ImageImageImageImageImage

No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame?

Moderators: Morris_Shatford, DG88, niQ, 7 Footer, lebron stopper, Reeko, Duffman100, HiJiNX, tsherkin

Basketball_Jones
RealGM
Posts: 31,615
And1: 18,671
Joined: Mar 09, 2004
     

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#101 » by Basketball_Jones » Mon May 17, 2021 10:29 pm

Childs wrote:
Basketball_Jones wrote:I think judging by the remarks in this thread, it's even more surprising he made hall of fame. It's not just Raptor fans, but he didn't resonate highly in the US either.


I mean hes an 11 time All Star, how many 11 time All Stars are not in the HOF?


Yeah that’s pretty impressive
2019 Eastern Conference All Stars

Derozan
Lowry
Ibaka
Valanciunas
Van Vleet
Delon Wright
Lebron
Embiid

There are only 2 teams in the league that rank in the top 6 in offensive and defensive efficiency: the Golden State Warriors and the Toronto Raptors.
NeoDragonKnight
Starter
Posts: 2,405
And1: 2,648
Joined: Aug 12, 2008
     

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#102 » by NeoDragonKnight » Mon May 17, 2021 10:42 pm

Childs wrote:
Basketball_Jones wrote:I think judging by the remarks in this thread, it's even more surprising he made hall of fame. It's not just Raptor fans, but he didn't resonate highly in the US either.


I mean hes an 11 time All Star, how many 11 time All Stars are not in the HOF?


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_NBA_All-Stars

looks like almost every player that has had 7 or more all star appearances are in the hall, the exception is Larry Foust. Those with 6 or less you can start to see the borderline hofers like Kemp, JO, Tim Hardaway, ect.
User avatar
WaltFrazier
RealGM
Posts: 38,290
And1: 34,732
Joined: Jan 21, 2006
Location: Ontario Canada
       

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#103 » by WaltFrazier » Mon May 17, 2021 11:30 pm

Jcity08 wrote:I mean thats great and all but he probably wouldnt got HoF if he didnt become 3rd fiddle with the Heatles. What did he do in Toronto that was really all that HoF worthy. Or are we all supposed to take notice just because we drafted him?


This is the thing. When he was here it was clear he was a fine player but not a first option. He went from here to being not just a 3rd option, but 3rd option on the ultimate superteam, with 2 superstars ahead of him. We don't even know if he would have been all that good as a second star. Certainly not a champion. I don't know if I can think of another Hall of famer, within the context of his era, that made the HoF as a 3rd best player.

edit - well I guess Rodman wasn't a 1-2 star, and now Toni Kucoc. Bosh was better than Kucoc, so sure put him in.
There goes my hero. Watch him as he goes.
User avatar
Jcity08
RealGM
Posts: 13,260
And1: 18,612
Joined: May 06, 2018
       

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#104 » by Jcity08 » Mon May 17, 2021 11:44 pm

WaltFrazier wrote:
Jcity08 wrote:I mean thats great and all but he probably wouldnt got HoF if he didnt become 3rd fiddle with the Heatles. What did he do in Toronto that was really all that HoF worthy. Or are we all supposed to take notice just because we drafted him?


This is the thing. When he was here it was clear he was a fine player but not a first option. He went from here to being not just a 3rd option, but 3rd option on the ultimate superteam, with 2 superstars ahead of him. We don't even know if he would have been all that good as a second star. Certainly not a champion. I don't know if I can think of another Hall of famer, within the context of his era, that made the HoF as a 3rd best player.

edit - well I guess Rodman wasn't a 1-2 star, and now Toni Kucoc. Bosh was better than Kucoc, so sure put him in.


I'll be honest I have no issue he got in, the requirements arent exactly strict, and he was pretty good but not all time great, and thats good enough for the Hall.

If I have any issue, its that the person who made the thread, made it to get exactly this type of response. "No thread on Bosh making the Hall of Fame?", as if we arent responsive enough for him.

