Klay Thompson vs Prime Joe Dumars

[SHAQ32]

I think there are several parallels between them as players, including perceived two-way excellence and not measuring out great in specific metrics. Who was better defensively, and who scored better overall relative to the league/era they played?

[KobesScarf]

Dumars much better defensively and a much better ball handler/playmaker. Klay is a much better scorer.

[penbeast0]

Not sure Dumars is that much better defensively. Against PGs, he was quicker and had a stronger lower base; against wings, Klay is longer and has a much bigger wingspan. Dumars you could shoot over.

[Cavsfansince84]

Dumars much better defensively and a much better ball handler/playmaker. Klay is a much better scorer.

Klay is a better shooter but I feel like as overall scorers there isn't that much difference. I mean the proof is in the pudding I think. Klay while playing next to the perfect player(s) to compliment his skill set maxed out at 22.3ppg and 111 ts+. Joe otoh maxed out at 23.5 on 104 ts+. To me Joe's overall skills as a combo guard push him past Klay as an all around player. Defense is also in Joe's advantage imo.

[henshao]

Dumars much better defensively and a much better ball handler/playmaker. Klay is a much better scorer.

Klay is a better shooter but I feel like as overall scorers there isn't that much difference. I mean the proof is in the pudding I think. Klay while playing next to the perfect player(s) to compliment his skill set maxed out at 22.3ppg and 111 ts+. Joe otoh maxed out at 23.5 on 104 ts+. To me Joe's overall skills as a combo guard push him past Klay as an all around player. Defense is also in Joe's advantage imo.

"The proof of the pudding is in the eating"

what I like about Dumars is similar. He can genuinely run point or two-guard, has shooting range out to 3, and defends as well as anyone you can hope to find at his height. Although Klay sometimes gets absolutely nuclear hot I don't think it's enough to overtake Joe, who also has greater locker room positives based on what others say of him

[Cavsfansince84]

"The proof of the pudding is in the eating"

what I like about Dumars is similar. He can genuinely run point or two-guard, has shooting range out to 3, and defends as well as anyone you can hope to find at his height. Although Klay sometimes gets absolutely nuclear hot I don't think it's enough to overtake Joe, who also has greater locker room positives based on what others say of him

I think that's the original wording. In modern times it's been abbreviated to what I wrote above.

[prolific passer]

Picked Dumars. Just think he had a more complete game.