#1 to NY w/GS and Pho
Moderators: HartfordWhalers, Texas Chuck, BullyKing, Andre Roberstan, loserX, Trader_Joe, Mamba4Goat, pacers33granger, MoneyTalks41890
#1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
Dom801e
- Veteran
- Posts: 2,788
- And1: 863
- Joined: Jul 05, 2016
#1 to NY w/GS and Pho
NY trades #8 and Robinson for #1 and Looney.
Robinson plus #8 has been rumored for both #1 and #2. Min seems to want a bit more; NY does not seem to want to deal Robinson unless they are sure their guy is there. So #2 is a no go unless it is draft night. This deal rectifies that. They also get a vet replacement C on an expiring inexpensive deal.
Min trades #1 and James Johnson for #2.
The Wolves move a contract for future flexibility and retain a top 2 pick. They likely would be looking to package it in the future.
GS trades #2 and Looney for Oubre and #8.
There have been talks of Oubre +#10 for #2. This iteration improves upon this a bit. Taking on Oubre is expensive given tax implications so moving Looney relieves a bit of that as his health may lead them to move on from him anyway.
Pho trades Oubre for Johnson and Robinson
Oubre seems to be the odd man out long term for the Suns. Here they replace him in the rotation with a tough, defensively versatile wing in Johnson. He fits what they do and is also a FA, but he would be much more easier to keep for a couple more years. They also add Robinson, who would give them a different look than Ayton. He would fit nicely in the rotation and could spot start on nights when Ayton is out.
Robinson plus #8 has been rumored for both #1 and #2. Min seems to want a bit more; NY does not seem to want to deal Robinson unless they are sure their guy is there. So #2 is a no go unless it is draft night. This deal rectifies that. They also get a vet replacement C on an expiring inexpensive deal.
Min trades #1 and James Johnson for #2.
The Wolves move a contract for future flexibility and retain a top 2 pick. They likely would be looking to package it in the future.
GS trades #2 and Looney for Oubre and #8.
There have been talks of Oubre +#10 for #2. This iteration improves upon this a bit. Taking on Oubre is expensive given tax implications so moving Looney relieves a bit of that as his health may lead them to move on from him anyway.
Pho trades Oubre for Johnson and Robinson
Oubre seems to be the odd man out long term for the Suns. Here they replace him in the rotation with a tough, defensively versatile wing in Johnson. He fits what they do and is also a FA, but he would be much more easier to keep for a couple more years. They also add Robinson, who would give them a different look than Ayton. He would fit nicely in the rotation and could spot start on nights when Ayton is out.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
Knickfan1982
- Lead Assistant
- Posts: 5,918
- And1: 2,185
- Joined: Mar 19, 2016
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
Dom801e wrote:NY trades #8 and Robinson for #1 and Looney.
Robinson plus #8 has been rumored for both #1 and #2. Min seems to want a bit more; NY does not seem to want to deal Robinson unless they are sure their guy is there. So #2 is a no go unless it is draft night. This deal rectifies that. They also get a vet replacement C on an expiring inexpensive deal.
If I have said it once I have said it a thousand times. Trading Robinson to move up is pointless and counter productive. We fill one hole with either Edwards or Ball but then open up another one by trading Robinson. Just no point.
Why rely on nuance, facts and logic when you can bludgeon the other side with mindless repetition of "Duuur McDaniel's has potential
and still be treated as if you were reasonable.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
shrink
- RealGM
- Posts: 59,422
- And1: 19,473
- Joined: Sep 26, 2005
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
Dom801e wrote:MIN trades #1 and James Johnson for #2.
The Wolves move a contract for future flexibility and retain a top 2 pick. They likely would be looking to package it in the future.
There are a couple reasons why this won’t work for MIN.
First, turning Johnson into a TPE removes the chances for salary matching many very good players that don’t fit in a $16 mil TPE, like Aaron Gordon, Oladipo, Myles Turner. That’s why GSW wants him. Johnson isn’t worth $16 mil, but he’s also MIN’s best piece for salary matching. He has also been better on and off the court than expected,
Second, while 1 and 2 may be in the same tier, being able to make the first choice is a big deal. It carries more weight because if you have the first choice, you get to pick any guy that may erupt in pre-draft workouts. More importantly, the #1 pick guarantees you get the guy you want, and with MIN willing to trade the pick at #1, any #2 pick carries a lot of risk.