Well hopefully now he got his question answered...
Image
Image

Signed with team T.W.O for the 2022-23 2023-24 2024-25 season.
User avatar
PD28
General Manager
Posts: 9,020
And1: 14,112
Joined: Jan 04, 2013
 

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#105 » by PD28 » Mon May 17, 2021 11:51 pm

supra2k8 wrote:
2019nbachamps wrote:
WuTang_OG wrote:He dipped on us

Tf should we care


Meanwhile you have Kawhi as your avatar


check your user name



Image
User avatar
OakleyDokely
RealGM
Posts: 36,594
And1: 69,386
Joined: Aug 02, 2008
Location: 416
 

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#106 » by OakleyDokely » Tue May 18, 2021 12:07 am

4th best player in Raptors history.
2019nbachamps
Lead Assistant
Posts: 4,541
And1: 4,916
Joined: Jul 10, 2019
 

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#107 » by 2019nbachamps » Tue May 18, 2021 2:37 am

supra2k8 wrote:
2019nbachamps wrote:
WuTang_OG wrote:He dipped on us

Tf should we care


Meanwhile you have Kawhi as your avatar


check your user name


I wasn’t the one crying about Bosh leaving us
slicedbread2
Assistant Coach
Posts: 3,756
And1: 3,208
Joined: Jan 23, 2014

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#108 » by slicedbread2 » Tue May 18, 2021 6:08 am

There's apathy at best to describe the reaction to Bosh being in the hall of fame in regards to the Raptors fan base.

Look nobody blamed him for leaving as quite frankly this team by the time he had left was no better if not worse off than before. His handling of leaving Toronto and making excuses rather than just being blunt and saying that he didn't trust the organization to make the right moves going forward would've sufficed. He handled it in a pathetic way and he wasn't a centrepiece you'd be able to build around. You had the following blunders that made built up over time in driving Bosh outta town:

1) Drafting Araujo over Igoudala. It was a bad move the second it was made and universally panned. This dude was at best drafted 15-20 spots too high as he went through the juco route where he spent 2 years at Arizona western CC then played his final 2 years at BYU. Igoudala proceeded to have a great career and brought it every time he played the Raps.

2) Trading away Vince Carter. Yea he wanted out, but Babcock settling for a pure garbage offer was one of the worse he moves he ever made and the fallout resulted in him being canned. All he had to show for this deal was Joey Graham and using a 1st round pick to get out of Jalen Rose's deal after he was fired and this trade occurred after Kobe dropped 81 on Rose's ass. The best played he brought in for Bosh was Jose Calderon.

3) BC's infatuation with Bargnani. He looked the part, but when it came time to put him to the test he failed spectacularly. Yes the Raptors bulking him up and taking away from his main strength of blowing by slower big men didn't help but his laziness and lack of work ethic was pathetic. If he even had half the work ethic of Dirk, it'd be a different story. BC's refusal to acknowledge that pasta man sucked and more importantly trading him elsewhere to help Bosh or cut his losses on him was antagonizing and he was here as long as BC.

4) The dumb trading of players. Charlie Villanueva was drafted with the 8th pick. Bynum was available and taking Joey Graham over Danny Granger stung. Charlie was traded after 1 year to Milwaukee for T.J. Ford who was promising but his neck injuries were concerning and he'd suffer a career ending injury in SA. They had a pg controversy and went with Jose, but made the stupid move of trading Rasho, Ford and the draft rights to Roy Hibbert for a broken down Jermaine O'Neal.

BC realized he made an error and made things worse by trading O'Neal to the Heat with a 2011 1st for Shawn Marion. This deal allowed Miami to gear up for the LBJ sweepstakes and Marion didn't wanna be here. He then engages in a S&T that brought Hedo Turkoglu here and he was a bum who's lasting impression was pretending to be sick with food poisoning only to be found at a bar later on. BC sent him to Phoenix for Leandro Barbosa after Bosh had left.

The crazy thing was the Heat's S&T of Bosh to the Raptors allowed the Raps to get back their 2011 1st that became Jonas Valanciunas. Seriously it's unbelievable how many blunders BC made and I had people wondering why I was following this team that had become a factory of sadness of sorts prior to Tim Lewieke coming in and changing things up. To summarize Bosh's time in Toronto and his rep around the league prior to going to Miami:

;ab_channel=TheBasketballFail
User avatar
Mikistan
RealGM
Posts: 26,256
And1: 39,418
Joined: Jun 30, 2008
Location: Shamblesland
   

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#109 » by Mikistan » Tue May 18, 2021 6:37 am

Bosh was good, but the trade exception we got from sign and trading him was even better.
Image
User avatar
Caped Crusader
Veteran
Posts: 2,662
And1: 4,000
Joined: Jul 30, 2012
 

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#110 » by Caped Crusader » Tue May 18, 2021 7:13 am

2019nbachamps wrote:
supra2k8 wrote:
2019nbachamps wrote:
Meanwhile you have Kawhi as your avatar


check your user name


I wasn’t the one crying about Bosh leaving us
You're the one to bring up Kawhi though. Terrible comparison. Kawhi left after reaching and leading us to the highest pinnacle. Bosh on the other hand lead us nowhere. He was part of what was literally the darkest era in Raptors history and while management was largely at fault, so was Bosh.

