thebigbird wrote:bbalnation wrote:thebigbird wrote:And this is supposed to prove that Kobe was the better player that year? Against the Magic LeBron averaged 39/8/8 on 59% TS. Kobe averaged 32/7/6 on 52% TS. Kobe had a far better supporting cast and, most importantly, big men who could contain Dwight Howard. That doesn't make him the better player that year.
For fun, here's the playoff comparison in 2009:
PPG - 35.3 / 30.2
RPG - 9.1 / 5.3
APG - 7.3 / 5.5
STL - 1.6 / 1.7
BLK - 0.9 / 0.9
PER - 37.4 / 26.8
WS/48 - .399 / .238
BPM - 17.5 / 9.1
VOP - 2.9 / 2.6 (with LeBron playing 9 fewer games).
There's no pro-Kobe argument here. There's zero pro-Kobe argument regarding him being the best player in the NBA for half a decade. And there's a strong pro-Wade argument for peak shooting guard during Kobe's era. Kobe simply was not the player that so many of his fans want to argue that he was.
Thanks for sharing.
We're talking about a period time, right?
You brought forward playoff stat comparisons, and surrounding players.
Do you mind sharing Lebrons 2010 Playoffs stats when he played for the Heat?Then, do you mind sharing Kobes 2010 Playoff stats?
I dislike using box scores to compare players.
I dislike choosing stats to put players above others. Its not necessary for me.
Both players are great.
Do you mean 2011? LeBron didn't play for the Heat in the 2010 playoffs.
In 2011:
PPG - 23.7 / 22.8
RPG - 8.4 / 3.4
APG - 5.9 / 3.3
STL - 1.7 / 1.6
BLK - 1.2 / 0.3
PER - 23.7 / 20.6
WS/48 - .198 / .099
BPM - 7.1 / 3.4
VOP - 2.1 / 0.5
Even if you think they're both great, one guy is a consensus top 3 player while the other is 10th-15th.
Thank you for correcting me: I got the years wrong.
We're talking about peaks. Imo, the end of Kobes peak crossed during the beginning of Lebrons.
Dwyane's peak was shorter, but the end of Kobes peak also crossed with his.
I dont know why you brought all-time fan-opinion rankings into it.
I disagree with you: Lebron from 2008-2011 was in the conversation with Kobe as the best players in the league. It's unfortunate we never got to see them match up in the playoffs, with a relatively even surrounding cast of players.
From 1999 to 2011:
Kobe, Shaq, Carmelo, Tim, Dwyane, Dwight, Allen (Iverson), Dirk, Lebron & Kevin (Garnett) were also in the conversation imo.