Post#1396 » by Zonkerbl » Thu Feb 4, 2021 4:05 pm
I was at Reed College when PCness was just starting out in the 1990s and there were people who took it too far. Statistically speaking it's inevitable, once you introduce an idea into a statistically large group of people there will be those whose, erm, interpretation of the theory is three or more standard deviations away from the mean.
I find it extraordinarily disingenuous to take those outliers and paint the whole movement with it. It happens on both sides of course - I'm sure the Dem national committee is drooling in anticipation of painting every single GOP candidate up and down the ticket with Marjorie Taylor Greene's whackiness, and I guess you know all's fair.
But the difference with MTG is there's no genuine, worthy policy theory that she is the extreme end of, and GOP isn't interested in censoring her. Yet here we have CRT, a legit and respectable theory finally doing a proper job of pushing back against the white supremacist perspective that has dominated not just academia but the entire zeitgeist of the country from slavery to the present, that is the target of a full fledged, full throated, unapologetic censorship campaign from the extremist right wing of the white supremacist movement. It's frankly unacceptable to just uncritically swallow all the BS about it, imho.
A movement that is so focused on censoring an idea critical of white supremacy should not be embraced under any circumstances. It is anti-American. I don't care how uncomfortable the ideas behind CRT make you feel or how annoying the statistical outliers are in their interpretation of it. I hate Nazis passionately and fully endorse punching them when they get in your face and spout nazi bs. But I still defend their right to say the stuff that I will subsequently punch them for. I am even more radically pro-expression than I am anti-Nazi. How would I know whom to punch? Best to let the festering pus of Nazism float to the surface where it can be excised with a good punch or two, then let it fester deep inside and turn into the War on Drugs or something like that. But the very, very last thing you should be involved in is a campaign to censor an idea you don't like. What are you, a Commie?
I've been taught all my life to value service to the weak and powerless.