He also lead management and the fans on. Does anyone remember the "should I stay or leave" poll? My goodness, talk about thirsty and desperate for attention. He was never upfront about his intentions and had his fair share of failures. He also gave up on the team in his final year here when he sat out key games just before the playoffs resulting in us missing the playoffs. After he parted ways he went on to make childish remarks about the city.

It didn't help that he joined the "not 1, not 2, not 3, not 4, not 5" Miami Heat who were universally hated. The key ingredients for the Bosh dislike are his lack of success coupled with his immaturity and diva behavior upon his departure. These are all pretty important factors as to why no one really cares about Bosh here and shouldn't be a surprise to you. He is just a footnote in our history and nothing more.

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using RealGM mobile app
maternal85
Starter
Posts: 2,127
And1: 1,802
Joined: Feb 14, 2016

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#111 » by maternal85 » Tue May 18, 2021 11:47 am

Harcore Fenton Mun wrote:We have a thread about Bosh and the Heat forum doesn't.

Congratulations.


The insecurity is comical. Why no thread people ask? Because we have REAL HISTORY NOW. We have a future HOF who'll be going in as a Raptor in Lowry. We have an Eastern conference and NBA title under our names now. Our superfan even made the HOF. People, we have real history now. No more celebrating division titles or former players who left us and didn't care. The only former players who should be celebrated, are the ones on the CHAMPIONSHIP team.
User avatar
LastNameEver
General Manager
Posts: 9,796
And1: 9,552
Joined: Mar 02, 2013

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#112 » by LastNameEver » Tue May 18, 2021 12:31 pm

Happy to see it even though the Toronto departure wasn’t handled well
B-Ball Freak
RealGM
Posts: 16,233
And1: 11,457
Joined: Jun 09, 2003
     

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#113 » by B-Ball Freak » Tue May 18, 2021 3:10 pm

slicedbread2 wrote:There's apathy at best to describe the reaction to Bosh being in the hall of fame in regards to the Raptors fan base.

Look nobody blamed him for leaving as quite frankly this team by the time he had left was no better if not worse off than before. His handling of leaving Toronto and making excuses rather than just being blunt and saying that he didn't trust the organization to make the right moves going forward would've sufficed. He handled it in a pathetic way and he wasn't a centrepiece you'd be able to build around. You had the following blunders that made built up over time in driving Bosh outta town:

1) Drafting Araujo over Igoudala. It was a bad move the second it was made and universally panned. This dude was at best drafted 15-20 spots too high as he went through the juco route where he spent 2 years at Arizona western CC then played his final 2 years at BYU. Igoudala proceeded to have a great career and brought it every time he played the Raps.

2) Trading away Vince Carter. Yea he wanted out, but Babcock settling for a pure garbage offer was one of the worse he moves he ever made and the fallout resulted in him being canned. All he had to show for this deal was Joey Graham and using a 1st round pick to get out of Jalen Rose's deal after he was fired and this trade occurred after Kobe dropped 81 on Rose's ass. The best played he brought in for Bosh was Jose Calderon.

3) BC's infatuation with Bargnani. He looked the part, but when it came time to put him to the test he failed spectacularly. Yes the Raptors bulking him up and taking away from his main strength of blowing by slower big men didn't help but his laziness and lack of work ethic was pathetic. If he even had half the work ethic of Dirk, it'd be a different story. BC's refusal to acknowledge that pasta man sucked and more importantly trading him elsewhere to help Bosh or cut his losses on him was antagonizing and he was here as long as BC.

4) The dumb trading of players. Charlie Villanueva was drafted with the 8th pick. Bynum was available and taking Joey Graham over Danny Granger stung. Charlie was traded after 1 year to Milwaukee for T.J. Ford who was promising but his neck injuries were concerning and he'd suffer a career ending injury in SA. They had a pg controversy and went with Jose, but made the stupid move of trading Rasho, Ford and the draft rights to Roy Hibbert for a broken down Jermaine O'Neal.

BC realized he made an error and made things worse by trading O'Neal to the Heat with a 2011 1st for Shawn Marion. This deal allowed Miami to gear up for the LBJ sweepstakes and Marion didn't wanna be here. He then engages in a S&T that brought Hedo Turkoglu here and he was a bum who's lasting impression was pretending to be sick with food poisoning only to be found at a bar later on. BC sent him to Phoenix for Leandro Barbosa after Bosh had left.

