j4remi wrote:Pharmcat wrote:
idzik was in way over his head . he is a cap guy not a talent evaluator/gm
2 of his signings turned out to be flops before season started: that goodwin rb who got arrested, the CB who didnt even bother to show up to the games
the draft with the best WR ever he misses on all of them despite having 12 total picks
he totally missed the CB position considering Ryan needs strong CB to run his schemes
Yeah it's nuts, took three WR's and whiffed on 'em all. The MacDougal pick might still work out but I don't have much faith at all. The Harvin trade looked good to me until I heard about the cap implications. He couldn't sign Rodgers-Cromartie, let Cromartie walk and never took a second look at Revis...imagine our defense with Revis in place, it would have made a big difference. Having an overload of Strong Safety's and no true FS was just dumb.
Then you get the Giacomini head scratcher and take a look at the state of our O-line...this dude really made some odd decisions. Even drafting Pryor was a head scratcher and I like the kid and his potential but when you have the many needs we did...it's a weird pick to throw at a non-need.
Using a baseball analogy, Idzik basically when 0 for 7 with 4 strikeouts and hitting into 3 double plays. It wan't just that he couldn't do diddly in the draft, he had 12 picks (5 more picks than most teams) and whiffed on pretty much all of them. Then he sat around slowly low balling or ignoring free agents that might of helped thinking somehow that they would come begging? and got left holding his own flaccid pecker in his hands.