Anyone interested in judging the Be the GM Teams?

ZarcMumoff · Post #1 » by **ZarcMumoff** » Mon May 30, 2011 1:41 am

Decided to make a separate thread so it's a bit cleaner.

If you haven't seen the 220+ page thread, that is the Be the GM thread. Basically, it's about 25 of us drafting players to fill out a team. Kind of like a fantasy draft, except not so much about stats as it is about just getting good overall players.

What I'm asking a few of you to do is judge these teams. The GMs will do a write-up on their team. Talking about the players, how they fit, what type of team they are...basically selling you on their team. The GMs will be posting these in another thread (Which we shall call "Be the GM Judging Thread").

When will all this take place? Well, from June 3rd-June 5th teams will be posting their write up in the Judging thread. On June 6th and June 7th, that is when you *the judge(s)* will be judging the team. What will you be judging them on?

Championship Contending (Can they win a title?) 30 points
Future (positioned to attain or sustain success over the next 5 years) 15 points
Roster Management (Did they build a smart team that fits together?) 5 points
Total Points=50 points

After judging the teams based off that, give your Top 8 teams from each conference (from the championship contending category, not overall).

I understand this is going to take a good amount of work, but we have put in 2 or 3 weeks of work for this. I know there are some smart people on this board, and hopefully you'll help sharing your knowledge by judging our teams.

If you have any questions, let me know. If you want to judge, let me know in this thread.

Kobblehead · Post #2 » by **Kobblehead** » Mon May 30, 2011 1:55 am

Are you accepting people in the league as judges?

ZarcMumoff · Post #3 » by **ZarcMumoff** » Mon May 30, 2011 2:01 am

Kobblehead wrote:Are you accepting people in the league as judges?

No. Well, preferably not. If we can get 3-5 non-Be the GM guys, that would be ideal.

I'm still thinking how we would do the judging if we can't get some non- guys to judge. Whether we would just do it the same way, or whatnot.

Kobblehead · Post #4 » by **Kobblehead** » Mon May 30, 2011 2:23 am

Alot of the opinions I value happen to be of users than own teams in this. I mean worst comes to worst, you can just accept 5 judges from each conference to analyze their opposite conference.

That way you have unbiased opinions and you get analysis from people who are committed to the league.

ZarcMumoff · Post #5 » by **ZarcMumoff** » Mon May 30, 2011 2:32 am

Kobblehead wrote:Alot of the opinions I value happen to be of users than own teams in this. I mean worst comes to worst, you can just accept 5 judges from each conference to analyze their opposite conference.

That way you have unbiased opinions and you get analysis from people who are committed to the league.

Smarter than me. That's a good idea. Except I'd probably do only 3 judges.

Still...I would like some non-Be the GM guys. Obviously, they would need to be guys who post around here a lot...board regulars.

Post #6 » by **tk76** » Mon May 30, 2011 3:49 am

You might ask some of the mods at other boards or at the general board?

76ciology · Post #7 » by **76ciology** » Mon May 30, 2011 3:54 am

or simply just let Dabods decide everything. hahaha

51X3RF4N · Post #8 » by **51X3RF4N** » Mon May 30, 2011 2:01 pm

I'm in on this if you'd let me. I love analysis and I'm interested to see what kind of teams were built!

Post #9 » by **tk76** » Mon May 30, 2011 3:12 pm

Any interest in me asking Brian Ward? He runs Depressedfan.com, one of the best Sixer blogs out there. He really knows his stuff and would really put in the time to be a good judge. I could also ask some of the people who run Libertyballers (like DBodner) if we need more judges. We could also ask Tom Moore.

Having Sixer Bloggers and journalists be the judges would be like having a celebrity panel (think American Idol). especially if we ask Mike Levin at Libertyballers.com.

51X3RF4N · Post #10 » by **51X3RF4N** » Mon May 30, 2011 3:21 pm

So tk76, does that mean I'm not in?

Post #11 » by **tk76** » Mon May 30, 2011 3:24 pm

This is PK5's show. he makes the decisions. As far as I'm concerned you should be on the panel.

51X3RF4N · Post #12 » by **51X3RF4N** » Mon May 30, 2011 3:28 pm

Cool. Well hopefully he feels the same.

ZarcMumoff · Post #13 » by **ZarcMumoff** » Mon May 30, 2011 4:02 pm

51X3RF4N...you're a board regular so you're definitely in.

My E-Mail is pjxn23 if you have any questions, or you can just post them here.

Really appreciate it...mucho gracias.

tk76...yeah, ask all the bloggers.

51X3RF4N · Post #14 » by **51X3RF4N** » Mon May 30, 2011 7:22 pm

Awesome! This will be fun!

Post #15 » by **tk76** » Mon May 30, 2011 7:44 pm

I sent an email to Kate Fagan, Tom Moore and the Bloggers at Depresedfan, Libertyballers and Recliner GM.

There are some very good posters at those sites who are not bloggers who I'm sure would make great judges, but we should probably wait and see if we get a good panel from this list. The other person I'm going to ask is Howard mass, who runs things here.

ZarcMumoff · Post #16 » by **ZarcMumoff** » Mon May 30, 2011 9:41 pm

tk76 wrote:I sent an email to Kate Fagan, Tom Moore and the Bloggers at Depresedfan, Libertyballers and Recliner GM.

There are some very good posters at those sites who are not bloggers who I'm sure would make great judges, but we should probably wait and see if we get a good panel from this list. The other person I'm going to ask is Howard mass, who runs things here.

Sounds excellent. Thanks for the help, tk.

Still...anyone here is more than welcomed to help.

Post #17 » by **tk76** » Mon May 30, 2011 9:52 pm

Brian, who runs Depressed Fan, is in as a judge.

ZarcMumoff · Post #18 » by **ZarcMumoff** » Mon May 30, 2011 10:43 pm

Woo! Great job, tk!

PK5 wrote:Be The GM Judges
51X3RF4N
Brian Ward

83SixersRocked · Post #19 » by **83SixersRocked** » Tue May 31, 2011 1:39 pm

It looks like you may have a pretty good cast of judges. If you decide you want another, just holler. I'd definitely be up for it.

Post #20 » by **tk76** » Tue May 31, 2011 2:15 pm

83SixersRocked, the more realGM posters we get as judges the better.