The crazy thing was the Heat's S&T of Bosh to the Raptors allowed the Raps to get back their 2011 1st that became Jonas Valanciunas. Seriously it's unbelievable how many blunders BC made and I had people wondering why I was following this team that had become a factory of sadness of sorts prior to Tim Lewieke coming in and changing things up. To summarize Bosh's time in Toronto and his rep around the league prior to going to Miami:

;ab_channel=TheBasketballFail



My god the BC era was horrible, seeing some of those names is giving me PTSD. The idiots on here that hate Masai, wonder what they'll think if they experience the BC era.
Bank Shot
RealGM
Posts: 16,682
And1: 12,558
Joined: Jun 24, 2007

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#114 » by Bank Shot » Tue May 18, 2021 3:23 pm

Great to see. Well deserved. Bosh made the All-Star game in his third year and then never missed it after that. That is super impressive. He gave us more good years than any Raptor not named Kyle Lowry, so I'll always appreciate him.
Kingsway_fan
RealGM
Posts: 14,736
And1: 10,318
Joined: May 25, 2016
Location: Paris
 

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#115 » by Kingsway_fan » Tue May 18, 2021 9:23 pm

B-Ball Freak wrote:
slicedbread2 wrote:There's apathy at best to describe the reaction to Bosh being in the hall of fame in regards to the Raptors fan base.

Look nobody blamed him for leaving as quite frankly this team by the time he had left was no better if not worse off than before. His handling of leaving Toronto and making excuses rather than just being blunt and saying that he didn't trust the organization to make the right moves going forward would've sufficed. He handled it in a pathetic way and he wasn't a centrepiece you'd be able to build around. You had the following blunders that made built up over time in driving Bosh outta town:

1) Drafting Araujo over Igoudala. It was a bad move the second it was made and universally panned. This dude was at best drafted 15-20 spots too high as he went through the juco route where he spent 2 years at Arizona western CC then played his final 2 years at BYU. Igoudala proceeded to have a great career and brought it every time he played the Raps.

2) Trading away Vince Carter. Yea he wanted out, but Babcock settling for a pure garbage offer was one of the worse he moves he ever made and the fallout resulted in him being canned. All he had to show for this deal was Joey Graham and using a 1st round pick to get out of Jalen Rose's deal after he was fired and this trade occurred after Kobe dropped 81 on Rose's ass. The best played he brought in for Bosh was Jose Calderon.

3) BC's infatuation with Bargnani. He looked the part, but when it came time to put him to the test he failed spectacularly. Yes the Raptors bulking him up and taking away from his main strength of blowing by slower big men didn't help but his laziness and lack of work ethic was pathetic. If he even had half the work ethic of Dirk, it'd be a different story. BC's refusal to acknowledge that pasta man sucked and more importantly trading him elsewhere to help Bosh or cut his losses on him was antagonizing and he was here as long as BC.

4) The dumb trading of players. Charlie Villanueva was drafted with the 8th pick. Bynum was available and taking Joey Graham over Danny Granger stung. Charlie was traded after 1 year to Milwaukee for T.J. Ford who was promising but his neck injuries were concerning and he'd suffer a career ending injury in SA. They had a pg controversy and went with Jose, but made the stupid move of trading Rasho, Ford and the draft rights to Roy Hibbert for a broken down Jermaine O'Neal.

BC realized he made an error and made things worse by trading O'Neal to the Heat with a 2011 1st for Shawn Marion. This deal allowed Miami to gear up for the LBJ sweepstakes and Marion didn't wanna be here. He then engages in a S&T that brought Hedo Turkoglu here and he was a bum who's lasting impression was pretending to be sick with food poisoning only to be found at a bar later on. BC sent him to Phoenix for Leandro Barbosa after Bosh had left.

The crazy thing was the Heat's S&T of Bosh to the Raptors allowed the Raps to get back their 2011 1st that became Jonas Valanciunas. Seriously it's unbelievable how many blunders BC made and I had people wondering why I was following this team that had become a factory of sadness of sorts prior to Tim Lewieke coming in and changing things up. To summarize Bosh's time in Toronto and his rep around the league prior to going to Miami:

;ab_channel=TheBasketballFail



My god the BC era was horrible, seeing some of those names is giving me PTSD. The idiots on here that hate Masai, wonder what they'll think if they experience the BC era.


