Diop wrote:JMAC3 wrote:
At end of the day, I think Giddey is a great pick and roll engine, but if you watch he has no ability to isolate and actually go by someone, it is all pick and roll generated. He can be a good player, but I would take at least 5 rookies over him probably.
how about 3 triple doubles in a row? his shooting is improving and he keeps delivering
I personally think Triple Doubles are the most overrated stat. Even when LaMelo gets one I think its crazily overblown, but it brings shine to Hornets so I don't make a big deal. I would rather celebrate a guy getting to the freethrow line 10 times or getting 6 steals than grabbing defensive rebounds, especially on a team like Thunder who lack an interior presence like Drummond, Adams or Allen who is going to grab all the rebounds anyways.
For Giddey, he is 6-8 playing majority of his minutes with Tre Mann, Aaron Wiggins, Darius Bazely and Isaiah Roby. They put the ball in his hands every single play, so he is pretty much going to get 10 assists if all you do is run high pick and roll the entire game. Thunder shutdown SGA, to let Giddey shine. Wouldn't shock me to see them trade Giddey after doing everything they can to build up his trade value.
Maybe I will eat crow, but....
Giddey still can't really shoot, teams are leaving him wide open daring him to shoot threes and he is shooting 26%. That means they go under screens, don't close out hard, he doesn't have gravity when he is off the ball, so he has to have the ball to be valuable. Once he gets better shooting maybe teams will start playing defense, but I don't think his 3% will be linear.
He is a bad athlete, who has 4 Dunks all season, at 6-8. He averages 0.9 steals at 6-8 so he isn't quick twitch to where he is getting out on fast breaks and creating easy opportunities for his team. He has the ball constantly and shoots 1.5 FTA per game. He has to have a screen at top of the key to beat his man off dribble, he doesn't have speed or quickness or ball handling skills to isolate and get to the bucket.
His number 1 asset is his BBIQ, which I think will make him a starter in the league for a long time, but as a 4th best player maybe 3rd depending on how successful the team is.
This is my current rookie class rankings for the future.
1. Barnes
2. Mobley
3. Cade
4. Franz
5. Kuminga
6. Green
7. Giddey
I don't know who it will be but I expect 4 or so more guys to really pop over the next two years and be better players than Giddey as well. He just lacks too much for me to end up being a top 5 guy from this class.