eyriq wrote:arkknight1988 wrote:eyriq wrote:The sad thing is that Vince Carter is better than Hedo or JRich. We traded him and Gortat just to downgrade his position. Hindsight is 20/20, and JRich was balling in Phoenix, but my oh my doesn't that trade just look horrid now.
it was a panic move, otis clearly didn't think it through. he killed two birds with 1 stone on the move, our assets and cap flexibility.
Right. As fans I remember we were excited by the moves. I remember arguing that Hedo as a starter would contribute more than Gortat as a bench player would, and I had bought into the JRich hype too. Then again, we are fans, we are supposed to think irrationally about our team and every move we make! LOL We are like children that don't know better, that blindly trust and smile in innocence. While the FO are the parents and supposed to protect and see things rationally. Otis has been one hell of a negligent parent!
i think you got it right the first time around.
that trade made orlando better. the question is, could there be a trade that would make us much much better. obviously yes, but no one was helping Magic out at the time. peaches and gortat were at their worst, they were believed to have very little trade value. VC was just semi-expiring, no rebuilding team had a player that magic could use.
there had always been second thoughts about dismantling the 2009 team. basically a two birds one stone move. getting back a key player from 2009 team that ownership and dwight expressed that they wanted AND dwight/Hedo was a low risk move in comparison to for example sending out jameer for baron davis. not a better talent were available to magic with the assets we have.
PHX trade made sense then, it makes sense now. the only better option could be to ride out the **** storm, sacrifice the season, further frustrate the fans, amnesty Lewis and try to put together a team through free agency. this is called judging after the fact though.
obviously, there were some problems with that. This seasons FA class was weak, there was no single difference maker available. and what if there were no season and dwight were to walk? otis had to do something' that is a risk no one could take. too much uncertainty. and fans were restless, they anted something to happen. would you be patient? no **** way.
so yeah, that trade made sense. a lot of sense.