Yep , and Babcock was even worse.. the scrubs vc had to play with was pitiful waste of one of the greatest superstars of the era
agkagk
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,075
And1: 2,091
Joined: Sep 03, 2011

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#116 » by agkagk » Tue May 18, 2021 9:48 pm

Bleep him and his Twitter account.
Ramed Nazored
Assistant Coach
Posts: 4,345
And1: 9,450
Joined: Dec 13, 2016

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#117 » by Ramed Nazored » Tue May 18, 2021 9:59 pm

Bosh deserves it, no doubt. But his Raptor tenure seems so remote and unspectacular given what’s been accomplished in the post-Bosh era, that in my opinions, he’ll go down as little more than a footnote. As another poster mentioned, we have real history now.
B-Ball Freak
RealGM
Posts: 16,233
And1: 11,457
Joined: Jun 09, 2003
     

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#118 » by B-Ball Freak » Tue May 18, 2021 10:24 pm

Kingsway_fan wrote:Yep , and Babcock was even worse.. the scrubs vc had to play with was pitiful waste of one of the greatest superstars of the era


No doubt, I still think Babcock was sent to sabotage the team from how bad he was a GM :lol:
Drygon
Veteran
Posts: 2,968
And1: 5,216
Joined: Dec 18, 2018

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#119 » by Drygon » Mon May 31, 2021 11:57 pm

slicedbread2 wrote:There's apathy at best to describe the reaction to Bosh being in the hall of fame in regards to the Raptors fan base.

Look nobody blamed him for leaving as quite frankly this team by the time he had left was no better if not worse off than before. His handling of leaving Toronto and making excuses rather than just being blunt and saying that he didn't trust the organization to make the right moves going forward would've sufficed. He handled it in a pathetic way and he wasn't a centrepiece you'd be able to build around. You had the following blunders that made built up over time in driving Bosh outta town:

1) Drafting Araujo over Igoudala. It was a bad move the second it was made and universally panned. This dude was at best drafted 15-20 spots too high as he went through the juco route where he spent 2 years at Arizona western CC then played his final 2 years at BYU. Igoudala proceeded to have a great career and brought it every time he played the Raps.

2) Trading away Vince Carter. Yea he wanted out, but Babcock settling for a pure garbage offer was one of the worse he moves he ever made and the fallout resulted in him being canned. All he had to show for this deal was Joey Graham and using a 1st round pick to get out of Jalen Rose's deal after he was fired and this trade occurred after Kobe dropped 81 on Rose's ass. The best played he brought in for Bosh was Jose Calderon.

3) BC's infatuation with Bargnani. He looked the part, but when it came time to put him to the test he failed spectacularly. Yes the Raptors bulking him up and taking away from his main strength of blowing by slower big men didn't help but his laziness and lack of work ethic was pathetic. If he even had half the work ethic of Dirk, it'd be a different story. BC's refusal to acknowledge that pasta man sucked and more importantly trading him elsewhere to help Bosh or cut his losses on him was antagonizing and he was here as long as BC.

4) The dumb trading of players. Charlie Villanueva was drafted with the 8th pick. Bynum was available and taking Joey Graham over Danny Granger stung. Charlie was traded after 1 year to Milwaukee for T.J. Ford who was promising but his neck injuries were concerning and he'd suffer a career ending injury in SA. They had a pg controversy and went with Jose, but made the stupid move of trading Rasho, Ford and the draft rights to Roy Hibbert for a broken down Jermaine O'Neal.

BC realized he made an error and made things worse by trading O'Neal to the Heat with a 2011 1st for Shawn Marion. This deal allowed Miami to gear up for the LBJ sweepstakes and Marion didn't wanna be here. He then engages in a S&T that brought Hedo Turkoglu here and he was a bum who's lasting impression was pretending to be sick with food poisoning only to be found at a bar later on. BC sent him to Phoenix for Leandro Barbosa after Bosh had left.

The crazy thing was the Heat's S&T of Bosh to the Raptors allowed the Raps to get back their 2011 1st that became Jonas Valanciunas. Seriously it's unbelievable how many blunders BC made and I had people wondering why I was following this team that had become a factory of sadness of sorts prior to Tim Lewieke coming in and changing things up. To summarize Bosh's time in Toronto and his rep around the league prior to going to Miami:

;ab_channel=TheBasketballFail


Vince wanted to stay & rescined his trade request (like Kobe did with Lakers).

However, Rob Babcack accepted Nets' crap package & traded him anyway.

It's confirmed by Rob Babcock & Sam Mitchell themselves years later.

http://pmd.fan590.com/audio_on_demand-2/Sam-Mitchell-with-tim-and-Sid-ts-20121107-Interview.mp3
http://pmd.fan590.com/audio_on_demand-2/Rob-Babcock-with-Tim-and-Sid-ts-20121107-Interview.mp3
User avatar
mintsa
Head Coach
Posts: 6,696
And1: 3,749
Joined: Jun 28, 2001

Re: No thread on Bosh making the hall of fame? 

Post#120 » by mintsa » Tue Jun 1, 2021 1:22 am

Would Bosh make the hall of fame if he stayed here, kept those raptors numbers/stats and all star games but still only had 1st round playoff exits ?

Return to Toronto Raptors