The concept is good, but if the Knicks were to offer a legitimate package for #2, MIN would cut out GSW. IMHO, the Knicks package doesn’t get it done, because of the upside limits on both Robinson and the #8.
Sign5 wrote:Yea not happening, I expected a better retort but what do I expect from realgm(ers) in 2025. Just quote and state things that lack context, then repeat the same thing over and over as if something new and profound was said. Just lol.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
SmokeyPaw
- Starter
- Posts: 2,207
- And1: 1,163
- Joined: May 14, 2016
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
Sorry but this is terrible for the wolves. No way the wolves trading down to dump Johnson. He's both a useful player and an expiring contract for trade puposes.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
wolves_89
- General Manager
- Posts: 8,130
- And1: 4,616
- Joined: Jul 10, 2012
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
No chance the Wolves pay to dump Johnson. This is a non-starter for Minnesota.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
jscott
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,062
- And1: 1,356
- Joined: Oct 14, 2004
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
WTF is this for the Wolves? 1 for 2?
Jesus..
Jesus..
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
killmongrel
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,079
- And1: 1,331
- Joined: Sep 18, 2018
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
If the Warriors wanted no part of this deal. What would it take for them to just get Oubre with their TPE? A future 1st? He's a 1 year rental.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
- eminence
- RealGM
- Posts: 17,144
- And1: 11,946
- Joined: Mar 07, 2015
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
I think GS would prefer Robinson over Oubre. MIN seems unnecessary. Just 2/?? for 8/Robinson makes some sense, though a bit short on value for the Knicks.
I bought a boat.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
Crives
- General Manager
- Posts: 9,127
- And1: 7,464
- Joined: Feb 21, 2014
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
killmongrel wrote:If the Warriors wanted no part of this deal. What would it take for them to just get Oubre with their TPE? A future 1st? He's a 1 year rental.
If Phx has big FA plans maybe a future GS 1st.. otherwise phx is going to value Oubre much more then a 1 year rental.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
- FutureKnicksGM
- Head Coach
- Posts: 6,933
- And1: 1,505
- Joined: Sep 26, 2005
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
Trading up with Mitch is DOA for NY.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
-
Commodor
- Analyst
- Posts: 3,201
- And1: 959
- Joined: Jul 24, 2008
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
Dom801e wrote:NY trades #8 and Robinson for #1 and Looney.
Robinson plus #8 has been rumored for both #1 and #2. Min seems to want a bit more; NY does not seem to want to deal Robinson unless they are sure their guy is there. So #2 is a no go unless it is draft night. This deal rectifies that. They also get a vet replacement C on an expiring inexpensive deal.
Min trades #1 and James Johnson for #2.
The Wolves move a contract for future flexibility and retain a top 2 pick. They likely would be looking to package it in the future.
GS trades #2 and Looney for Oubre and #8.
There have been talks of Oubre +#10 for #2. This iteration improves upon this a bit. Taking on Oubre is expensive given tax implications so moving Looney relieves a bit of that as his health may lead them to move on from him anyway.
Pho trades Oubre for Johnson and Robinson
Oubre seems to be the odd man out long term for the Suns. Here they replace him in the rotation with a tough, defensively versatile wing in Johnson. He fits what they do and is also a FA, but he would be much more easier to keep for a couple more years. They also add Robinson, who would give them a different look than Ayton. He would fit nicely in the rotation and could spot start on nights when Ayton is out.
I like it but can we add a few of our 2nds or 21 FRP And just take Robinson too?
Phoenix may value picks more than a back up to Ayton.
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
- Reign23
- RealGM
- Posts: 11,728
- And1: 12,524
- Joined: Dec 29, 2014
- Location: Germany.
-
Re: #1 to NY w/GS and Pho
yeah i wouldn't move #8 + Mitch for no pick in this draft.
formerly known as knickst4pe
Return to Trades and Transactions


