Stratmaster wrote:Ok. Those guys make just about every top 15 small forwards of all time list. Pippen usually is listed as 5th or 6th with LBJ, Bird, Durant and Dr. J ahead of him and pretty much consensus top 4. I looked at 5 different lists including ESPN and I am pretty confident that will be consistent in any respected list you look at.
Old timers Elgin Baylor and Havlicek are occasionally rated above Pip and occasionally below him.
I am not debating. Just trying to understand your cutoff. It appears you are cutting off the superstar label right at Pippen. And that is fair.
Pippen is in the next tier below the superstar group to me. As I said, for me, a requirement to be a superstar by my definition is to be a #1 scorer that can carry a championship team, and Pippen fails that test, it doesn't matter to me what else he does, he can't be a superstar while failing that test.
In Pippen's defense, that is literally maybe the worst thing you can say about him, he's more or less outstanding at everything else and wasn't a bad scorer or anything.
Here's a link discussing Bill Simmons from his basketball pyramid book updated in 2020:
https://www.theringer.com/nba/2020/4/19/21225904/scottie-pippen-bill-simmons-book-of-basketball-hall-of-fame-pyramid
He has him ranked 28th as of last year (I doubt anyone passed him in the past season either).
Here's the original (2009 list)
https://www.basketball-reference.com/awards/simmons_pyramid.html
When looking at that list, I agree Pippen is just below the line of guys I'd generally consider superstar which was ~20. The four guys who passed him I'd all put on my superstar list though which means about 24 guys.
Personally I call the 5th or 6th best small forward of all time a superstar...and probably a half dozen more after him. It's just a difference in where we draw the line.
I agree that the term superstar is just made up, I mean I agree Pippen is a first ballot HOF worthy player. When looking at criteria, to me superstar requires a guy that can be your #1 scorer on a title team, and I just don't see Pippen as that possibility. In the same vein, I would probably not view Bill Russell as a superstar for the same reason, but I never watched him play, and the era was so laughably different that the comparison is sort of difficult for me to make.