Who's First Team All-NBA?

[Old School]

I think most reasonable fans would agree:

PG: Chris Paul
SG: Kobe
SF: LeBron
PF:
C: Dwight Howard

But who's the PF Duncan (the proven better player) or KG (the biggest difference maker)

[LiquidFire]

PG: Chris Paul
SG: Kobe
SF: butler
PF: Jamison
C: Dwight Howard

Lebrons overrated

[Old School]

PG: Chris Paul
SG: Kobe
SF: butler
PF: Jamison
C: Dwight Howard

Lebrons overrated

Looks like I smoked out the first unreasonable fan. Butler and Jamison's mother wouldn't pick them over LeBron or Duncan/KG.

[C'mon Cavs]

PG: Chris Paul
SG: Kobe
SF: butler
PF: Jamison
C: Dwight Howard

Lebrons overrated

I might pick Stevenson over Kobe, but the rest looks fine.

[Reks]

G:Paul
G:Kobe
F:Lebron
F:Garnett(should be Duncan)
C:Howard

[Old School]

-= original quote snipped =-



I might pick Stevenson over Kobe, but the rest looks fine.

If you're serious, I can only hope you're eyesight gets better.

[purp8gldvanessa]

duncan, who's proven more than garnett has.

[carrottop12]

Paul
Kobe
LeBron
Garnett
Howard

It has as more to do with the Celtics record then it does with it being Garnett.

[sp6r=underrated]

I doubt it will be close for the first team. It shouldn't, based on their play this year: Paul, Bryant, Lebron, Garnett, and Howard are the clear first team.

[TheKingOfVa360]

KG has to get this spot

[TheSheriff]

It is clearly:

KG (first off the NBA does not differentiate betwixt the PF and SF on the ward teams)
Howard
Lebron
Paul
Kobe

The second is where the debate should be.

[G35]

Well Duncan vs KG

PPG

Duncan 19.3
KG 18.8

Rebounds

Duncan 11.3
KG 9.2


Blocks

Duncan 2.0
KG 1.3


Assists

Duncan 2.8
KG 3.4


Steals

Duncan .7
KG 1.4


FG%

Duncan 49.7
KG 53.9


These two are fairly even. I'm thinking Amare should get it based on statistical performance......

[yiskobesogood]

lol you guys are insane. KG couldnt even get first team all nba when he put up 24 ppg. this has Amare written all over it.

First team all nba

Kobe
Paul
Howard
Amare
Lebron

[TMACFORMVP]

I think KG will have to make the 1st team, like mentioned earlier moreso with the Celtics rather than himself.

CP3
Kobe
Bron
KG
Howard

[Basti]

lol you guys are insane. KG couldnt even get first team all nba when he put up 24 ppg. this has Amare written all over it.

First team all nba

Kobe
Paul
Howard
Amare
Lebron

umm what about impact?

[purp8gldvanessa]

i wouldn't put amare in the league of duncan and kg. Amare's atrocious defense is enough reason to leave him out no matter how much he scores.

[Old School]

Well Duncan vs KG
These two are fairly even. I'm thinking Amare should get it based on statistical performance......

You're right Amare's performance is why the Suns are up 3-0 over Timmy's team ... oops.

Stats are only an indicator of performance, not performance itself.

[Albanian Damien]

If the first team isn't

Paul
Bryant
LeBron
KG
Dwight

Then I will go sneak away to New Jersey and go hide in a bomb shelter because everything I was taught to be true in this world has been proven false.

[pballa]

i wouldn't put amare in the league of duncan and kg. Amare's atrocious defense is enough reason to leave him out no matter how much he scores.

bingo

[G35]

-= original quote snipped =-



You're right Amare's performance is why the Suns are up 3-0 over Timmy's team ... oops.

Stats are only an indicator of performance, not performance itself.

Disagree. This isn't the MVP voting where you are taking in intangibles. Otherwise how did Amare get 1st team last year. If you talk about impact you have to account for KG playing in only 71 games this year.

Stoudamire outclasses KG/Duncan in just about every major statistical category. If you want to base it on impact or (perception) then just fill out KG/Duncan/Kobe/Lebron 1st team every year.

We'll just argue over who gets to be the PG.......