Would you trade Vladdy for Tatis Jr?

[Raptors Realtor]

Assuming neither the Jays or Padres win the World Series this season, and both teams are looking for a shakeup in the offseason... Is this a trade you'd consider?

[LBJKB24MJ23]

maybe?

[s e n s i]

there are 3 other Jr's in the league i would trade vladdy for in a heartbeat, tatis Jr. being one of them

[Asianiac_24]

In a heart beat

[Raps in 4]

Yes.

His offence is way down this year too (pretty much identical production to Vladdy). Not sure if it's because he had to stop roiding or because of the time off. Obviously he gives you elite defence at a more premium position though, so he'll always have more value than Vladdy. Tatis is worth 4.4 fWAR this year to Vladdy's 0.5, despite both of them swinging a mediocre bat all season.

Having said that, he wouldn't help us immediately as this team can't hit.

[Randle McMurphy]

Of course

[dagger]

Yes.

His offence is way down this year too (pretty much identical production to Vladdy). Not sure if it's because he had to stop roiding or because of the time off. Obviously he gives you elite defence at a more premium position though, so he'll always have more value than Vladdy. Tatis is worth 4.4 fWAR this year to Vladdy's 0.5, despite both of them swinging a mediocre bat all season.

Having said that, he wouldn't help us immediately as this team can't hit.

We have a lot of internal options for 1B, we could realize acceptable production and defence from a platoon if necessary. We have no low cost options for an elite LF hitter, so yes


Sent from my iPhone using RealGM Forums

[Madvillainy2004]

In a heartbeat

[bluerap23]

Pretty irrelevant because it would never happen. I am extremely interested to see what happens with Vlad's contract this off-season

[greekman]

tatis jr, juan soto for chapman, manoah, kirk, biggio, prospects

bichette
tatis jr
guerrero
soto
springer
who cares
who cares