zaymon wrote:QingJames wrote:zaymon wrote:
Some of us wouldnt trade Wagner for Barnes straight up let alone Suggs and Wagner.
lol come on now, that'd be foolish. Wagner looks good but Barnes certainly projects to be much better than both of those guys at this point, it's crazy the level of skill he's already attained while also having far superior physical characteristics to basically every other rookie except Mobley and perhaps Kuminga. Yet, even I'm not so big of a homer that I wouldn't trade Barnes for Mobley if offered. Barnes projects amazing but Mobley will likely win several DPOYs, so I would do that deal if Cleveland offered (they wouldn't).
Barnes is great, pleasure to watch
but he relies on his tools a lot. Barnes looks almost fully developed physically while Wagner has a lot room to grow.
Barnes is 6'7 pf/c while Wagner is 6'10 sg/sf, you could argue whose ceiling is really higher, but
Wagner is more skilled for sure.
People compare Barnes to Giannis, but he is not great driving to the rim. Wagner has a lot more volume and better efficiency.
This is pretty much every player ever, if Wagner wasn't 6"10 he wouldn't have nearly the rookie impact he's having.
Also every rookie will get stronger as they get closer to their prime. Look at rookie Lebron who had an NBA body coming in compared to Miami/Cavs (big 3) and LA Lebron.
Point being none of the rookies are fully developed physically if they are 19-20 years old.
Secondly skills develop over time, Barnes is a FAR better offensive player right now than he was in college.
In conclusion saying a rookie won't get better because you think they are fully physically developed at 20 or there skills won't expand after 20 is absolutely foolish to assume, for both Barnes and Franz, especially since they are 20 year olds. Arguing otherwise is just putting your own bias as a fan ahead of wisdom.