on athletecism like Rose. We are also far more advanced in medicine than when Hardaway and Hill played.
Isaac relies mostly on his length, motor, lightning fast reflexes and coordination. Aside from another freak injury i expect him to be perennial dpoy candidate. On offense he wont be the engine, but if he can be average 3 point shooter than thats more than enough.
Vucevic will be in his prime propably for the next 3-4 years so we have:
*/*/*/dpoy/allstar.
I am in the trade AG resign Fournier camp so we have:
*/shooter/*/dpoy/allstar.
I was quite pleased with Okeke. His shooting is for real and his rim protection was underrated. He also showed some passing potential. If he doesnt pan out we have solid defensive forward in Aminu. Next piece is Fultz, i am not so high on him. When the pressure went up his play went down. He looked almost relieved to be injured. I dont like that we extended him. Cole is a fighter i like him more than Fultz already.
The positive side of all the injuries is that we can have a top 5 pick without trading our veterans. Thats unique situation with very high potential. Our front office needs to be careful to balance between chemistry and losing. We still have young guys to develop and some veteran to resign. Best case scenario we will have a top 5 talent and strong team to develop him. Not one prospect fits with Gordon or Fultz but almost all fit with Vucevic and Fournier.
Your plan seems to be not taking into consideration our future and present prospects

I will never understand how people on this board underrate how important athleticism is to Isaacs defensive game. He isnt half the defender he is if he had say the athleticism of Chuma. His ability to run down plays, slide, recover is what makes him a great defender. Wingspand is great, but you need that athletic ability to go with it or youre gonna be average. And speaking of chuma, look at his recovery from an ACL, looks how much that has effected his quickness, and that was his first injury. Isaac has the same injury (worse actually) on top of numerous other injuries to his legs\feet. To assume hes not going to suffer athletically would be very naive. Even if its just for one season, now we are looking at his 6th season before hes back to being to what he was last year (which to me is not a superstar level)
I know people here love him, but thats alot of faith to put in a guy who hasnt shown to be a superstar on both sides of the court

As for Gordon and fultz, sorry but what "type of players fit" with them? we really have no idea because we've never seen them with any other types of players besides buddy ball and the ball hog. Whos to say that Gordon and Fultz as the 2nd and 3rd option to a superstar wouldnt work. Like hypothetically, say we somehow traded gordon and fultz for porzingis, you dont think those 2 would flurish playing with Luka? or Beal? or a guy who can be a focal point of an offense? Because i personally think thats the PERFECT role for gordon. Like if we traded gordon to the warriors (his hometown team) and he replaced Draymond, the narrative on AG would be vastly different. He has the skillset to be a very good player (sure not a superstar), just not in this system with this cast

and honestly, keeping fournier? talk about a mistake, what has he ever done except maybe try to play hero-ball to boost his numbers while ignoring team ball, unless its buddy ball?


Let me be honest, i am terrified about Isaac health. I will **** my pants every game next season. His offense is average at best, you cant build team around it BUT his defense? I consider him generational defensive talent. The kind of talent Duncan had when he could transform his team defense even being old and unathletic. I think that potential is worth the risk 10 out of 10 times. If he cant stay healthy we still can terminate his contract early. Look at his defensive advanced stats, they are goat tier at his age. His eye test is even better. I wont willingly reject the upside. He can also shoot at his height which is also insane.

I dont think Gordon and Fultz are good enough to fit players around them. They should be low usage players, but they dont have low usage player skill set. Gordon right now is more useful. He is great 1 on 1 defender, good passer and improving shooter, but he doesnt have one elite skill and every ability has caveat. He is not team defender and overall high iq player like Draymond. All in all i wouldnt be against keeping Aaron IF we didnt have multiple replacements already. Lets be honest we didnt aquire Isaac, Aminu and Okeke by accident, Gordon was already here. Multiple positions defenders are valueable, we should use this asset until its too late.
Fultz we have secured already so we will have him for now, but i dont think we should build around him, until he shows he can shoot. We extended him for below average starter money so its not like we went all in on him.

Fournier ignored team ball at times becouse he is our best scorer and we dont have much talent around him. He is still passing much more than Ross while being better shooter, defender and pick and roll ball handler. He cant pass too much becouse there is no one to score unless you like watching isoAG.
My money is on Banchero going number 1 !
MagicFan4Lyfe
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,980
And1: 1,904
Joined: Feb 26, 2006
Location: Negative Land
       

Re: Official Speculation Thread '20-'21 VII: Where do we go from here? 

Post#420 » by MagicFan4Lyfe » Wed Feb 3, 2021 12:35 am

Orlando Magic fans: "Will the front office make any moves"

Magic Front Office: "Nah too much work for us to do. We'll keep on running a Rob Hennigan team and hope to draft the next Giannis.
Lightning can strike twice. Meanwhile, don't disturb us. We are going back to sleep."


Orlando Magic are BACK!!!

Return to Orlando Magic